Southtowns Record

ZBA 10.28.26 Agenda Packet (full text)

Town of West Seneca Zoning Board of Appeals Oct 28, 2026, 6:00 p.m. 132 pages

Page 1

WEST SENECA ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1300 Union Road, West Seneca, NY 14224 6:00 PM in the Community Center October 28, 2026 AGENDA Meeting # 2026-10 CALL TO ORDER OPENING OF PUBLIC HEARING APPROVAL OF PROOFS OF PUBLICATION APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. Minutes of Meeting #2026-09 OLD BUSINESS NEW BUSINESS 2026-041 Request of Julie Slisz for property located at 33 Florence Ave to allow for construction of patio roof with 6' separation from existing roof off of house. (10' separation is required) 2026-042 Request of Thomas Fitzgerald for property located at 89 Thorndale Ave to allow for construction of an enclosed porch in front with 18' front setback. (30' setback required) 2026-043 Request of Emily Kawa for property located at 30 Woodcrest Dr. to allow for expansion of driveway 0' to lot line. (3' separation required) 2026-044 Request of Patricia and Kevin Engleka for property located at 168 Charlescrest Ct. to allow for the installation of a pool with 7' separation to deck/house. (10' separation required) 2026-045 Request of Jeffrey Stange for property located at 95 Thomas Dr. to allow a variance to erect a 6' fence in the front/side yard and with a 16' projection past house. (maximum 4' height allowed in the front/side yard and no projection allowed) 2026-046 Page 1 of 132

Page 2

Request of Jason Havens for property located at 4350 Seneca St. to allow for construction of an addition with 5' side yard setback. (25' side yard setback required) 2026-047 Request of Debbie Wolcott for property located at 182 Tampa Dr. to allow construction of a patio roof off of house with a 6.5' separation from detached garage. (10' separation required) 2026-048 Request of Lawrence Monaco for property located at 94 Villa Maria Road to allow the installation of a generator 2' from lot line. (5' setback required) 2026-049 Request of Stan Sajecki for property located at 238 Schultz Road to allow the construction of a new single family home with 38.79 front setback. (40' front setback required) 2026-050 Request of Jason Zurek and Bonnie Sullivan for property located at 162 Tampa Drive to allow construction of a covered front patio roof with 25' front yard setback. (30' setback required) 2026-051 Request of Ari Goldberg with Barclay Damon LLC for interpretation of the proposed use for property located at 1100 Southwestern Blvd. ADJOURN Future meetings are held the fourth Wednesday of the month at 6:00 pm Page 2 of 132

Page 3

WEST SENECA ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 1300 Union Road, West Seneca, NY 14224 6:00 PM in the Community Center September 23, 2026 September 23, 2026, Draft Meeting Minutes Start Time: 6:00 PM Roll Call  Chairperson Stephen Stachowski  Zoning Board Member Joette Tronolone  Zoning Board Member Amelia Greenan  Zoning Board Member Edmund Bedient  Zoning Board Member Paul Lang: Absent (Excused)  ZBA Counsel Joseph Trapp  Code Enforcement Representative Doug Busse Opening of Public Hearing  Motioned by: Tronolone  Seconded by: Greenan to open the Public Hearing.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Approval of Proofs of Publication  Motioned by: Greenan, and  Seconded by: Bedient to approve proofs of publication.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Approval of Minutes from previous meeting  Motioned by: Tronolone  Seconded by: Bedient for approval of the August 2026 Minutes.  A correction was made to change an agenda item number under Old Business from 2026- 029 to 2026-22 for 29 Class Avenue. The motion was amended to include this correction.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried as amended. Page 3 of 132

Page 4

OLD BUSINESS There was no old business to discuss. NEW BUSINESS Agenda Item 2026-038: 91 Circle End Drive The applicant's representative, contractor Pearson Wing, requested a height variance for a new detached garage. The original garage was dilapidated and non-compliant, located one foot from the property line. The new garage is being built 10 feet from the house and three feet from the property line to meet code. However, a significant dip in the property's grade causes the rear of the new garage to exceed the height limit. Signatures of support were provided from all adjacent neighbors, and Erie County had no objections. AREA Variance Balancing Test 1. Will an undesirable change be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties? No. Replacing a dilapidated structure with a new, mostly compliant one is an improvement. The applicant provided letters of support from neighbors. 2. Can the benefit sought by the applicant be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance? No. The applicant explored other placements, but they would either create drainage issues for neighbors or be unsafe due to the steep grade. This location is the best option. 3. Is the requested area variance substantial? No. The request is modest, with only the rear portion of the garage exceeding the height limit by approximately two feet. 4. Will the proposed variance have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district? No. Any potential drainage or environmental issues will be addressed during the standard inspection process. The slight height increase is not expected to affect neighbor sight lines. 5. Was the alleged difficulty self-created? Partially. While the applicant chose to build the garage, the difficulty is primarily caused by the property's natural topography, which is not the applicant's fault. The contractor acted in good faith by stopping work when the issue was discovered.  Motioned by: Greenan  Seconded by: Tronolone for approval.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Page 4 of 132

Page 5

Agenda Item 2026-039: 1151 Center Road The applicant, property owner Kevin Smith, requested a variance to install a six-foot privacy fence that extends 13 feet past the rear of the house into the side yard. Town code requires fences in the side yard to be no more than four feet tall. The purpose is to provide privacy and screen a new gas generator from view. The applicant provided signatures of support from neighboring properties, and Erie County offered no objection. AREA Variance Balancing Test 1. Will an undesirable change be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties? No. Fences are common, and this one will improve curb appeal by hiding a generator and providing privacy. 2. Can the benefit sought by the applicant be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance? No. A compliant four-foot fence would not provide the desired level of privacy or effectively screen the generator. 3. Is the requested area variance substantial? No. The increase from a four-foot to a six- foot fence is not considered substantial. 4. Will the proposed variance have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district? No. The professionally installed fence will not have any adverse physical or environmental impact. 5. Was the alleged difficulty self-created? Yes, but this was not the determining factor in the board's decision.  Motioned by: Tronolone  Seconded by: Greenan for approval.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Agenda Item 2026-040: 111 Summit Avenue Mark Filipski, representing his daughter (the homeowner), requested a variance for a six-foot privacy fence on a corner lot. The proposed fence would extend 40 feet along the side yard, connecting to an existing fence. The purpose is to create privacy. The fence will match the neighbor's existing fence. Letters of support were provided from multiple neighbors. AREA Variance Balancing Test 1. Will an undesirable change be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties? No. With letters of support from neighbors, the board viewed the fence as an improvement to the property's appearance. 2. Can the benefit sought by the applicant be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance? No. Alternatives like shrubbery would require more maintenance and might not provide the same level of privacy or aesthetic appeal. Page 5 of 132

Page 6

3. Is the requested area variance substantial? No. The request for a fence is not considered substantial. 4. Will the proposed variance have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district? No. The fence is seen as a visual improvement with no negative environmental effects. 5. Was the alleged difficulty self-created? No. The difficulty arises from the property being a corner lot, a pre-existing condition not created by the homeowner.  Motioned by: Bedient  Seconded by: Stachowski for approval.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Other Business  Chairperson Stachowski reminded the board to complete their annual training.  The board discussed improving the variance application form, potentially modeling it after the City of Buffalo's form, which asks applicants to address the area variance test questions directly.  A discussion was held regarding clarifying the meeting schedule on future agendas. The board typically meets on the fourth Wednesday of the month, but there is no meeting in November, and the December meeting is on the first Wednesday. The board secretary and counsel agreed to ensure the public schedule is clear on the website and in official notices. Adjournment  Motioned by: Bedient  Seconded by Greenan to close the Public Hearing.  Vote: Ayes: 4, Noes: 0. The motion carried.  The meeting was adjourned. End Time: 6:29 PM Page 6 of 132

Page 7

Page 7 of 132

Page 8

Page 8 of 132

Page 9

Page 9 of 132

Page 10

Page 10 of 132

Page 11

Page 11 of 132

Page 12

Page 12 of 132

Page 13

Page 13 of 132

Page 14

Page 14 of 132

Page 15

Page 15 of 132

Page 16

Page 16 of 132

Page 17

Page 17 of 132

Page 18

Page 18 of 132

Page 19

Page 19 of 132

Page 20

Page 20 of 132

Page 21

Page 21 of 132

Page 22

Page 22 of 132

Page 23

Page 23 of 132

Page 24

Page 24 of 132

Page 25

Page 25 of 132

Page 26

Page 26 of 132

Page 27

Page 27 of 132

Page 28

Page 28 of 132

Page 29

Page 29 of 132

Page 30

Page 30 of 132

Page 31

Page 31 of 132

Page 32

Page 32 of 132

Page 33

Page 33 of 132

Page 34

Page 34 of 132

Page 35

Page 35 of 132

Page 36

Page 36 of 132

Page 37

Page 37 of 132

Page 38

Page 38 of 132

Page 39

Page 39 of 132

Page 40

Page 40 of 132

Page 41

Page 41 of 132

Page 42

Page 42 of 132

Page 43

Page 43 of 132

Page 44

Page 44 of 132

Page 45

Page 45 of 132

Page 46

Page 46 of 132

Page 47

Page 47 of 132

Page 48

Page 48 of 132

Page 49

Page 49 of 132

Page 50

Page 50 of 132

Page 51

Page 51 of 132

Page 52

Page 52 of 132

Page 53

Page 53 of 132

Page 54

Page 54 of 132

Page 55

Page 55 of 132

Page 56

Page 56 of 132

Page 57

Page 57 of 132

Page 58

Page 58 of 132

Page 59

Page 59 of 132

Page 60

Page 60 of 132

Page 61

Page 61 of 132

Page 62

Page 62 of 132

Page 63

Page 63 of 132

Page 64

Page 64 of 132

Page 65

Page 65 of 132

Page 66

Page 66 of 132

Page 67

Page 67 of 132

Page 68

Page 68 of 132

Page 69

Page 69 of 132

Page 70

Page 70 of 132

Page 71

Page 71 of 132

Page 72

Page 72 of 132

Page 73

Page 73 of 132

Page 74

Page 74 of 132

Page 75

Page 75 of 132

Page 76

Page 76 of 132

Page 77

Page 77 of 132

Page 78

Page 78 of 132

Page 79

Page 79 of 132

Page 80

Page 80 of 132

Page 81

Page 81 of 132

Page 82

Page 82 of 132

Page 83

Page 83 of 132

Page 84

Page 84 of 132

Page 85

Page 85 of 132

Page 86

Page 86 of 132

Page 87

Page 87 of 132

Page 88

Page 88 of 132

Page 89

Page 89 of 132

Page 90

Page 90 of 132

Page 91

Page 91 of 132

Page 92

Page 92 of 132

Page 93

Page 93 of 132

Page 94

Page 94 of 132

Page 95

Page 95 of 132

Page 96

Page 96 of 132

Page 97

Page 97 of 132

Page 98

Page 98 of 132

Page 99

Page 99 of 132

Page 100

Page 100 of 132

Page 101

Page 101 of 132

Page 102

Page 102 of 132

Page 103

Page 103 of 132

Page 104

Page 104 of 132

Page 105

Page 105 of 132

Page 106

Page 106 of 132

Page 107

Page 107 of 132

Page 108

Page 108 of 132

Page 109

Page 109 of 132

Page 110

Page 110 of 132

Page 111

Page 111 of 132

Page 112

Page 112 of 132

Page 113

Page 113 of 132

Page 114

Page 114 of 132

Page 115

Page 115 of 132

Page 116

Page 116 of 132

Page 117

Page 117 of 132

Page 118

Page 118 of 132

Page 119

Page 119 of 132

Page 120

Page 120 of 132

Page 121

Page 121 of 132

Page 122

Page 122 of 132

Page 123

Page 123 of 132

Page 124

Page 124 of 132

Page 125

Page 125 of 132

Page 126

Page 126 of 132

Page 127

Page 127 of 132

Page 128

Page 128 of 132

Page 129

Page 129 of 132

Page 130

Page 130 of 132

Page 131

Page 131 of 132

Page 132

Page 132 of 132

Back to the document