City Council minutes — October 19, 2026 (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
Regular Council Meeting
Monday, October 19, 2026
Council Chambers
6:30 p.m. Caucus — Meeting will immediately follow the Caucus
Live via Facebook @ http//facebook.com/lackawannany/
Meeting Called to Order/Pledge of Allegiance.
NB: Meeting being recorded.
Rolt Call; Couneil: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Dept. Heads: Law, Development & Marketing, Public Works (E), Public Safety,
Comptroller, Recreation (E)
Hearings from Citizens:
Approval of Minutes: of the Regular Meeting of October 5, 2026 as written.
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to adopt the minutes of the regular meeting of October 5, 2026
as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano Carried 5-0
Departmental Reports:
1. City Comptroller — A/P Checking Listing #7, dated 10/5/2026.
2. City Clerk’s Office — Monthly Report, dated 9/1/2026 — 9/30/2026.
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to receive and file Departmental Reports one and two.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano Carried 5-0
Communications from the Council:
Council Member Muflahi requests a discussion regarding the current status of the City Council’s vote
to adopt NYS Veterans Property Tax Exemption RPTL 458-a(11).
3. Amira Muflahi
Re. October 5, 2026 Council Action, Letter to Council regarding RPTL 458-a(11) Implementation
Good Afternoon Colleagues,
A full week has passed with no comment from the Council or Mayor. What direction are we
heading in? Are we going to prolong the inevitable? A public hearing was never mentioned or advised
until our October 5 meeting. | have posed questions to Christy and Michael Milks, with no follow up
responses, even until now.
City Clerk, Grace, please put this back on the agenda for our upcoming meeting. The agenda
item can be listed as the following:
Councilmember, Amira Muflahi, would like to discuss the current status of the City Council’s vote to
adopt New York State Veterans Property Tax Exemption RPTL 458-a(11).
AMIRA MUFLAHI, 1: WARD COUNCIL MEMBER
Page 2
Attached is an analysis of the actions taken by council on October
5, 2026. An additional report and
guidance will follow. At this time, | believe it is feasible for the
Council to comply with the public hearing
requirement and to properly enact a local law implementing
the RPTL 458-a(11) before the December 1st
status date. My report will address the timeline for each step
CHRISTY COOPER, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY
RE. Council Action 10/5/26
item #4 motion for adoption of RPTL §458-a(11)
Dear Council President Marrano, Honorable City Council;
| have reviewed the action of the City Council taken on 10/5/26
with respect to the motion
Councilperson Muflahi and the adoption of the Real Property
Tax Law (RPTL) Section 458-a(11). It is in
the position of the Law Department that the action is ineffect
ive to implement the Veterans’ Alternative
Exemption of RPTL §458-a(11) and that a local law, with public hearing,
is required to modify the current
tax exemption and expand the City’s Veterans’ Tax Exemption.
ANALYSIS:
The prior Veterans’ Exemption, codified under City Code Chapter
201 was adopted by local law.
A local law is therefore required to amend the prior local iaw
and expand the City’s application of RPTL
§458-a(11) from only those prior provisions enumerated to the prior
provisions plus section 11. (see
1982 Op. State Comp. No. 82-35, 1984 Op. State Comp. No.84-2
6 and 1998 Op. State Comp. No, 98-22),
As the Council is aware, RPTL §458-a(11) may be adopted at local-op
tion by, “local law or
resolution.” (See RPTL 458 a(11)) Councilperson Muflahi “moved”
to adopt the tax exemption. The
language recorded by the City Clerk was as follows, "I move that
the City of Lackawanna adopt the full
real property tax exemption authorized under New York Real Property
Tax Law §458-a(12) for qualifying
permanently and totally service-disabled veterans." (See Cert Packet
10.5.26) State law does not define
a “motion” but in practical terms, a motion is less formal than a resoluti
on. (NYCOM Handbook for City
Officials (Dec. 2025) Ch. 5).
The action also does not satisfy the requirements of a local law. The
City Charter directs that,
“all local laws shail be introduced, considered and enacted in accordan
ce with the procedure prescribed
in the Municipal Home Rule Law. Notice of a public hearing on local
laws shall be given by publication
once in the official newspaper at least five days prior to such hearing.”
(Lackawanna City Charter Ch. 3
§3.10(B)).
In addition to the form prescribed by the City Charter §3.9, MHR
§20(4) requires that a local law
be in its final form and distributed to council members, if by email,
for a period of no less that 10 days
exclusive of Sundays. The local law must be in its final form before a public
hearing. (Op. Atty. Gen. No.
78-243, Op, State Comp. No 81-124) The text was not distribu
ted in a form or fashion to satisfy this
requirement.
Since the Council’s actions do not satisfy the requirements for
a local law or a resolution, the
action is Ineffective to implement the section of law.
POTENTIAL REMEDY:
A draft text of the law will be submitted for council’s review along
with the documentation previously
requested from Assessor Michael Milks, as soon as possible but no later
that the deadline for agenda
Page 3
items to be placed for the next council meeting. The wording of the original
motion will be made clearer
and more precise to accomplish the implementation, should council choose
to do so. The terms “full real
property tax exemption” and “service-disabled” are ambiguous, and/or do not
match the terminology of
the statute, and will be amended.
Council may act to schedule a public hearing on the matter. The public hearing
must be held
before the adoption of the law. The hearing cannot be scheduled prior to
the law’s distribution in its
“final form.” Proper notice of the hearing must be made at least 5 days prior
to the hearing date.
Additional and specific guidance will follow along with a draft of the law
and the Assessor’s report.
if any councilperson has questions with respect to the specific language of the
draft local law or
procedure, please address them to the Law Department and | will be sure to include
information in the
report to council.
CHRISTY COOPER, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY
Moved by Anderson second by Meegan to receive and file.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Communications from Division/Department Heads:
Senior Foreman, Public Works requests the City Council approve the bid from
Frey Electric for the
Senior Center Improvement Project and the ordinance for this CDBG Grant.
Frey was the only bid
received. The amount of the bid was $145,473. This project is funded through
the Community Block
Grant program.
4, To: Honorable Members of the Lackawanna City Council
From: Dan Geercken, Senior Foreman of Public Works
Re: Bid Approval — Senior Center Improvements Project (2026 CDBG)
Dear Honorable Council Members:
! respectfully request that the Lackawanna City Council approve the bid submitted
by Frey
Electric for the Senior Center improvements Project, funded through the Communit
y Development Block
Grant (CDBG) program.
Frey Electric submitted a bid in the amount of $145,473.00, This was the only bid received
for
the project.
DANIEL GEERCKEN, SENIOR FOREMAN OF PUBLIC WORKS
Moved by Anderson second by Surdyke to receive and file, act on ordinance.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
ORDINANCE
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2026-2027 BUDGET ORDINANCES ADOPTED
JUNE 9, 2026.
BE IT ENACTED by the City Council of the City of Lackawanna, New York, as
follows:
Page 4
GENERAL FUND
Section 1, That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance adopted June 9", 2026, is hereby amended
to
add the following Budget Code to the Capital Fund: H.2080.0622 — “Senior
Center
Upgrades/Repairs (CDBG).”
SECTION 2, That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to transfer
unappropriated
fund balance in the amount of $150,000.00 to the “Transfer to
Other Fund — Capital”
Budget Code [A.9000.9550].
CAPITAL FUND
SECTION 3. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to increase the “Capital
Fund
Inter Fund Transfers” Budget Code [H.0000.5031] by $150,000.00,
SECTION 4, That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to allocate budgeted
funds in
the amount of $150,000.00 to the H.2080.0622 — “Senior Center Upgrades
/Repairs
(CDBG).”
THIS ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATLEY.
DATED: October 20, 2026
Lackawanna, New York
Moved by Anderson second by Surdyke to adopt ordinance as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Senior Foreman, Public Works requests the City Council approve the
ordinance to transfer funds
between budget lines.
5. Comptroller's Office
Dan Geercken ~ Senior Foreman
lam requesting that the Comptroller transfer funds in the amount of $5,237.5
0 from Budget
Line CL.8160.0443 (Repairs and Replacements) to Budget Line CL.8160.0202
(Garbage Totes),
DANIEL GEERCKEN, SENIOR FOREMAN OF PUBLIC WORKS
Moved by Anderson second by Meegan to receive and file, act on ordinance.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
ORDINANCE
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2026-2027 BUDGET ORDINANCES ADOPTED
JUNE 9™, 2026.
BE IT ENACTED by the City Council of the City of Lackawanna, New
York, as follows:
SECTION 1. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance adopted June 9", 2026, is hereby
amended to
transfer budget appropriations between budget lines.
SECTION 2. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance adopted June 9, 2026, is hereby
amended to
decrease budget line CL.860.0443.0000 Special Revenue Fund Garbage and
Refuse —
Page 5
Repairs and Replacements by $5,237.50 and to increase budget
line CL.8160.0202.0000
Special Revenue Fund Garbage and Refuse - Garbage Totes
by $5,5237.50.
THIS ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
DATED: October 20, 2026
Lackawanna, New York
Moved by Anderson second by Meegan to adopt ordinance as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Director of Public Safety requests the City Council authorize the
sale of a 2020 Ford Police Interceptor.
Proceeds will be placed in the Police Dept. Operating Budget.
6. To: Lackawanna City Council
Attn: Council President Frederic Marrano
From: Dino Marrocco, Director of Public Safety
Subject: SALE OF POLICE DEPARTMENT VEHICLE
Honorable Council Members:
| respectfully request authorization to sell the following police vehicles:
* 2020 Ford Police Interceptor VIN# 1FM5K8ABSLGA84063
All proceeds from the sale of aforementioned vehicle will be placed
in the Lackawanna
Operating Budget Police Department account code A-3120-250,
DINO MARROCCO, DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC SAFETY
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to approve request.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Director of Purchasing requests the City Council enter into a 2-year
contract for electricity with Next
Era Energy Services and a 2-year contract with Mirabito Power
& Gas, LLC for gas and for Mayor to
sign both contracts.
7. Lackawanna City Council
Hon. FredericJ. Marrano, President
2838 South Park Ave.
Lackawanna, New York 14218
Re: Electricity and Gas
Hon, FredericJ. Marrano:
lam asking the City of Lackawanna to enter into a two-year contract
for electricity with Next Era
Energy Services with a fixed rate of $0.095/kWh for those two
years. | am also asking the Council to have
the Mayor sign into a two-year contract for gas with Mirabito Power
& Gas, LLC with a one year
$0.481/CCF fixed rate and a year two $0.508/CCF fixed rate. | have attached
the REP and pricing. For
electric, the City will be saving $0.004/kWH for the two years as
compared to current pricing. For gas,
the City will be saving $0.169/CCF in year one and $0.142/CCF in
year two as compared to current
Page 6
pricing. Both the electric and gas rates stated here are for usage and do not
include the delivery charges
imposed by National Grid or National Fuel, which will remain the going
rate.
THOMAS NICOMETO, DIRECTOR OF PURCHASING
A copy may be obtained in the City Clerk’s Office.
Moved by Anderson second by Surdyke to approve request and have
Mayor sign contracts.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Fire Chief Fino requests the City Council approve the ordinance
creating a budget line and advance
funds regarding the DASNY grant sponsored by Senator April Baskins
in the amount of $50,000. The
grant will be used to renovate the kitchen at Fire House #3 located
on South Park Avenue. The City will
be reimbursed once the work is complete.
8. Lackawanna City Council
Honorable Fred Marrano, President
2838 South Park Ave.
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Dear Council Members,
The Fire Department has been awarded a DASNY grant (#30031)
sponsored by Senator April
Baskins in the amount of $50,000. This grant will be used to renovate
the kitchen at Fire House #3 on
South Park Ave. The Grant Disbursement Agreement was executed
by DASNY on September 17, 2026. |
have inciuded a copy of the GDA for your review. This grant will
reimburse the city once the items are
purchased and the work is completed. | am requesting the creation
of a budget line, and advanced of
funds in the amount of $50,000 for the purchase of the items requested
in the grant application.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
JAMES J. FINO, FIRE CHIEF
A copy may be obtained in the City Clerk’s Office.
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to receive and file, act on ordinanc
e.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
ORDINANCE
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2026-2027 BUDGET ORDINANCES
ADOPTED JUNE 9%, 2026,
BE IT ENACTED by the City Council of the City of Lackawanna,
New York, as follows:
GENERAL FUND
SECTION 1. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance adopted June 9", 2026, is
hereby amended to
add the following Budget Code to the Capital Fund: H.2080.0626
— “Renovations to the
Firehouse #3 Kitchen (DASNY).”
GENERAL FUND
Page 7
SECTION 2. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended
to transfer unappropriated
fund balance in the amount of $50,000.00 to the “Transfer
to Other Fund — Capital”
Budget Code [A.9000.9500].
CAPITAL FUND
SECTION 3. That the 2026 — 2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended
to increase the “Capital
Fund Inter Fund Transfers” Budget Code [H.0000.5031] by
$50,000.00.
SECTION 4. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended
to allocated budgeted funds
in the amount of $50,000.00 to the H.2080.0626 — “Renova
tions to the Firehouse #3
Kitchen (DASNY)."
THIS ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
DATED: October 20, 2026
Lackawanna, New York
Moved by Anderson second by Meegan to adopt ordinance as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Fire Chief Fino requests the City Council approve the ordinance creating a budget line and advance
funds regarding a DASNY grant sponsored by Assembl man
John Rivera in the amount of $250,000.
The grant will be used to purchase new portable radios firehou
se gear lockers and install a water line
for a fire hydrant at the training tower. The grant will reimbur
se the City after the work is complete.
9. Lackawanna City Council
Honorable Fred Marrano, President
2838 South Park Ave.
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Dear Council Members,
The Fire Department has been awarded a DASNY Brant (#29394
) sponsored by Assemblyman
John Rivera in the amount of $250,000. This grant will purchas
e new portable radios, install a water line
and fire hydrant at the fire training tower, and purchase firehou
se gear lockers, The Grant Disbursement
Agreement was executed by DASNY on August 31, 2026. | have
included a copy of the GDA for your
review. This grant will reimburse the city once the items are
purchased and the work is completed. | am
requesting the creation of a budget line, and advanced of funds
in the amount of $250,000 for the
purchase of the items requested in the grant application.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me.
JAMES J. FINO, FIRE CHIEF
A copy may be obtained in the City Clerk’s Office.
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to receive and file, act
on ordinance.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Page 8
ORDINANCE
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 2026-2027 BUDGET ORDINANCES ADOPTED JUNE 974, 2026,
BE IN EBACTED by the City Council of the City of Lackawanna, New York,
as follows:
GENERAL FUND
SECTION 1. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance adopted June 9%, 2026,
is hereby amended to
add the following Budget Code to the Capital Fund: H.2080.0625
~ “Purchase
Emergency Equipment and Install Water Line and Hydrant (DASNY).”
GENERAL FUND
SECTION 2. That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to transfer unappropriated
fund balance in the amount of $250,000.00 to the “Transfer to Other
Fund ~ Capital”
Budget Code [A.9000.9550].
CAPITAL FUND
SECTION 3. That the 2026 ~ 2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to increase
the “Capital
Fund Inter Fund Transfers” Budget Code [H.0000.5031] by $250,000.00,
SECTION 4, That the 2026-2027 Budget Ordinance is hereby amended to allocat budgeted
funds in
the amount of $250,000.00 to the H.2080.0625 — “Purchase Emergency
Equipment and
Install Water Line and Hydrant (DASNY)."
THIS ORDINANCE SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY.
DATED: October 20, 2026
Lackawanna, New York
Moved by Anderson second by Muflahi to adopt ordinance as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Assistant City Attorney submits to the City Council Proposed Local
Law no. 1, 2026 — Alternative
Veterans’ Real Property Tax Exemption under RPTL§ 458-a(11); Assessor
’s Fiscal Impact Report and
implementation Procedures,
10. To: Council President Marrano and Honorable Members of the Lackawanna
City Council
From: City of Lackawanna Law Department
Date: October 15, 2026
Re: Proposed Local Law No. 1, 2026 — Alternative Veterans’ Real Property
Tax Exemption Under RPTL
§458-a(11); Assessor's Fiscal Impact Report and implementation Procedur
es
As indicated in my prior correspondence, and in advance of the October
15, 2026, noon deadline
for submission of agenda items, the Law Department and City Assessor
are providing this report
concerning the proposed adoption of the additional Alternative
Veterans’ Real Property Tax
Exemption authorized under New York Real Property Tax Law ("RPTL")
§ 458-a{11).
Page 9
This report Includes a summary of the legal requirements previously communicated
to the Council,
the City Assessor's analysis of the potential fiscal impact, and
the procedural steps necessary to
implement the exemption, should the Council elect to adopt the propose
d local law.
Importantly, the Law Department and City Assessor have complet
ed the necessary preliminary
work on a timeline that permits the Council to consider and
enact the proposed legislation
sufficiently in advance of the City's December 1 taxable status
date.
I, PRIOR COUNCIL ACTION AND LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
As explained in my prior correspondence, the Council's October
5, 2026 action concerning RPTL
§ 458-a(11) was insufficient to effectuate the exemption.
Although RPTL § 458-a{1.1) authorizes adoption by local law
or resolution, the City's existing
Alternative Veterans’ Exemption was enacted by local law
and is codified under Chapter 201 of the
Lackawanna City Code. For the reasons previously stated, it
remains the position of the Law
Department that the appropriate legislative action is the adoptio
n of a local law amending Chapter
201to Incorporate the additional exemption authorized by subdivis
ion 11.
The October 5 action did not satisfy the procedural require
ments for adoption of a local law under the
Municipal Home Rule Law and the Lackawanna City Charter. The
prior motion also employed
terminology that did not precisely correspond to the Statutory
provisions, creating potential ambiguity
regarding the scope and application of the exemption. The
proposed Local Law No. 1-2026 is intended to
correct these deficiencies.
The Law Department further recommends that the Council
expressly rescind Its October 5, 2026
action concerning RPTL § 458-a(11). Although the prior action
was Ineffective to implement the
exemption, formally rescinding it will eliminate any potential
confusion regarding the Council's
legislative actions, avoid conflicting or contradictory directio
ns, and establish a clear record that
the exemption is being implemented exclusively through the properly
enacted local law.
Rescission should occur before the Council's vote on the proposed
legislation
il. CITY ASSESSOR'S REVIEW AND IDENTIFICATION OF ELIGIBLE VETERA
NS
City Assessor Michael Milks has completed an individualized
review of all 327 properties currently
receivingthe Alternative Veterans’ Exemption on the City's assessm
ent roll.
This review Identified 28 properties with documentation presentl
y on file establishing
eligibility for the additional exemption authorized by RPTL § 458-a(11
).
The Assessor's review reflects substantial work undertaken
to identify potentially eligible veteransin
advance of Implementation. Ratherthan relyin
on gso
future lel
applicaty
ions or waitingfor qualifying
Page 10
veteransto independently seektheadditional benefit,
theAssessorhas undertaken the necessary
review and outreach to identifyand contact as many potent
ially eligibleveteransaspossibleand
determinewhetherdocumentation establishing eligibilityis availabl
e.
This advance work Is particularly important because it
positions the City to lmplement the exemption
promptly and efficiently, while reducing the possibility
that eligible veterans will be overlooked or
unnecessarily delayed in receiving the benefit.
The 28 properties presently identified represent those
for which qualifying documentation is
currentlyavailable.
They should not be interpreted asthe total number ofveterans
whomay
ultimately qualify.
Additional veterans may become eligible or establish their
eligibility by submitting documentation of
aqualifying permanent andtotal disability designation fromth
e United States Department of Veterans
Affairs.
In the near term, the number of qualifying properties can
reasonably be expected to Increase as
additional veterans provide the necessary documentatio
n. Over the longer term, the number will
fluctuate as property ownership, residency, disability classifi
cations, and other eligibility
circumstances change.
Accordingly, the Assessor's findings represent a current,
documented baseline for estimating the
exemption's potential impact, rather than a fixed or perman
ent measure of the number of
beneficiaries.
Ill. ESTIMATED FISCAL IMPACT
The City Assessor hasalso analyzed the potential effect of the proposed exempt
ion upon the City's
taxable assessed valuation and the resulting distribution of the
City's real property tax levy.
Of the 327 Alternative Veterans' Exemption files reviewe
d, the 28 properties presently identified as
qualifying have a combined total assessed value of $3,555,
600.
These properties currently receive exemptions totaling $1,614,
020, Implementation of RPTL
§458-a(11) would remove an additional $1,941,580 in assesse
d value from the City's taxable assessment
roll, based upon the Assessor's review.
Using the City's 2026 Budget Book, the Assessor calculated
the following estimated impact:
Existing Tax Structure With Proposed Exemption
City real property tax levy $14,445,047 $14,445,047
Total taxable assessed value $761,036,255 $759,094,675
Tax rate per $1,000 of assessed value $18.98 $19.03
Page 11
Based upon these figures, the Assessor estimates that impleme
ntation of the additional exemption
would increase the City's real property tax rate by approximately
$0.05 per $1,000 of taxable
assessed value, assuming the total tax levy remains unchanged.
For illustrative purposes, a property with a taxable assessed
value of $100,000 would experience an
estimated increase of approximately $5 annually asa result
of the redistribution of the tax burden
attributable to the newly exempt properties.
This increase does not represent an Increase in the City's overall
tax levy. Rather, it reflects the
redistribution of an unchanged levy across a smaller taxable
assessment base.
These figures areestimates based upon currentlyavailable informa
tion andshould notbe interpreted asa
definitive projection of the 2027 tax rate or the ultimate fiscal
impact of the exemption.
Theanalysisnecessarily assumesthattheCity's 2027 tax levy
remainsequaltothe2026levy andthat
there are nochanges tothetaxable assessed valuation other than
theadditional exemptions presently
identified. As the Assessor recognizes, those assumptions are unlike
lyto reflect all changes thatwill
occurinthe ordinary course ofpreparingthe 2027 assessment
roll and City budget.
Furthe the estimat
r,ed impact isbased upon only the 28properties presently
documented as eligible.
Additional qualifying veterans may beidentified, andthe number
ofeligible properties may increase in the
near future. Over time, the number of qualifying properties
andthe total assessed value removed from
taxation can and likely will fluctuate.
The Assessor's calculations therefore providetheCouncilandthepubli
cwithareasonable estimate of
the exemption's immediate potential impact, based uponthe bestinf
ormation presently available.
IV, PROPOSED LOCAL LAW AND PUBLIC HEARING
As previously advised, adoption of a tocal law requires complia
nce with the procedural provisions of the
Municipal Home Rule Law and the Lackawanna City Charter, includin
g distribution of the legislation in its
required final form, "aging" or in other words, giving adequa
te time for consideration ofthelaw byCouncil
members and the public, publication of notice or public hearing,
and a public hearing held before adoption.
Council President Marrano has authorized publication ofthe notice
ofpublichearing. Dueto the
publication deadlines ofBuffalo Business First, the City's officialnewspape
r, theearliest available
publication date is October 23, 2026.
The following notice is scheduled for publication on that date:
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
NOTICE ISHEREBY GIVEN
thatthe City of Lackawanna willholda Public Hearingon Novemb
er 2, 2026,atS:00
p.m.,at2838South ParkAvenue, CityHallCouncilChambers,
Lackawanna, New York 14218,
Page 12
The topic
of discussion willbe proposed Local LawNo. 1-2026, author
izinga fullexemption fromreal
proper taxes ty
forthe qualifying primary residences ofdisabled veterans
under New York Real Property
Tax Law §458-a(11).
The full text of the proposed local law may be examined atthe
City Clerk's Office in City Hall and is
posted on the City ofLackawanna website. The regular meeting
of the Lackawanna City Council will
follow, with the Council caucus commencing at 6:30 p.m.
and the regular meeting Immediately
thereafter.
END OF NOTICE
The November 2 public hearing will provide the Council and members of the
public with an
Opportunity to consider the proposed legislation, the Assesso
r's fiscal analysis, and the anticipated
effect upon qualifying veterans and other City taxpaye
rs before final legislative action,
V. IMPLEMENTATION TIMELINE AND REQUIRED COUNCIL ACTION
The Law Department and City Assessor have completed their
respective reviews and prepared the
necessary information within a timeframe that allows the
proposed exemption to be considered and
implemented before the City's December 1 taxable status date.
The significance of this timing should not be overlooked.
The Assessor's extensive review of
existing exemption files, identification of documented qualifyi
ng properties and advance outreach
to potentially eligible veterans demonstrates a proactive
effort to ensure that the exemption, if
adopted, can be administered promptly and that qualifying
veterans have a meaningful
Opportunity to receive the benefit. In coordination with
the Law Department's preparation of the
proposed legislation and required adoption procedures,
the City is well situated to implement this
exemption in a timely manner should Council adopt the propose
d local law.
This coordinated effort provides the Council with both the
Information necessary to make an informed
legislative decision and a workable schedule for timely impleme
ntation.
Should the Council wish to proceed, the recommended
course of action is as follows:
1. Receive and review proposed Local Law No. 1-2026 and
the accompanying fiscal impact
analysis prepared by the City Assessor.
2, Conduct the public hearing scheduled for November 2, 2026,
following proper
publication of notice and compliance with the applicable statuto
ry requirements.
3. Rescind the October 5, 2026 action purporting to adopt
RPTL § 458-a(11), thereby eliminatingany
ambiguity concerningthe operative legislative authorization.
Thiscanbe done by motion of any council
member and passed upon a majority vote in the affirmative.
Page 13
4. Considerand, ifapproved, adoptpogsad Local Law No.1-2026 following
the public hearing and
satisfaction of all applicable procedural requirements.
Page 14
ALTERNATIVE VETERANS EXEMPTION
2026 budget book figures used in analysis|
EXEMPTION SNAPSHOT
2026 TAX RATECOMPARISON
327 28 CURRENTRATE. REVISED RATE
Alternative veterans
Known Permanent & Total Vets $18.98 $19.03
per 1,000 assessed value per 1,000 assessed value
3.56M 1.61M Rate change: +$0.05 per 1,000 AV
P&T Vets Total assessed value Current P&T exempt amount
WHATTHAT MEANS FOR A PROPERTY
TAXABLE VALUE CHANGE
$100,000 $1,898.00 $1,903.00
$1,941,580 $150,000 $2,847.00 $2,854.50
$175,000 $3,321.50 $3,330.25
$200,000 $3,796.00 $3,806.00
“Tax amounts use the rates shown and exclude garbe1ge fees and any property-specific exempiions.
Page 15
LOCAL LAW NO. 1-2026
ALOCAL LAW AMENDING CHAPTER 201, ARTICLE XI, OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF
LACKAWANNA TO PROVIDE AN EXEMPTION FROM REAL PROPERTY TAXATION FOR VETERANS
WITH PERMANENT AND TOTAL SERVICE-CONNECTED DISABILITIES PURSUANT TO REAL
PROPERTY TAX LAW§ 458-a(11)
Be it enacted by the City Council of Lackawanna as follows:
Section 1. Legislative Intent and Purpose.
The City Council of the City of Lackawanna recognizes the service and sacrifices of veterans of
the United States Armed Forces and the importance of providing real property tax relief to
veterans who have sustained disabilities as a result of their military service.
The City Council further recognizes that§ 458-a(11) of the Real Property Tax Law of the State of New
York authorizes municipalities, by local law, to provide a full exemption from real property taxation
for qualifying veterans who have been determined by the United States Department of Veterans
Affairs to be permanently and totally disabled as a result of their military service.
The purpose of this Local Law is to exercise the authority granted by Real Property Tax Law§
458-a(11) and to amend the existing veterans exemption provisions of the Code of the City of
Lackawanna to provide such exemption.
Section 2. Amendment to Chapter 201, Article XI, § 201-45.
Section 201-45 of Chapter 201, Article XI, of the Code of the City of Lackawanna, entitled
"Findings; purpose," is hereby amended to read as follows:
§ 201-45. Findings; purpose.
The City Council of the City of Lackawanna finds that the provision of real property tax
exemptions to qualifying veterans serves an important public purpase by recognizing their
service and sacrifices on behalf of the United States.
The City Council further finds that the Real Property Tax Law of the State of New York authorizes
municipalities to provide increased real property tax exemptions to qualifying veterans and,
pursuant to§ 458-a(11), to provide a full exemption from real property taxation for qualifying
veterans with permanent and total service-connected disabilities.
It is the intent of the City Council to maintain the veterans' exemptions previously established
under this Article and to provide the additional exemption authorized by Real Property Tax Law §
458-a(11).
Section 3. Addition of§ 201-47.1 to Chapter 201, Article XI.
Page 16
Chapter 201, Article Xi, of the Code of the City of Lackawanna is hereby amended
by adding a
new§ 201-47.1, entitled "Exemption for veterans with permanent and total
service-connected
disabilities,” to read as follows:
§ 201-47.1, Exemption for veterans with permanent and total service-
connected disabilities,
A. Exemption authorized,
Pursuant to§ 458-a(11) of the Real Property Tax Law of the State of New
York, real property
located within the City of Lackawanna that constitutes the primary residence of
a qualifying
veteran who has a permanent and total disability as a result of military
service shall be exempt
from one hundred percent (100%) of real Property taxation levied by the City of
Lackawanna,
including applicable special assessments and special ad valorem levies,
to the extent authorized
by§ 458-a(11).
B, Eligibility.
To qualify for the exemption provided by this section, a veteran shall satisfy
all applicable
eligibility requirements set forth in Real Property Tax Law§ 458-a(11), including the
requirements that:
1. The veteran meets the applicable eligibility requirements of Real Property
Tax Law§
458-a;
2. The real property for which the exemption is sought constitutes the veteran's
primary
residence; and
3. The veteran's permanent and total service-connected disability is establis
hed by a letter,
official form, or other documentation issued by the United States Departm
ent of
Veterans Affairs specifically confirming that the veteran is permanently
and totally
disabled as a result of military service.
C. Application and administration.
Applications forthe exemption authorized bythis section shall besubmitted
to the CityAssessor on
forms prescribed bythe New YorkState Department of Taxation and Finance,
together with such
documentation as may be required by Real Property Tax Law§ 458-a(11).
The City Assessor shall determine eligibility for the exemption and administer
the same in
accordance with applicable provisions of the Real Property Tax Law.and
regulations and guidance
issued by the State of New York.
D. Limitation of exemption.
The exemption provided by this section shall apply only to taxes, special
assessments, and special
Page 17
ad valorem levies imposed by or on behalf of the City of Lackawanna to
the extent authorized by
Real Property Tax Law§ 458-a(Il). Nothing herein shall be construed to
authorize an exemption
from taxes levied by another taxing jurisdiction unless such jurisdiction
has independently
authorized the exemption as required by law.
In no event shall the exemption reduce the taxable assessed value of qualifyin
g real property
below zero.
E. Relationship to existing veterans exemptions; exemption not subject
to maximum limits.
The exemption authorized pursuant to this section and Real Property Tax
Law§ 458-a(Il) shall be a
full exemption from taxation and applicable special district charges, assessme
nts, and special ad
valorem levies, without regard to the home value cap established in§ 201-46
or the maximum
exemption amounts established in§ 201-47 of this Article. Neither the home value
cap nor the
maximum exemption amounts established in those sections shall apply to, limit,
or otherwise
reduce the exemption authorized herein.
Nothing contained in this section shall repeal, reduce, or otherwise modify
the existing veterans
exemptions established pursuant to§§ 201-46 and 201-47, which shall
remain in full force and
effect for exemptions granted pursuant to Real Property Tax Law§ 458-a(2).
Section 4. Severability.
If any clause, sentence, paragraph, subdivision, section, or part of this Local
Law shall be adjudged
byacourt of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unconstitutional, such judgment shall not affect,
impair, or invalidate the remainder thereof, but shall be confined in its operation
to the clause,
sentence, paragraph, subdivision, section, or part thereof directly involved
in the controversy in
which such judgment shall have been rendered.
Section 5S. Effective Date.
This Local Law shall take effect immediately upon filing with the Secretary
of State.
CHRISTY COOPER, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY
Moved by Muflahi second by Anderson to receive and file; schedule Public
Hearing for Monday,
November 2, 2026 at 5:00 p.m. in Council Chambers.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Request to Waive the Rules:
Moved by Muflahi second by Anderson to Waive the Rules.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Page 18
Mayor lafallo requests the City Council approve the resolution
regarding the proposed use of the
Community Development Block Grant for 2027-2028.
A. Honorable Council President
Honorable Council Members
2838 South Park Ave.
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Dear Honorable Body:
lam requesting the City Council waive the rules and grant approval
of the attached resolution
regarding projects | have proposed using Community Development
Block Grant (CDBG) Funds for 2027-
2028.
Your anticipated cooperation regarding this important matter
is greatly appreciated.
ANNETTE IAFALLO, MAYOR
Moved by Anderson second by Meegan to receive and file, act
on resolution.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
RESOLUTION #12, 2026
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDING
WHEREAS, The City of Lackawanna is in need of funding for
eligible programs under the Community
Block Grant Program; and
WHEREAS, the City of Lackawanna is desirous of obtaining financial
assistance for these proposals; and
WHEREAS, it is in the public interest that the City of Lackawanna
apply for such financial assistance from
the Community Development Block Grant Program through
Erie County Department of Environmental &
Planning; and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held on October 16, 2026 in the
Council Chambers of Lackawanna City
Hall for citizen input and suggestions for projects to be submitted
for funding, and
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED,
That the City Council submits the following project(s) to be
considered for funding by the CDBG Program
during the 2027-2028 grant cycle:
1* Priority — Lackawanna Community and Senior Center Upgrades/Repairs
NOW, therefore it be resolved, that the Lackawanna City Council,
hereby authorizes Mayor lafallo to
sign, submit and execute a contract with the Erie County Communi
ty Development Block Grant
{ECCDBG) Program for the cited project(s) upon approval of the ECCDBG;
and
Be it further resolved, that the City of Lackawanna is committ
ed to providing no less that 5% cash match
for said project.
THIS RESOLUTION SHALL TAKE EFFECT IMMEDIATELY
Page 19
DATED: October 19, 2026
Lackawanna, New York
Moved by Anderson second by Surdyke to adopt
resolution as written.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marran
o Carried 5-0
B. Assistant City Attorney — Request the City Council
approve the bond resolutions and ordinance
associated with the Police/Court Facility and Demolition
of the former City Hall Extension.
Moved by Marrano second by Anderson to receive and
file.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marran
o Carried 5-0
Business Registration:
Paramount Auto LLC, Harieth Alkadi, 2839 South Park
Ave., Towing and Recovery,
Moved by Marrano second by Surdyle to TABLE request.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marrano
Carried 5-0
Tabled Items: Remove from the TABLE item #6 which
was tabled at the October 5, 2026 Council
Meeting.
No Motion.
Old Business:
Adjournment:
Moved by Marrano second by Muflahi to adjourn meeting
.
Yeas: Muflahi, Anderson, Meegan, Surdyke, Marran
o Carried 5-0