Text
TOWN OF WALES ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS PUBLIC HEARING MEETING MINUTES October 7, 2026 The meeting of the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Wales was held on the 7th day of October 2026 at the Town of Wales Community Center, 12345 Big Tree Road, Wales Center, New York. CALL TO ORDER Chairman Edward Wilkolaski called the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m. EST ROLL CALL Chairman Edward Wilkolaski – present Board Member Mark Gietler - present Board Member Russ Clothier Jr. - present Board Member James Cornell – present Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent OTHERS PRESENT Applicants – David and Xena Vallone Case #1, Dennis and Kelly Osinski Case #2. One (1) resident who is on file with the Clerk. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ADOPTION OF AGENDA MOTION # __ By Zoning Board of Appeals Member Mark Gietler, second by Zoning Board of Appeals Member Russell Clothier Jr, to accept the Zoning Board of Appeals Agenda of October 7, 2026. Carried ayes-4 nays-0 ACCEPTANCE OF MINUTES OF PRIOR MEETING MOTION # __ By Zoning Board of Appeals Member Mark Gietler, second by Zoning Board of Appeals Member Russell Clothier Jr, to accept the Zoning Board of Appeals Workshop September 23, 2026 and July 1, 2026 Public Hearing meeting minutes. Carried ayes-4 nays-0 OLD BUSINESS – none. NEW BUSINESS CASE#1 Applicants: David and Xena Vallone SBL# 179.00-2-8 The applicants at 13781 Schang Road, East Aurora, New York would like to appeal the allowance for a detached accessory building located in front of the primary building: Wales Code Section 200-22 - Area Variance. 6-2026 210-1 Family Residence Public Hearing:Summary of Application The applicants seek an area variance under Section 200-22 of the Town of Wales Zoning Code to permit a detached accessory building (pole barn) located in front of the primary building. The applicants propose to construct a pole barn to the side of the existing dwelling. Presentation Mr. and Mrs. Vallone appeared on behalf of the application and stated that nothing had changed since the workshop meeting. The applicants explained: The house sits on a diagonal relative to the property line. To keep the barn in line with the house, the right end of the barn extends approximately two feet beyond the front building line of the house at one corner; the other corner is essentially on the line. A drainage swale and pond to the rear of the property limit the ability to move the barn farther back. There is ample side clearance to the property line; the relief requested concerns only the front building line. The house is set approximately 90-plus feet back from the road. The applicants described drainage improvements on the site, including fill already brought in. Board Questions Board members asked about the location of the swale and pond, the distance of the barn from the road, and the drainage improvements. The applicants confirmed the barn cannot reasonably be relocated given the pond and drainage constraints. A Board member noted having read the Planning Board minutes, which reflected that its members were in favor of the application. Public Comment The Board invited public comment. One member of the public spoke in support of the application. No one spoke in opposition. Board Deliberation for Vallone Variance: The Chairman explained the Board deliberation process. He stated that there are questions asked that can be all Aye or Nay and still have an opinion of opposing or granting a variance. All the questions are the ones asked for an area variance. He stated the Board will need a few minutes to go over the five questions then they will deliberate. The Board reviewed the application according to the required five factors: Whether undesirable change would be produced in character of neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties.ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Likely no one would perceive the setback issue. 90 plus feet off road and building size and style fit area. Fits the character of neighborhood. Whether benefit sought by applicants can be achieved by a feasible alternative to the variance. ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Without changing the size of the barn, the swale/pond/property features would make it cost prohibitive. Due to existing land features and pond. Lot layout and pond do not provide other options. Whether the requested variance is substantial: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Setback is very minimal (only a few feet). Location is only a few feet in front of the main house which is some distance away. It’s only one corner. Would the variance have an adverse impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Unlikely any negative impact. Fits perfectly with area. Again it fits. Whether the alleged difficulty was self-created: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - YesZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - YesZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - Yes ZBA Board Member James Cornell – Yes ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Most all variances are self-created. ROLL CALL VOTE ON Case#6-2026: Chairman Edward Wilkolaski – aye Board Member Mark Gietler - aye Board Member Russ Clothier Jr. - aye Board Member James Cornell – aye Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Determination of ZBA based on the above factors: The ZBA, after taking into consideration the above five factors, finds that: The benefit to the Applicants does outweigh the detriment to the neighborhood of community. Reason: Little to no impact. There is minimal to zero detriment to neighborhood. The ZBA further finds that a variance of frontage from section 200-22 of the Zoning Code is the minimum variance that should be granted in order to preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community because benefit to applicant outweighs the impact. The motion to grant the variance is passed. CASE#2 Applicants: Dennis and Kelly Osinski SBL# 178.00-2-61.2 The applicants at 13583 Schang Road, East Aurora, New York would like to appeal the 20’ side requirement and the allowance for a detached accessory building in front of the primary building on the property with a one-family dwelling: Wales Code Section 200-22 - Area Variance. 7-2026 210-1 Family Residence Public Hearing:Summary of Application The applicants seek an area variance under Section 200-22 of the Town of Wales Zoning Code for a side yard setback of less than the required 20 feet — a five-foot reduction, resulting in a 15-foot side setback — to permit construction of a barn for vehicles, implements, and tractors. Presentation Mr. and Mrs. Osinski appeared on behalf of the application and stated that nothing had changed since the workshop meeting. The applicants explained: The proposed barn will store vehicles, implements, tractors, and other equipment. The barn dimensions, length, and height are set out in the variance packet. The proposed building is more than 300 feet from the street. During discussion, the Board indicated that relief for placement of the accessory building in front of the primary dwelling, which had been included in the notice of hearing but was not necessary given the building's distance from the road after the applicants gave the Building Inspector/CEO Dan Whitehead the exact dimensions on a current survey, and the Board considered the five-foot side-setback reduction as the relief actually required. The adjoining property owners, Tony and Alisha Roncone, signed a letter stating they have reviewed the plans, are aware of the five-foot variance, and support the application. A tree line between the properties screens the barn from the neighboring homes. Existing electric and gas utilities running along the side of the driveway prevent the barn from being shifted farther from the property line; absent those utilities, the barn could have been pushed closer to the existing asphalt and no side-setback variance would be needed. The driveway apron will be stone initially, to be matched to asphalt in due course. Board Questions Board members asked about the tree line screening, the location of the entrances and doors, and the driveway surface. The applicants confirmed the site plan details. The Board noted that the survey dimensions requested at the workshop meeting had been added to the most recent survey. Attendees asked general questions about setback requirements for accessory buildings. The Board explained the requirements applicable to placement of accessory buildings relative to the road and the 20-foot side setback, and referred residents to the Town Code available on eCode360 and to the Building Inspector / Code Enforcement Officer, Dan Whitehead, as a resource before undertaking any project. Public Comment The Board invited public comment. A letter was noted from Tony and Alisha Roncone, the neighbor in favor of the project. No one spoke in opposition. Board Deliberation for Osinski Variance: The Chairman explained the Board deliberation process. He stated that there are questions asked that can be all Aye or Nay and still have an opinion of opposing or granting a variance. All the questions are the ones asked for an area variance. He stated the Board will need a few minutes to go over the five questions then they will deliberate. The Board reviewed the application according to the required five factors: Whether undesirable change would be produced in character of neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties.ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Little to no issue 400 plus feet back and adjacent neighbor is in support. All neighbors support it. Very in character to area. Building is over 400’ from road. Whether benefit sought by applicants can be achieved by a feasible alternative to the variance. ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Gas and electric line make the location alternative difficult. Due to existing utilities. Options would involve cutting mature trees or moving utilities. Whether the requested variance is substantial: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Only side setback from edge and only on one side. 5’ foot variance. Is substantial distance from road. Also has letter from neighbors giving ok. Set back from road and neighbors approval make it minimal. Would the variance have an adverse impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - NoZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - NoZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - No ZBA Board Member James Cornell – No ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Not even noticeable. Whether the alleged difficulty was self-created: ZBA Chairman Edward Wilkowlaski - YesZBA Board Member Mark Gietler - YesZBA Board Member Russell Clother, Jr. - Yes ZBA Board Member James Cornell – Yes ZBA Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Reasoning: Most all variances are self-created. ROLL CALL VOTE ON Case#5-2026: Chairman Edward Wilkolaski – aye Board Member Mark Gietler - aye Board Member Russ Clothier Jr. - aye Board Member James Cornell – aye Board Member Kevin Ingraham – absent Determination of ZBA based on the above factors: The ZBA, after taking into consideration the above five factors, finds that: The benefit to the Applicants does outweigh the detriment to the neighborhood or community. Reason: Little to no issue. So minimal but so far off the road. No detriment. The ZBA further finds that a variance of setback from section 200-22 of the Zoning Code is the minimum variance that should be granted in order to preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community because benefit to applicants outweighs the impact. The motion to grant the variance is passed. ADJOURNMENT MOTION#__ by Zoning Board of Appeals Member Mark Gietler and seconded by Zoning Board of Appeals Member James Cornell to adjourn the meeting at 6:41 p.m. Carried ayes-4 nays-0 Respectfully submitted, Michelle Homac, Zoning Board of Appeals Clerk