tbm11.09.2026 (full text)
Page 1
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
ROLL CALL: Present: Supervisor Gary Dickson
Councilmember Scott Robertson
Councilmember Mary Sherman
Councilmember Robert Breidenstein
Absent:
SUPERVISOR CALL TO ORDER
1. Pledge of Allegiance
2. Fire Safety Notification
3. Roll Call
CONSENT AGENDA
1. Accept agenda as published
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Sherman, to accept the agenda as
published.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
MINUTES TO BE APPROVED
1. Town Clerk Newton re Meeting Minutes 2026-20 of October 26, 2026
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Sherman, to approve Meeting Minutes
2026-20 of October 26, 2026.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
LEGAL NOTICES
1. Town Clerk Newton re Proofs of Publication and posting of legal notice "OF A PUBLIC HEARING
TO CONSIDER THE 2027 TENTATIVE BENEFIT BASIS BUDGET & 2027 TENTATIVE
ADVALOREM BUDGET" in the Town of West Seneca.
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Breidenstein, to open the public
hearing.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
Director of Finance Wnek gave a presentation about the budget process and highlighted the following
items:
- The Recreation Department will offer a Summer Day Camp Program
- Utilities, electricity and gas, are increasing
- Increase of $263,000 for the Police Department for overtime
- Increase of $139,000 for the Buildings and Grounds Department to add more labor
- Increase of $100,000 for blacktop paving, an increase of $120,000 for machinery and parts, and an
increase of $75,000 for salt and chemicals in the Highway Fund
- Decrease overall of 6.05% in the Sewer funds
- Continue to be within the NYS tax cap
1
Page 2
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
Councilmember Sherman requested confirmation that the increase in health insurance is 7.5% and
who gives the town this increase. Director of Finance Wnek stated the LMHF Board of Trustees voted
on the contract. Councilmember Breidenstein stated that he and Detective Dave Jarczyk represent
the town on the board of trustees.
The following comments and questions were received:
James Randolph, West Binrwood Drive:
- Regarding the bar graph, the Highway Fund showed a large surplus in 2026 and there is a
substantial reduction for 2027 and questioned how this would impact the following year — Supervisor
Dickson stated the town does not want to keep more than is needed, noting the fund balance is
taxpayer money and that the fund balance was at 7% when he became Supervisor.
Councilmember Breidenstein asked if the increases in 2022 and 2023 were reflective of the
insurance claim. Director of Finance Wnek stated the insurance claim would have been recorded in
the Capital Projects Fund and the increases were reflective of ARPA funds the town received.
Supervisor Dickson stated sales tax increased and interest rates increased during this time.
Beverly Leising, Harwood Road:
- Referred to page 10 of the Tentative Ad Valorem budget and asked if it is correct that the interest
earnings increased $500,000 because of the large amount of money in the town's bank account -
Director of Finance Wnek stated Interest Casualty and Liability and Interest Investment were
recorded separately and both have been allocated to the Interest Earnings ($340,000 total) and the
balance of the increase is due to town being proactive and shopping interest rates.
- Had understood that increases would be limited to the increases negotiated in the contracts and
was surprised to see that the Deputy Supervisor's salary was increased by 6% - Supervisor Dickson
stated, as a general rule, that is the case, but there are a couple of exceptions. Mrs. Leising stated
that in her opinion, the exceptions are not very good.
- In her opinion, the increase in postage is low
- Referred to the Town Attorney's increase of $9,700 for equipment and asked what was being
purchased - Town Attorney Trapp stated the funds are for a machine that will fold and send out
correspondence for the prosecutors, noting the volume of mail in pleas has continued to increase.
- Referred to the increase of $117,000 in Police Department overtime and asked what the increase
was based on, for example, Civic and Patriotic events - Chief Cosgrove stated the Community
Policing and Warrant Clerk lines were reduced and allocated to the Ovetime line for 2027 and noted
the net increase is $50,000.
- Referred to the Recreation Department and the almost $15,000 increase in the slay of the Assistant
which, in her opinion, is excessive for one year - Supervisor Dickson stated one cannot mistake the
budget line for a salary line and, in his opinion, the budget line was low in 2026 and the employee will
receive a Step increase and a cost of living increase this year.
- Why is the salary of the Director of Senior Services higher than the Supervisor's salary - Supervisor
Dickson questioned what Mrs. Leising was referring to. Mrs. Leising stated the Supervisor's salary.
Supervisor Dickson reviewed the line and stated it is just the way it is, and he will not comment on
this, and it is up to the public to decide. Mrs. Leising stated that is not accurate, the Town Board
votes on the salaries. Further, Mrs. Leisng commented that the Director of Senior Services assistant
is being paid well. Supervisor Dickson stated this is typical in government and commented that the
Deputy County Executive makes more than the County Executive, and Deputy Mayors make more
2
Page 3
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
than Mayors. Supervisor Dickson stated that he would not be opposed to Mrs. Leising starting a
petition to increase his salary.
- What is the status of employee's healthcare contributions - Supervisor Dickson stated employees
are contributing, and health insurance is expensive. Mrs. Leising reminded the Town Board that her
own healthcare costs are increasing, and her social security is not, and encouraged the Town Board
to make adjustments to the budget to benefit taxpayers.
Joe O'Donnell, Nancycrest Lane:
- Asked if a line in the budget indicated grant revenue the town receives - Supervisor Dickson stated
funds are applied to each project and a grant summary is provided at Town Board meetings to
provide this information.
Councilmember Breidenstein referred to the estimated revenues, for example, the Clerk Fees, and
asked who sets the amounts - Town Clerk Newton stated fees are set by several entities including
the Town Clerk's Office, State and local laws, noting that the town has one of the lowest solicitor fees
in Erie County.
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Sherman, to close the public hearing.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
REGARDING PUBLIC COMMENTS
The Board will now entertain public comments for an item on the agenda or for any topic of concern.
Each speaker should state your name and street for the record. Please be respectful in your
comments and do not divulge any personal or confidential information (for example: names, specific
situations, etc.). Speakers should recognize that not all questions or comments can be answered
immediately and may require additional research. It is the Board’s goal to respond in a thoughtful,
timely, and accurate manner.
The following comments and questions were received:
Beverly Leising, Harwood Road:
- Please consider donating to West Seneca Cares
- Commented on a close call with a deer
- Requested an update on an agreement with the Civic and Patriotic Commission requiring financial
disclosure - Mr. Trapp stated he forwarded an agreement to the Director of Recreation for his review
and has contacted the commission's attorney. Mrs. Leising questioned the increase to the line.
Supervisor Dickson stated the current revision will lower the levy by $22,000.
PUBLIC COMMENTS
NEW BUSINESS
1. PRESENTATIONS
1. Director of Finance re Budget Hearing Presentation
3
Page 4
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
2. COMMUNICATIONS TO BE VOTED ON
1. Director of Finance re Letter of Authorization
Director of Finance Wnek stated delinquent ECWA bills will be added to tax bills in 2027 in addition to
charges for grass cutting and demolition.
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Breidenstein, to adopt the attached
Letter of Authorization as Part of the 2027 Town of West Seneca Budget.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
*Appendices*
2. Director of Finance re 2027 Benefit Basis Budget
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Sherman, to adopt the Town of West
Seneca 2027 Benefit Basis Budget, which includes the Sewer, Water, Industrial Park, Gas Lighting
and Electric Lighting Funds, as previously filed by the Town Supervisor and known as the “Tentative
2027 Benefit Basis Budget” as set forth on the document filed with the Supervisor and entitled “2027
TWSNY Benefit Basis Tentative.”
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
3. Director of Finance re 2027 Ad Valorem Budget
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Breidenstein, to adopt the Town of West
Seneca 2027 Ad Valorem Budget, which includes the General and Highway Funds, as previously
filed by the Town Supervisor and known as the “Preliminary 2027 Ad Valorem Budget” entitled
“TWSNY 2027 Preliminary Budget.”
On the question, Councilmember Breidenstein asked Supervisor Dickson what budget line the funds
for the additional postage costs to mail tax receipts would be allocated. Supervisor Dickson stated he
understands M&T Bank will no longer send receipts for escrow payments the Lockbox services
processes and the costs would be incurred by the town, but does not have a breakdown for each of
the factors involved, for example, labor, postage, and other. Supervisor Dickson stated that based on
the amount of $22,000 provided by Town Clerk Newton, he has allocated $25,000 to the contingency
account to cover the additional costs. Town Clerk Newton stated the new procedure applies to both
the Town and County bills and the School bills. Supervisor Dickson stated the town would charge the
school districts to cover the associated costs.
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Sherman, to amend the original motion
to incorporate the attached changes.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
*Appendices*
Supevisor Dickson asked the Town Board members if they had any other amendments.
Councilmember Breidenstein stated that he would support an additional patrol position for the Police
4
Page 5
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
Department. Supervisor Dickson stated the current salaries of Police Department personnel make the
addition of another Police Officer prohibitive and asked if there are retirements in 2027. Chief
Cosgrove stated there will be two retirements in February - March 2027. Supervisor Dickson stated
that he understands Chief Cosgrove would hire someone later in 2027 and would support this. Chief
Cosgrove stated he intends to hire for the July academy. Councilmember Breidenstein stated one
candidate hired this year did not complete the academy. Chief Cosgrove confirmed this is true and is
short a police officer. Supervisor Dickson stated the Police Department budget would support the
hiring of a candidate later in the year.
Councilmember Breidenstein asked Director of Finance Wnek what the tax levy would be with the
adjustments. Director of Finance Wnek stated 2.7% instead of 2.77%.
Councilmember Breidenstein commented that the town has done an exemplary job over the past 7
years and asked what the impact would be by bringing the Highway Fund balance down to 15%.
Supervisor Dickson cautioned that the town is closer to the bottom of the acceptable range and has
worked very hard over the last 7 years to be fiscally responsible to the residents. Director of Finance
Wnek stated $60,000 is the amount that could be used to bring the Highway Fund balance down to
15% and decrease the tax levy to 2.5%. Councilmember Sherman also spoke of the efforts made to
keep the increases to the very minimum.
Motion by Councilmember Breidenstein, seconded by Councilmember Robertson, to use $60,000
from the Highway Fund balance to lower the overall town tax levy from 2.7 % to 2.5%.
The initial vote was Councilmembers Breidenstein and Robertson voting for this and Councilmember
Sherman voting against this. Supervisor Dickson then stated that he had not cast his vote, but he
would vote in favor of the motion and asked Councilmember Sherman if she would like to change her
vote. Councilmember Sherman stated she would change her vote and go with the majority decision.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Breidenstein, to adopt the Town of West
Seneca 2027 Ad Valorem Budget, which includes the General and Highway Funds, as previously
filed by the Town Supervisor and known as the “Preliminary 2027 Ad Valorem Budget” entitled
“TWSNY 2027 Preliminary Budget" with the changes attached and the use of $60,000 from the
Highway Fund balance.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
3. WARRANT
1. Director of Finance re Approval of Warrant
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Breidenstein, to approve the vouchers
submitted for audit, chargeable to the respected funds as follows::
General Fund: $ 412,395.27
Highway Fund: $ 213,097.37
Capital Fund: $ 426,539.40
Trust & Agency Fund: $ 0.00
5
Page 6
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
Sewer Districts: $ 169,273.29
Water Districts: $ 0.00
Drainage District: $ 0.00
Gas Conversion Lighting Districts: $ 240.59
Electric Lighting Districts: $ 1,382.45
Total: $ 1,222,928.37
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
4. REPORTS FOR FILING
1. Town Clerk Newton re Town Clerk monthly report for October 2026
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Robertson, to receive and file the Town
Clerk monthly report for October 2026 .
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
ISSUES OF THE PUBLIC
The following comments and questions were received:
James Randolph, West Bihrwood:
- Recognized Veterans Day
Joe O'Donnell, Nancycrest Lane:
- Referred to the Letter of Authorization and asked if the funds collected for the delinquent water bills
would be remitted to the county - Director of Finance Wnek stated the town would remit the payments
to the ECWA. Mr. O'Donnell asked if the town received compensation for this. Supervisor Dickson
stated the town would gain interest on the funds until they are remitted to the county. Director of
Wnek stated the Letter of Authorization process is not a new process. Mr. O'Donnell asked if
assessment challenges were billed back to the challenger. Supervisor Dickson stated he was not
aware of this.
COMMUNICATIONS BY BOARD MEMBERS AND DEPARTMENT HEADS
Director of Recreation Cox
- Reminded all of the day camp scheduled for Veterans Day and all school holidays
- Additional pickle ball sessions have been added
- Full and half day camps are scheduled for Summer 2027
Chief Cosgrove
- The winter parking ban is delayed until December 1st
- An initiative to educate people regarding e-bikes will begin with stricter enforcement in 2027
- The benefit for Scott Windover was very well attended and made Chief Cosgrove proud of the
community
Councilmember Robertson
- Recognized all involved in creating the 2027 budget and lowering the rate
- Congratulated the West Seneca High Schol football teams for making the playoffs
6
Page 7
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
Supervisor Dickson
- Anticipates a demolition of a dilapidated building on the property of 1194 Seneca Creek Road
- Addressing the concerns of Covington Drive residents and the Engineering Department will have
quotes available for the next Town Board meeting
- A Veterans Day Ceremony is scheduled for November 11th at 11 A.M. outside at the Veterans
Walkway to Freedom
- Joined members of the Joint Veterans Committee to meet with veterans at the Seneca Healthcare
Center
- Newly elected Councilman John Rusinski should be going the Town Board at the next meeting after
the election results are certified
Councilmember Breidenstein
- Agreed with Chief Cosgrove about the benefit for Scott WIndover and encouraged everyone to get
screened for skin cancer
- A schedule will be released for meeting dates for 2027
- Thanked the Police Department for their food collection drive
Highway Superintendent Adams
- Leaf collection underway
- Playgrounds at Daniel J. Shaw Memorial Park, formerly Westgate, and Peter J. Donlon Memorial
Park, formerly Carriage Park have been completed and the new signs will be installed when delivered
with a proper dedication to follow
Town Attorney Trapp
- Regarding tax assessment challenges, the parties filing the challenges are paying for this
Town Clerk Newton
- The outstanding water delinquencies are being collected by all Town Clerks/Tax Receivers in Erie
County
- Currently in the final penalty phase for the school tax collection through November 30th before
unpaid taxes are returned to Erie County
Deputy Supervisor Greenan
- An Request For Qualifications for on demand demo engineering services has been released and
questions are due November 18th and submissions are due December 4th - Councilmember
Breidenstein stated that received two inquiries and will forward them to Ms. Greenan.
Supervisor Dickson requested that the delayed parking ban hours be added to the town sign.
EXECUTIVE SESSION
ADJOURNMENT
Motion by Supervisor Dickson, seconded by Councilmember Robertson, to adjourn the meeting at
7:15 P.M.
Ayes: 4 Noes: 0 Abstain: 0 Motion Carried
7
Page 8
WEST SENECA COURT ROOM DRAFT TOWN BOARD
1250 Union Road 2026-21 Meeting Minutes
West Seneca, NY 14224 November 9, 2026
8