Planning Board agenda packet — November 18, 2026 (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Agenda Checklist
Date [| /l g [A 6 Zoning Board of Appeals
Planning and Development Board
Property Address I bovA sTReer // SECTIOU jf. 17, Block 1 Lov 3
Reason in Front of Board CR Cur woEVARY SETE PLAY REEVE lw
Special Use Permit needed for: Zoning? Yee/Ne) || Planning? Yes (Soy
_
Agenda Applicant 67 (ET RUCCS WhRepwu
se // DESTRE WITIO W Deyelormewt—
Agenda Item Revrew & D¥5CUS5. FREL¥ moa Y SETE
; Tr FeRAPRoPpIED 273,000 ~ SQUARE
PLA Poo msaucacrvATur,&
uy DESTREBVT Cov FACH I
Zone SM LofHt & MEN EUm<EWBVSFRLAL
><
Use variance needed? Ye/No)
Description of use variance (not allowed in that zone) a
Area variance needed? Yes (No
Description of area variances needed (parking, height, etc.) VA
A M BR Y
PREZEmtA sore
Description of agendause J KE VSEwW LDESC USS
(Lita FOR A PRobDICD 273, C00" SQuARE-FOeT mépy Fer uta,
Zp)
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) MV UL
Legal opinion / research (attached if applicable) WVO
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 2
4 DYNAMIC ES ss Germ
ENGINEERING ao aeee
November 2, 2026
Via Electronic Submission
([email protected])
City of Lackawanna
Planning and Development Board
714 Ridge Road — Room 309
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Attn: Charles D. Clark
Director of Development
RE: Proposed Manufacturing/
Warehouse Development
Section 141.19, Block 1, Lot 3
2303 Hamburg Turnpike
City of Lackawanna
Erie County, NY
DEC #2179 25-02847
Submission Cover Letter
Dear Mr. Clark,
On behalf of the applicant, J.G. Petrucci Co., Inc., please find the following enclosed items
consulting the submission for the above-mentioned project:
e One (1) signed copy of this Submission Cover Letter prepared by our office, dated
November 2, 2026;
e One (1) signed copy of the completed Full Environmental Assessment Form;
e One (1) signed copy of the City of Lackawanna Planning and Development Board
application;
e One (1) signed and sealed copy of the Preliminary and Final Site Plan prepared by our
office, dated October 30, 2026;
e One (1) signed and sealed copy of the Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan (SWPPP)
prepared our office, dated October 2026;
e One (1) signed and sealed copy of the ALTA/NSPS Land Title Survey prepared by Control
Point Associates Inc. PC, dated June 11, 2026; and
e One (1) signed copy of the Traffic Impact Study prepared by Dynamic Traffic, dated
October 30, 2026.
The 31.66-acre site is primarily undeveloped, vacant land located in the Renaissance Commerce
Park. The site is bordered by Dona Street to the North, and Hamburg Turnpike (NYS Route 63)
to the East. Existing conditions include railroad tracks along the Hamburg Turnpike frontage, an
electrical transmission tower with a 60-foot-wide Niagara-Mohawk easement bisecting the site in
the western portion, and Smoke Creek running along the southern property line.
www.dynamicec.com
Lake Como, NJ | Chester, NJ | Toms River, NJ | Newark, NJ | Marlton, NJ | Newtown, PA | Philadelphia, PA | Bethlehem, PA
King of Prussia, PA | Allen, TX | Houston, TX | Austin, TX | Delray Beach, FL | Tampa, FL | Annapolis, MD | Newark, DE
Page 3
Dynamic Engineering Cons
ultants, P.C.
November 2, 2026
The proposed developme Page 2 of 2
nt includes a 273,000
140,000 SF lay down pav SF manufacturing/warehou
ement area. The property se building and
Site in the BRA-Mi (Medium is Split Zoned, with the wes
Industrial) Zoning District whi ter n portion of the
(Light Industrial) Zoning Dist le the Gastern portion is in the
rict. A majority of the pro
posed building is within the
BRA-LI
Zoning district boundary, whi approximate L|
le the remaining portion of
is within the BRA-MI district the building, and the entire
. The LI district recognize laydown area
Warehousing as a Specia s Manufacturing as a Per
l Use Permit. The MI dist mit ted Use, and
use, warehousing as a Spe rict recognizes Manufactu
cial use permit, and outdoo ring as permitted
r storage as a permitted use
,
The LI district permits bui
lding height up to 45 F'T/3s
height up to 60 FT. The tories, while the Mi district
Proposed building anticipat permits building
es a building height of app
rox. 60 FT which
district.
Additional improvements
to the site to include employ
landscaping, walkways, sto ee/visitor Parking with AD
rmwater management faci A access, lighting,
lities, utilities and other ass
ociated items.
Should you have any questi
ons, comments or require
hesitate to contact the und additional information, ple
ersigned. ase do not
Sincerely,
Principal _
Page 4
DYNAMIC
See"
PRELIMINARY AND FINAL SITE PLAN S|
FOR
J.G. PETRUCCI CO., INC.
PROPOSED MANUFACTURING/WAREHOUSE DEVELOPMENT
SECTION 141.19, BLOCK 1, LOT 3
2303 HAMBURG TURNPIKE
CITY OF LACKAWANNA
ERIE COUNTY, NEW YORK
PREPARED BY
DYNAMIC ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS, P.C.
50 PARK PLACE - SUITE 901
NEWARK, NJ 07102
WWW.DYNAMICEC.COM
Page 5
Page 6
PAP SEIS MRL EPG APL AY NP
ig]
t
PME VATE oem
: bag
:: nHE Bi | 4 :
Fer aR 7 TR SPN PER
5 mee HE a 2,
SSN
a Se maeARSE aN SST
phy Reneepid
eras =
ES
t
scm pe cr
t Hl
: Bsa
i
2 me ttanune boning ie lao pl ‘COMMENCEMENT _OF WORK MOTE: * thet tt mae,
‘oes Sune “ SUES TT OPN PR ER Fe ere
EURARPPROL EES So a Saf bar ein Sw Sena
1 moe Ee ce Eittew TEL ATLL A NO en om ene moc mene SA SLRSEATS
8" ASURRTL en ISgeLSScaASSuo ot ea
Re mac MS JrcneR me eo 8
DO me
Seer aT Si =
ea oa in oi Se
Sra, z ra
oe = = =
one
[= eroo |
cs =
= seus
eae —| sees
enicen Se
(Gann sari ae
Siu. ni ae
it eywpae kiees
i mae aS ign ek teiwkd «=k te ean Cammarene maead tee :
oe ore —* = H
i
&
x
Et
Ff cusenreesmeve:*
i HHu
E t a
d qi :
mh ae
SEP Se ar Bet
crrerearcauriygg
= merece momar sio po
pote
a ae
SEARLS ae! ‘Se Rees RF
SL NSE
AS SSE
er ees PES IS CEA AIS LSE re me en eer mo 8 Ei
"RRs
Pen SRE PE
ft 4 i
i 5 iH
i ii
i : i
|i i
ii
A| i 5 iH i f
ia i
es * ROR AERIRA TRG POAT
AACS
RAT CALE
en nee pee es aren ron canes nervosa mbar as Ni 2 PPS RANE
BARS PT ARP PT ot a2 are ae
cy eae ee (Gs Turner
bere eman been esas fa wv
sas
wa 236 Gm A I
Sas
2
Naege
nee neneee
r * SER US EUR EpO Tene norma arena,
“eset * 2S WEL Ot BCPA WO RO SRS SE Ease eee DYNAMIC
ance imo ‘RRSP RE RP PRL SRR 2 Se eS Sas era rae odie a RCE PE orm we ENGINEER!RT
TaeOMRCS
Rae Lideannrsen ° SURG SPAN RSW A PERT SR, ERT HL a BSE oe creomamnioea neem an one anu rout enn anent oie
He cumcaneeeee mts
eae ae eae
a ia aT ‘ADA NOTES.
"Rar eae su warigtme a etn Ee ae
Somat Ss
Soo Rairig? ore enue erm. FEES SEER. cm eeosome Eee.
eae
Sie AE SPE
Bre altho eReremmmnwune, ne ge RSE ae
Sa ia
br ine syeae
“RR a ns tom nn
gue anor rzamens beanie bal
SSRELTTRS aoe aut pa oe en a ne ets
oti JOSHUA. SEWALD
og
bsTSR cay ruse mounts alae mee rtmerasaares seta
GaN
"Brel
Eat a eh tt tis Wawase Wie Nee esas fe Fagn * Soa Mie
CeAbie au ee CR i
wr no
GENERAL NOTES
SURRae
Ae UROL SALEEM
Ve LANE BASLTIRT,
LE Ne ce aa ore a ree re,
Page 7
DONA STREET
Wu beimes bana
JOSHUAM. SEWALD
ay SEL EXISTING
CONDITIONS
PLAN
Page 8
DONA STREET
° (99.43 AC)
id
=
|
car 5
caltssts
es
aS
JOSHUAM, SEWALD
ay ey
eh DEMOLITION
PLAN
eas ee |
a a RO aL
Page 9
!
N |
|
TREET
nea u =
—
ms “es
) , |ti—
Fy
WS 1/6 OF Y
1 IF AcOMI
WO ERE D
NE AGLPION
A,
/ '1 ANHAST
' DEL Wr,i
\ 4 y
' i"
iY at
ti i fl yo ad
My
(Derr mOUSTRIAL |
ar
(GRA-L) ZON
OVERALL SITE
PLAN
|
Page 10
DOBA STREET
) tt = ‘a
y , TTL SHUCEAENEESTSTSTEAEORET
ACEH
|
} oy BS Poise
fete tea Tee eee
a
| — are are]
Po
t
+ || dostnred atone
‘eniorext
s
ences
TAL 1G, Po ‘monet JG, PETRUCCI CO.. ING,
WHLRSIeS
|
i i
! |
f 1
?/ i
us ye oF SITE PLAN
Ld
|
onsate UP eae
oe
w fieaeing
Page 11
DONA STREET DYNAMIC!
: }--
: BN gy
Page 12
ee ym
ns EDR ceo AIT Pho nen\arommmsraning,
—> oo oe rot
)Ammmnecws + | a |
DYNAMIC!
DRAINAGE PLAN JOSHUA M, SEWALD
Page 13
N DONA STREET
f
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
UTILITY PLAN
|
——
pare er
10
Page 14
fii PLAW TO Ba UTEIZED FOR LANDSCAPE PURPOSES OMY U
[sum sim 12 OF 25 FOR LANDSCAPE PLAN HOTES AND DETAES Q 3
a c=
DONA STREET
=a o
» 2
e = my, “|
= pum 7
2
ETRUCCI CO. INC.
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
LANDSCAPE
PLAN
Page 15
is PLAN TO bi UTRZED FOR LANDSCAPE PURPOSES OMY
0
—— TEMA
AOR SE ree
Ses See errr
: ee en
ee
sDADE
‘*
RTAORESArsRPMs
REE EMS
moran ara cieesoeta
AES et eR
Ae eam
ne
“LT GLN CSE RESET See
ResSark ea ae ae
Ca ea Sarasa
fet aime no was BE a am ne A 9 HH
3
eee Sema hsTRA DTT
AS LErIN PeR Pa La sais
ae ee
PGR ‘GRRSEMA DGRoraSANDE Salty SU Pa te OS ge
oe ET,
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
‘ in : nested eh Me mo ms aee
it ae
(Regge oar ws men a a ee
I" LANDSCAPE
1 RPO RRA AD CES geen e neve NOTES &
ee, Cel
DETAILS
ne
ERFa mo ntea
“TASTR
PAoe Pe es
(BRE AA
aT RE
Te 8 enA
Page 16
7 [ORS FLAN To oa Uri FoR Lianrma PURPOSES OMY
DONA STREET
oe aie eee a ee ee a a
we tw te te te te ote fer to Mk tie tae ee hae ae ar tay a ae kee aa dae te tt
= Dy de ky Bw te Be ta a bn tw bo be te a ta be te be be ty“ be be te te ft ws
te
ERERRE
FERRERS
ER EE
©
wy tw ke he My Aw da ky to ky Day tay ha Re By Ow Gy bu ay Re tar ty by ky Ow aw ube be te .
ta tw
he te
ww
tae tet
ar tar ae
err ta ae JOSHUA M. SEWALD
1 te we We tw te sma
LIGHTING PLAN
Page 17
[ss PLAN To ne TEED Fon 0 ONION A SeDRRRNT COTROL PURPOREA OAT
Prac J.C, PETRUCCI! CO,. INC,
RO MO SNE cE FM
mie
=
IT, Froese nent rssnrning —> 14
JOSHUA M, SEWALD
SS ==
SOIL EROSION
AND SEDIMENT
CONTROL PLAN
eons arm — a3 ru EiFess
psa
pare er
4
Page 18
3 2 08 Wal ie 4
& ill e223 ;
2 af) Bag
8226 Lo
Ss 5 8 ¥
i if
bed
Pou
i
5
i;
ie
li
le
ti
ag
i i re
a] a ae
Sit i
dae H
a) gle | pin H
BlgetA) | Bie
aa | geile
;d
q
fe) Siebel SEBevstert
AP
|
Ht es
A net
a) See gene
[meee QsteSies
i cane
Pr
Hy a i
| i ca ie
t) i
a oe ee
Gh os
i
£
gi barf i H
gONP ea ar i
2 fadi Ing
eae! fia) 2 BE
a
Schaal ia
q
|
9
i i
Fe
s
s
SSS GEESE
Page 19
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
CONSTRUCTION
DETAILS
ae
vw/s0/2006
Page 20
T TH ef TT
Bey is
x st3i
2 ai
CONSTRUCTION
DETAILS
Page 21
ett EiEE car TET loca nenvseremanirccaeg
—> 9 coemucrin
es
CONSTRUCTION
JOSHUA M. SEWALD.
DETAILS
=+?
Page 22
Nv
RSAP ORDERING GUIDE NV-1 ORDERING GUIDE
Nvaw2
raft
eed
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
CONSTRUCTION
DETAILS
Page 23
PEERY
‘FOS ELEV. oT nj a80m Au. E
REFERENCE 547.087 4 aera
sorro u 2258286
or wrens ro) Shenker
7 HYDRO FRAME AND | rome OEP
USE‘dreams
STOR SUMP ELEY. con 5 IDAED moor
AE
SECTION A-A
PRODUCE seKcIeATION Finan
=} pe ate
ow 128. 810)
rey
PR VERS: 3.7 3.19 meta —
REFERENCE: 267 4813,
BOTTOMCF WTERNALS: 1 H3m(380
Me 999009
SECTION AA
tees
iw ta finer Jocnenss anmancesent
Hoeseer HydroS
ne in in ITS Face resisting
‘es ou ands Regn es
—> 22 cvercron amas CONSTRUCTION
DETAILS
Fad 9po/re28
ese uaa «a
Page 24
“THiS PLAN TO Bll UTRIZED FOR VIELE CICULATION PURPOSES OMY
PETRUCCI CO. INC.
bed
> nore crea ran
JOSHUA M. SEWALD
VEHICLE
CIRCULATION
PLAN (WB-67)
PYM | vessrece
21
Page 25
Nv
weg
=
Fy
‘rag tee
sean
{Janae
o> 2 von crete ii
JOSHUA M, SEWALD
VEHICLE
CIRCULATION
PLAN (FIRE
LP ore) |
cas zat
ae
Page 26
DONA STREET | a
> morn omnes rom oO
"VEHICLE
CIRCULATION
PLAN (REFUSE)
ae
Page 27
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Dynamic Engineering Consultants, PC
50 Park Place, Suite 901
Newark, NJ 07102
Regarding: 5 Dona Street, Lackawanna, NY 14218 // Section 141.19, Block 1, Lot 3
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
Date: N/A
Time: N/A
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
Welded Tube USA LLC — 2 Dona Street KLP Logistics — 2 Steelworkers Way Suite 100
Time Release Properties — 6 Dona Street KPM Logistics — 2 Steelworkers Way Suite 100
BLD VII LLC — 8 Dona Street Gateway Trade Center — 1951 Hamburg Turnpike
Total Quality Assurance International — 8 Dona Carlioti Holdings LLC — 1951 Hamburg Turnpike
Street Suite 100 Compass Minerials — 1951 Hamburg Turnpike
Max Advance Brakes — 8 Dona Street Suite 130 Burroughs 1978 LLC — 1951 Hamburg Turnpike
Renaissance 6 LLC — 2 Steelworkers Way
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 28
T&T Andolino Properties LLC — 2300 Hamburg 2558 Hamburg Turnpike LLC — 2558 Hamburg
Tumpike Turnpike
Sucro Real Estate NY LLC — 2303 Hamburg 2600 Hamburg Turnpike LLC — 2600 Hamburg
Turnpike Turnpike
Tecumseh Redevelopment Inc — 2303 Hamburg 2646 Hamburg Turnpike LLC — 2646 Hamburg
Turnpike Turnpike
Erie County Industrial Development Agency — 2303 Aida Rivera — 2674 Hamburg Turnpike
Hamburg Turnpike Charles Colosimo — 2678 Hamburg Turnpike
RAF Supply Inc - 2350 Hamburg Turnpike George Dechent — 2682 Hamburg Turnpike
2368 Hamburg Tpk Lckwn LLC — 2368 Hamburg Kimberly Knapik — 2686 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Frankin Ball — 2690 Hamburg Turnpike
2368 Hamburg Tpk Lekwn LLC — 2372 Hamburg Geoffrey Smith — 2694 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Sharon Colafranceschi — 2698 Hamburg Turnpike
2368 Hamburg Tpk Lckwn LLC -— 2376 Hamburg Jeffrey LeRoy — 2704 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Thomas Carpenter — 2708 Hamburg Turnpike
2368 Hamburg Tpk Lckwn LLC ~ 2380 Hamburg James Dailey — 2712 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Matthew Pacillo — 2722 Hamburg Turnpike
MLG Contracting Inc — 2424 Hamburg Turnpike Frank Gable — 2726 Hamburg Turnpike
FTS Development LLC — 2470 Hamburg Turnpike Gino Monaco — 2730 Hamburg Turnpike
Om Sai Hotels LLC — 2500 Hamburg Turnpike Property Build Unlimited — 2734 Hamburg
Ellicott Lodging Inc ~ 2502 Hamburg Turnpike Turnpike
2510 Hamburg Turnpike LLC — 2510 Hamburg Philip Gable — 2738 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Louis Fucina — 2742 Hamburg Turnpike
2520 Hamburg Turnpike LLC — 2520 Hamburg Abdul Albaneh — 2744 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike Dennis Parsons — 2748 Hamburg Turnpike
Speedway LLC — 2530 Hamburg Turnpike Dennis Parsons — 2752 Hamburg Turnpike
POAGS Hole Properties LLC — 2540 Hamburg Gerard Pilla — 2756 Hamburg Turnpike
Turnpike
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 29
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Bordering Property Notice
Dear Sir or Madam:
As an adjoining property owner in the City of Lackawanna, you are hereby notified that a neighbor has made an
application to the City of Lackawanna’s Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals as
follows:
1, Vv Preliminary Site Plan Review 2. Special Use Permit
3) Development Plan Review 4. Variance
5, Zoning Law Appeals 6. SEQR Negative Declaration
Address: 5 Dona Street, Lackawanna, NY 14218 (Renaissance Commerce Park)
Property owner: Erie County Industrial Development Agency (ECIDA)
Applicant: JG Petrucci Warehouse / Distribution Development
Regarding: Review and discuss the preliminary site plan for a proposed 273,000-square-foot manufacturing and
distribution facility to be developed by JG Petrucci at Renaissance Commerce Park. The proposed development
is located on parcels south of Dona Street and Route 5, near the park’s entrance (Section 141.19, Block 1, Lot
3).
The purpose of this review is to provide preliminary feedback and facilitate continued project planning. No final
action will be undertaken on the site plan at this meeting. Final site plan consideration will occur at a future
meeting and follow completion of the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) process and the referral
review required under Section 239 of the General Municipal Law.
You are entitled to appear at the public hearing to express your support or opposition to the granting of the
application scheduled for:
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 30
Communications, relating to the application, may be filed with the appropriate Board before the meeting by
writing to:
Department of Development
Attn: Planning and Development Board / Zoning Board of Appeals
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 31
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
/ Vf: ; Agenda Checklist
Date [i};/.[ g Llp Zoning Board of Appeals
Planning and Development Board
Property Address /2// ABSd77 L041)-
Reason in Front of Board S77 LGN LLEAL LALLle DEC
Special Use Permit needed for: Zoning? Yes / ©} Planning? Yes (fo)
Agenda Applicant S7ZUZ/IV LOMAVEL
Agenda tem CR(WLTIVG TO BULD AA Mell BOLE LEI
tore KM MEMM EO CoebubeMi
Use variance needed? Yes info)
Description of use variance (not allowed in thi
Area variance needed? Yes/No)
Description of area variances needed (parking, height, etc.) al
Description of agenda use Li Yin. SVE MAN 7O BW lO A
NEW BUMLOMG Fox 50) 70. OFFN THE
ABETCOD ELTON, PEO 1293. ABBO]
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) YES
Legal opinion / research (attached if applicable) NMQD
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 32
CITY OF LACKAWANNA
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
714 Ridge Road — Room 309
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
APPLICATION
TO THE CITY OF LACKAWANNA
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Date: a [ A sii 2 Application No.
Site Plan Review Filing Fee $10.00
A Less than 0.5 acres $ 50.00
0.5 to 1.0 acres $ 200.00
1.0 to 2.0 acres : $ 400.00
2.0 to 5.0 acres $ 400.00
____ Greater than 5 acres
$ 400.00 plus $100.00 per acres $
___ Special Use Permit $ 500.00
X__ Development Plan Review $ 50.00
Property Address: ("3 l| hUbstL VY»
S.B.L. No.
Description of Proposed Project: (WJ & AVE lake Sn ~ +e Weve Leeosned
weASaCla4 apphox: ate 1 050 bo
2 Ueaiakione
T
Orci betes Ce eat be Gin t¥S Cochentla deal wh
124% ASbott CJ. Te Peeaesh ell
Hh BISofAcT aE WE
Oweleepaont } WW praleme |os) fou AE pRepeahy,
Director of Development
Page 33
APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE to the City of Lackawanna Planning and Development
Board for-a site plan review, special use permit, development plan review or subdivision review as
required by the Municipal Code of the City of Lackawanna. The applicant hereby agrees to comply with
all applicable laws, rules, ordinances and regulations.
Signature of Applicant
Appli cant Phone No,
ole of Applicant to Project
(owner, attorney, lessee, agent,
architect, engineer, contractor...)
Property Owner:
NAME:
Address:
Director of Development
Page 34
Short Environmental Assessment Form
Part I - Project Information
instructions for Completing
Part | — Project Information. The applicant or project sponsor is responsible for the completion
of Part 1, Responses become part of the
application for approval or funding, are subject to public review, and may be subject to further verificatio
n. Complete Part 1 based on
information currently available, If additional research or investigation would be needed to fully respond
to any item, please answer as
thoroughly as possible based on current information,
Complete all items in Part 1, You may also provide any additional information which you believe
will be needed by or useful! to the
lead agency; attach additional pages as necessary to supplement any item.
Part ‘ ~ Project and ". Ve
Sen! gy UPAnree
™A att! & Van (CW
Project Location
PE and attachDy map):
sa of Pro posett 4, ote bo Qua 4 Wu, Vy
Plas . nie
aMees ogy ie to |VSonll tre Ve
ond nw SIANESS Ox Ce a L' 24 AN ott-(2,)
rcies we-( Ly 36 cladO& Lew el 0M ew al RA Mod
a=sine eae
eDiets
U pplicant6 Ubon.
Telephone:
Vbsy en
v8 Ue proposed action only involve the legislative adoption of a plan, local
administrative rule, or regulation?
If Yes, attach a narrative description of the intent of the proposed action and the environmental resources
that
BI
L138)
may be affectedin the municipality and proceed to Part 2, If no, continue to question 2.
2, Does the proposed action require a permit, approval or funding from any other government Agency?
If Yes, list agency(s) name and permit or saarar LL, 2 2
3. a. Total acreage of the site of the proposed action? ! ae acres
b. Total acreage to be physically disturbed? acres
c. Total acreage (project site and any contiguous properties) owned
or controfled by the applicant or project sponsor? acres
4, Check all land uses that occur on, are adjoining or near the proposed action:
5, [Urban [] Roral (non-agriculture) [1] industrial []_ Commercial CX’ Residential (suburban)
[I] Forest Agriculture [-] Aquatic [1] Other(Specify):
[—] Parkland
Pass | of3 SEAF 2019
Page 35
5. Js the proposed action, YES
C]
a, A permitted use under the zoning regulations?
s|_Ss} Al]
LIL é} |IA
sa
b. Consistent with the adopted comprehensive plan?
[]
YES
6, Is the proposed action consistent with the predominant character of the existing built or natural landscape?
x]
7. Is the site of the proposed action located in, or does it adjoin, a state listed Critical Environmental Area? YES
If Yes, identify:
8, a. Will the proposed action result in a substantial increase in traffic above present levels?
b, Are public transportation services available at or near the site of the proposed action?
c, Are any pedestrian accommodations or bicycle routes available on or near the site of the proposed
action?
$. Does the proposed actfon meet or exceed the state energy code requirements?
Ifthe proposed action will exceed requirements, describe design features and technologies:
&
10, Will the proposed action connect to an existing public/private water supply? NO | YES
If'No, describe method for providing potgble water:
LN
11. Will the proposed action connect to existing wastewater utilities? NO | YES
If No, describe method for providing wastewater treatment: =
(2. a, Does the project site contain, or is it substantially contiguous to, a building, archaeological site, or district NO | YES
which is listed on the National or State Register of Historic Places, or that has been determined by the
Commissioner of the NYS Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation to be eligible for listing on the
State Register of Historic Places?
b, Is the project site, or any portion of it, located in or adjacent to an area designated as sensitive for
archaeological sites on the NY State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) archaeological site inventory?
13. a. Does any portion of the site of the proposed action, or lands adjoining the proposed action, contain YES
wetlands or other waterbodies regulated by a federal, state or local agency?
b. Would the proposed action physically alter, or encroach into, any existing wetland or waterbody? Li
If Yes, identify the wetland or waterbody and extent of alterations in square feet or acres:
P
age2 of3
&
Page 36
I4, Identify the typical habitat types that occur on, or are likely to be found on the project site. Check
all that apply:
[JShoreline [7] Forest [7] Agricultural/grasslands [] Early mid-successional
[]Wetland fq Urban [7] Suburban
15. Does the site of the proposed action contain any species of animal, or associated habitats, listed
by the State or ES
(FID! B41
<
Federal government as threatened or endangered?
16. [s the project site located in the 100-year flood plan?
EB
(7. Will the proposed action create storm water discharge, either from point or non-point sources?
DI DTP ~” [| tAx UJ
~<
Ci
If Yes,
a. Will storm water discharges flow to adjacent properties?
EEN Deseo A nied DAW au lot sedh,
b, Will storm water discharges be directed to established conveyance systems (runoff and storm drains)?
Vaart : \ )
18, Does the proposed action include construction or other activities that would result in the impoundment of water
NO | YES
or other liquids (e.g., retention pond, waste lagoon, dam)?
If Yes, explain the purpose and size of the impoundment:
[} |
19, Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the location of an active or closed solid
waste | NO | YES
management facility?
If Yes, describe:
ie] m7
20.Has the site of the proposed action or an adjoining property been the subject of remediation (ongoing or
NO | YES
completed) for hazardous waste?
[f Yes, describe:
i
I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE AND ACCURATE
TO THE BEST OF
MY KNOWLEDGE
y) Meare! Date: a/:/ 24
Title: GaJAD —
PRINT FORM Page 3 of3
Page 37
9/8/26, 10:30 AM onX Hunt
WAvenue)
KOWIAK
re.
‘Line
oe
09/08/26 10:03
—
x | Opi
oo
rene@ | JASKOWIAK
JESSICA
Distance
© 26 yds
Line Type
Ee!
Save Undo
https://webmap.onxmaps.com/hunt/mapiline/create 4
Page 38
PROJECT ADDRESS
1311 Abbott rd
Lackawanna 14218
PROJECT INFORMATION
ADDRESS
CLIENT\OWNER: 1311 Abbott rd
Lackawanna 14218
ISSUE DATE: 25\08\26
DRAWN \ CHECKED: BID ACCURATE
CLIENT
DRAWN BY
BID ACCURATE
Project
PRELIMINARY DRAWINGS:
PHASE
Project
BelliAve)
00
DATE : 25-08-26
Page 39
BELL AVE
150-8 1/2”
ADDRESS:
1311 Abbott rd
Lackawanna 14218
Q
3s 70° 48'-6"
avou L089
CUENT
l
DRAWN BY
L LOT COVERED BUILDING
BID ACCURATE
© AREA COVERED AREA
12821 SFT 3500 SFT /
8
Project
SITE PLAN
PHASE
Project
r=)
162"
01
SCALE : 1\8" = 140"
DATE : 25-08-26
Page 40
BELL AVE
ADDRESS.
1311 Abbott rd
Lackawanna 14218
19°
qvou LL08v
‘CUSTOMERS ‘CUSTOMERS CLIENT
WAITING AREA Saul WAITING AREA
eee pve seed pecemoNWL
sen ypete
DRAWN BY
BID ACCURATE
AWM ALO Co)
é PARKING AND DILIVERY <= DRIVE WAY
: SERVICE LOT w ACCESS “= 47
50
Project
OPEN HALL storace T BUTLDING LAYOUT FLAN
RACKING
5Y-8 1/2"
j PHASE
Project
g ‘SERVICE
3 <S owe starr
‘STORAGE
“ee RACKING
L
S57 1/2"
*
02
SCALE : 1\8” = 1'-0"
DATE : 25-08-26
Page 41
STANDARD. STANDARD
PREFINISHED PREFINISHED
GABLE SIDING GABLE SIDING
or
3 ADDRESS
2 1311 Abbott rd
2 Lackawanna 14218
VERTICAL T
PRE-FINISHED PRE-FINISHED
STEBL SIDING (HIGH STEEL SIDING (HIGH
QUALITY BOARD QUALITY BOARD
‘AND BATTEN 109K) AND BATTEN LOOK)
|
CUENT
2-0" HIGH w ROLLING SHUTTERS STANDARD 3:6"7" S40" HIGH
WAINSCOT STONE FOR 40x10" DILIVERY COMMERCIAL WAINSCOT STONE
VENEER ACCESS STEELDOOR FOR VENEER DRAWN BY
STAFF AGGESS
RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION (FACING SERVICE LOT) LEFT SIDE ELEVATION (FACING ABBOTT ROAD) BID ACCURATE
Project
ELEVATION DRAWINGS
PHASE
Project
10 1/7 —+
STAN
PREFINISHED.
GABLE SIDING
VERTICAL
PRE-FINISHED
STEEL SIDING (HIGH
QUALITY BOARD
AND BATTEN LOOK)
Loy
03
ee Ah
35" HIGH COMMERCIAL,
WAINSCOT STONE, ALUMINUM
VENEER. FRONT DOOR,
FRONT ELEVATION (FACING BELL AVE}
SCALE : 3\16" = 1-0"
DATE : 25-08-26
Page 42
SITE PLAN OR ZONING REFERRAL TO COUNTY OF ERIE, N.Y.
AND REPLY TO MUNICIPALITY
Submit this form with full statement of proposed action (as described in GML 239- DO NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE
m(c)) at www.Erie.gov/IRonline, OR mail a hard copy (retain a copy for your files) Case No.:
to: Erie County Division of Planning, 95 Franklin Street, Room 1053, Buffalo, N.Y.,
14202 Postmark/Delivery Date: 10/02/2026
The proposed action described herein is referred in accordance with the provisions of NYS General Municipal Law §239 | - nn
A Municipal Referral Map is available to help determine whether an applicable action is subject to referral.
Description of Proposed Action
1. Name of Municipality: | City of Lackawanna
§239-m(4)(b) provides that the county shall have 30 days after receipt of a full statement of the proposed action to reply.
If the county fails to reply within such period, the referring body may take final action.
However, any county reply received after 30 days but 2 or more days prior to final action by the referring body shall be subject to §239-m(5)
The referring body shall file a report of its final action with the county within 30 days per §239-m(6).
2. Hearing Schedule: Date Time Location
3. Action is before: Legislative Body CL] Board of Appeals Planning Board
4. Action consists of: LJ New Ordinance CL] Rezone/Map Change (LJ Ordinance Amendment
Site Plan © Variance L] Special Use Permit C1 Other:
5. Location of Property: © Entire Municipality Address: 1311 Abbott Road
5a.S.B.L. of Property: 142.07-3-18.1
6. Referral required as 1 State or County () Municipal Boundary (Farm Operation located in an
site is within 500’ of: Property/Institution Agricultural District
L} Expressway County Road 1) State Highway L] Proposed State or County Road,
Property, Building/Institution,
Drainageway
pa penta ek a ae he Abbott Bottle Return plans to construct a new 3,500 sq. ft. facility to
scope of variances or site plans) ‘eplace current leased space at 1243 Abbott.
8. Other remarks:
9. Submitted by: Charles Clark Email: [email protected]
10. Return Address: Lackawanna City Hall, 2838 South Park Avenue - Rm 113. Lackawanna 14218
Reply to Municipality by Erie County Division of Planning
Receipt of the above-described proposed action is acknowledged on 10/02/2026 . The Division herewith
submits its review and reply under the provisions of applicable state and local law, based on the information
submitted with this referral.
1. (| The proposed action is not subject to review under the law.
2. (| Comment on proposed action is attached hereto.
3. (] The proposed action is subject to review; Recommendation on Proposed Action is attached hereto.
4. No Recommendation; proposed action has been reviewed and determined to be of local concern.
By the Division of Planning: Date: 10/27/2026
ZR1
Revised 3/24
Page 43
German, Timothy
From: Larson, Michael
Sent: Tuesday, October 27, 2026 9:41 AM
To: German, Timothy
Subject: Fw: Bottle Return building - 1311 Abbott Rd in Lackawanna
Michael Larson | Junior Sanitary Engineer
Erie County | Div. of Sewerage Management
95 Franklin St., 1034 | Buffalo, NY 14202
P:+1(716) 858-2703 | F:+1(716)858-6257
[email protected] | http://ww.erie.gov
From: Larson, Michael <[email protected]>
Sent: Monday, October 26, 2026 2:51 PM
To: Hall, David <[email protected]>
Subject: Bottle Return building - 1311 Abbott Rd in Lackawanna
David,
The Erie County Division of Sewerage Management (DSM) has reviewed the material submittal for the proposed Bottle
Return Building in Lackawanna and has the following comments:
1. The proposed project is located within Erie County Sewer District No. 6. The sanitary sewers near the proposed
project are owned by ECSD #6. The sanitary flows are tributary to Erie County trunk and interceptor lines and
ultimately travel to the Southtowns Advanced Wastewater Treatment Plant.
2. Review and approval of any sanitary sewers installed is required by Erie County DSM.
3. Sanitary sewer system design shall be in accordance with Ten States Standards and Erie County Sewer District
Rules and Regulations and Design Requirements.
The design engineer is encouraged to discuss preliminary sanitary sewer plans with DSM in advance of completing sewer
design. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me.
Thanks,
Michael Larson | Junior Sanitary Engineer
Erie County | Div. of Sewerage Management
95 Franklin St., 1034 | Buffalo, NY 14202
P:+1(716) 858-2703 | F:+1(716)858-6257
[email protected] | http://www.erie.gov
Page 44
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Steven Rohauer
Regarding: 1311 Abbott Road, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
Date: N/A
Time: N/A
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
1253 Ridge LLC — 1249 Ridge Road 7-Eleven Inc — 1329 Abbott Road
Kohinur Begum — 1250 Ridge Road Exhaust Realty LLC — 1350 Abbott Road
Soibhan Cooley — 1254 Ridge Road Wadha Propertiers LLC — 1361 Abbott Road
Michael Kloc — 1257 Ridge Road Mary LaSota — 38 Bell Avenue
South Buffalo Properties — 1258 Ridge Road Gina Glowacki — 39 Bell Avenue
Jessica Jaskowiak — 1260 Ridge Road Adam Hamm — 41 Bell Avenue
Nurjahan Hossain — 1261 Ridge Road Sean Monaghan — 42 Bell Avenue
Maak Realty LLC — 1298 Abbott Road Devin Hayes — 45 Bell Avenue
Christopher Daniels — 1305 Abbott Road Helene Kowiak — 49 Bell Avenue
Abbott Ridge Partners LP — 1328 Abbott Road Thomas Giammichele — 50 Bell Avenue
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 45
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Bordering Property Notice
Dear Sir or Madam:
As an adjoining property owner in the City of Lackawanna, you are hereby notified that a neighbor has made an
application to the City of Lackawanna’s Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals as
follows:
1. ve Site Plan Review 2, Special Use Permit
3. Development Plan Review 4... —_s~ Variance
5. Zoning Law Appeals 6. 4 SEQR Negative Declaration
Address: 1311 Abbott Road, Lackawanna, NY 14218
Property owner: Kim Krog
Applicant: Steven Rohauer
Regarding: Requesting a negative declaration for a state environmental quality review (SEQR) and site plan
approval to permit construction of a new 70-foot by 50-foot structure to handle current bottle & can redemption
services offered at 1243 Abbott Road (Abbott Bottle Return), located in the Neighborhood Commercial (NC)
zone.
You are entitled to appear at the public hearing to express your support or opposition to the granting of the
application scheduled for:
Communications, relating to the application, may be filed with the appropriate Board before the meeting by
writing to:
Department of Development
Attn: Planning and Development Board / Zoning Board of Appeals
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 46
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Agenda Checklist
Date / ! [ / 6/26 Zoning Board of Appeals
Planning and Development Board
Property Address 2504 SOUTuybbl,1d(4A Ue
Reasonin Front of Board (442 WEL,Ta S/ VAAWYAV MC.le
Vice
Special Use Permit needed for: Zoning? Yes (NooI Planning? Yes (ie)}
Agenda Applicant £ WAV WAT | (had
4 ALS UY LLC
Agenda Item LE QuESTING OM OL VIM ANO STL bE AV
zoe VC UH BOL. Hoo0) Cone (
Use variance needed?”eh
yes No
Description of use variance (not allowed in thai
Area variance needed? Yes (fe)
Description of area variances needed (parking, height, etc.) a
Description of agenda use Lit,VET ING TO SWE TO a 50H SW)A
Laie 10 alteomnmobit AV ELIME LEEQ
[ yLICLE KEAli BAA29 -
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) (Le 2)
Legal opinion / research (attached if applicable) AV 0
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 47
CITY OF LACKAWANNA
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
714 Ridge Road — Room 309
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
APPLICATION
TO THE CITY OF LACKAWANNA
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Date:October 30, 2026 Application No.
Site Plan Review Filing Fee $10.00
Less than 0.5 acres $ 50.00
0.5 to 1.0 acres $ 200.00
1.0 to 2.0 acres $ 400.00
2.0 to 5.0 acres $ 400.00
Greater than 5 acres
$ 400.00 plus $100.00 per acres $
Special Use Permit $ 500.00
Development Plan Review $ 50.00
Property Address: 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
S.B.L. No. 142.23-1-3
Description of Proposed Project:Small, low-traffic administrative office for an existing
primarily online used-vehicle purchasing and resale business, with three
designated parking spaces (per DMV requirements). On-site customer
activity very limited: minimal signage: no inspections, repairs or servicing.
Director of Development
Page 48
APPLICATION IS HERBBY MADE to the City of Lackawanna Planning and Development
Board for -a site plan review, special use permit, development plan review or subdivision review as
required by the Municipal Code of the City of Lackawanna. The applicant hereby agrees to comply with
all applicable laws, rules, ordinances and regulations.
Evan Walton ee
Name of Applicant Signature of Applicant
Address of Applicant Applicant Phone No.
BP Owner, Cash4Cars WNY LLC
Applicant’s Email Role ofApplicant to Project
(owner, attorney, lessee, agent,
architect, engineer, contractor...)
Property Owner:
NAME: 2504 South Park Ave LLC
Address
Director of Development
Page 49
PLANNING BOARD - PROJECT NARRATIVE
Cash4Cars WNY LLC | 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
SBL; 142.23-1-3 | Applicant: Evan Walton | Owner: 2504 South Park Ave LLC
Proposed Use
Cash4Cars WNY LLC proposes a small, low-traffic administrative office for an existing, primarily online
used-vehicle purchasing and resale business, with three designated parking spaces {per DMV requirements).
On-site customer activity would be very limited. Minimal, small signage Is proposed. No inspections, repairs, or
vehicle servicing would occur on the property at any time.
Operations and Customer Activity
Purchasing and resale activities would be conducted primarily online or by telephone. Customer visits would
be infrequent and generally arranged in advance. The proposed location would not operate as a traditional,
high-traffic vehicle dealership.
Parking and Neighborhood Compatibility
Three designated vehicle spaces are proposed to support DMV business-location requirements. The proposed
spaces would be located farther inside the property, near existing buildings, as shown on the accompanying
parking exhibit, subject to City review. This placement is intended to limit street visibility and neighborhood
impacts.
Signage and Site Appearance
Only minimal, small business identification signage is proposed, subject to City approval. No large advertising
signs, vehicle repairs, inspections, servicing, dismantling, or scrapyard activities are proposed.
Zoning and Planning Review
The applicant recognizes that vehicle sales are not a permitted use as of right in the Neighborhood
Commercial district and is separately requesting a land use variance from the Zoning Board of Appeals. This
proposal is subject to the applicable City review and approval requirements.
APPLICANT CONTACT
Evan Walton | Owner, Cash4Cars WNY LLC
Phone <a:
Business mailing address: [a
Property owner: 2504 South Park Ave LLC
Submitted by Evan Walton, Owner, Cash4Cars WNY LLC
Page 50
Ste
eid pesoe SET wd PRD
oF aE WOT We
ae oesmocr
[¢ SET OR EX 5/8" REBAR
DORRANCE (eo woz) AVENUE,
NORTH UNE WOT a8 TWP10, ROT
we ane Smee
Zao)
é
seo 30K net ove g
Ps
ia
sco"
FINE at.
Ma¥d HLNOS
‘Zao Grund
0a 107 aN ASH
GONGAV (som .99)
oe
Cs
realcr
ian
SURVEY OF
PART OF LOT 285, TOWNSHIP 10, RANGE 7
BUFFALO RESERVATION
CITY OF LACKAWANNA, ERIE COUNTY, NEW YORK
DATE ROMRON/TPE
Date: DECEMBER 8, 2025
TAX No. 142.25-1-2 & 5
Page 51
et OF Le 8” musk eats Peavedin
SARE Nes om tenLe
Pe Pet 2
Saw oaeioon
ASH FOR CARS WNY
PROPOSED PARKING SITE EXHIBIT! DORRANCE ("#0") AVENUE som ne our orsrg
2504 South Park Avenue | Lackawanmay;NY— ~ ~{— TE em O—r——~—_<S
Preliminary zoning review - not a certified site pla i le& 3& oe an an ag oa me Bai CH
' N.,
:z a
i
-
a creme
/ 235,004
eg
= a —
| |? zo OF OR ‘
$00"
;& [oo]
SPACE 1 &
; 3
§ | rivet ae
\o san aoe § 3
gi
€ | uri ;
S
= ls 3
= |: 4
&
i
>
S jar?
is
4, i
1 prewce g re
1 z
t
2
8
AJ i
ion g
race wae 1)
SURVEY OF
PART OF LOT 283, TOWNSMP 10, RANGE 7
BUFFALO CREEK RESERVATION
CITY OF LACKAWANNA, ERIE COUNTY, NEW YORK
Oat ewan GPI ENGINEERING, LANDSCAPE.
ARCHITECTURE & SURVEYING, LLP
Job No. 19253 Dole DECEMBER 8, 2023
Seale: = 30° TAX Mo, 142,.23-1-2 & 3
Page 52
(611 DORRANGE/AVE
°251/4'SOUTH PARK¢AVE|
2Wellechnologys Coipoiart
03/30/2026
Page 53
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Evan Walton
Regarding: 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
14M Enterprises Inc — 2540 South Park Avenue
Sorrento Lactalis Inc — 2501 South Park Avenue
Howard Feller — 67 Dorrance Avenue
William Simson — 65 Dorrance Avenue
Francesca Goodwin — 63 Dorrance Avenue
Erie County Sewer Dist #6 — 61 Dorrance Avenue
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 54
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
2504 South Park Ave LLC
Regarding: 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
14M Enterprises Inc — 2540 South Park Avenue
Sorrento Lactalis Inc — 2501 South Park Avenue
Howard Feller — 67 Dorrance Avenue
William Simson — 65 Dorrance Avenue
Francesca Goodwin — 63 Dorrance Avenue
Erie County Sewer Dist #6 — 61 Dorrance Avenue
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 55
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Bordering Property Notice
Dear Sir or Madam:
As an adjoining property owner in the City of Lackawanna, you are hereby notified that a neighbor has made an
application to the City of Lackawanna’s Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals as
follows:
1; ve Site Plan Review 2. Special Use Permit
3. Development Plan Review 4. WV Vaviance
5. Zoning Law Appeals 6. SEQR Negative Declaration
Address: 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
Property owner: 2504 South Park Ave LLC
Applicant: Evan Walton / Cash4Cars WNY LLC
Regarding: Requesting a use variance to accommodate an administrative office for an online used vehicle
purchasing and resale business in the Neighborhood Commercial (NC) Zone.
Regarding: Requesting site plan approval to operate an administrative office for an online used vehicle
purchasing and resale business in the Neighborhood Commercial (NC) Zone.
You are entitled to appear at the public hearing to express your support or opposition to the granting of the
application scheduled for:
Communications, relating to the application, may be filed with the appropriate Board before the meeting by
writing to:
Department of Development
Attn: Planning and Development Board / Zoning Board of Appeals
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 56
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Agenda Checklist
Date_//y,ala (0 Zoning Board of Appeals
Planning and Development Board
prpenyadhien eo (77 400TH {pe ME.
renmintiontottont ALA LALMuce [Gre LEAN PLE.
Special Use Permit needed for: Zoning? Yes /Mo |) Planning? Yes/ é- |
Agenda Applicant MALOUS JNYEMS L COCLR MILLET FT.
Agenda Item LEO KM ZOEA he,ta/ SAE.
zone Lal (YMTCAL Lear LUTE
Use variance needed? Yes / No
Description of use variance (not allowed in th
Area variance needed? fa /'No
Description of area vatiances needed (puking height, a) LAZ/AVE LOE
IAW DMYUES, Cllanolat ALEZURLUNT 7O4
S0UAL Evinbie FER LENT.
Description of agenda
use L(YS770 HO SENSAN LLL 47
SAL Boe LOL LUBLIC AO ELWHIE
LENTAL
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) VAS
Legal opinion / research (attached if applicable) AhO)
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 57
CITY OF LACKAWANNA
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT tS
714 Ridge Road — Room 309 SS
Lackawanna, NY 14218 Ss
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866 =
APPLICATION
TO THE CITY OF LACKAWANNA
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Date: q / 4 O | QL Application No.
Site Plan Review Filing Fee $10.00
LoLess than 0.5 acres $ 50.00
0.5 to 1.0 acres $ 200.00
1.0 to 2.0 acres $ 400.00
2.0 to 5.0 acres $ 400.00
_____Greater than 5 acres
$ 400.00 plus $100.00 per acres $
Special Use Permit $ 500.00
Development Plan Review $ 50.00
Property Address: a7 i Sorth Par kK Kye
spin. Ya 3¥-Q-22.\
Description of Proposed Priees_Convursion at oo Sawer reakouvane burlding
into O Place of Quddiic Resemblu § own runtal hol .
“tho Qroshidon Wil aovare as a skal Vall for Private avers,
Connmeanicha Denctions, ound Sootal aathoring ie. Bills game .
The 2xistrrng Kitchan layout wil oe estrieted “bo Lawyperar
Stooyag ank~ Pre-Prepaved Cocdkaring, alroe- ot PS only.
Director of Development
Page 58
APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE to the City of Lackawanna Planning and Development
Board for -a site plan review, special use permit, development plan review or subdivision review as
required by the Municipal Code of the City of Lackawanna. The applicant hereby agrees to comply with
all applicable laws, rules, ordinances and regulations.
Lolty will?am>d
Mutco) Nudhee
Applicant Phone No,
Applicant’s Email Role of Applicant to Project
(owner, attorney, lessee, agent,
architect, engineer, contractor...)
Property Owner:
NAME:
Address:
Director of Development
Page 59
92026 at 3:22:55 PM
2/11 South Park Ave
awanna NY 14218
Jnited States
$C pill 20
Ce
+Ase
lw“aul
au sed.
7 Did
S15 Spee 1 Coctade
Water, ‘a [#£72:
a Swios li ety(w
ithSoien $157" )
16" Su
areepr epQM}
o -ee mid
Q Garlic Dy
ap
Page 60
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Corey Williams
Regarding: 2711 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
Nasir Afif— 2719 South Park Avenue 717 Ridge Road LLC — 717 Ridge Road
Ahmed Ali Alahrag — 2717 South Park Avenue SJAMS 2025 LLC — 715 Ridge Road
Ahmed Alahrag — 2707 South Park Avenue SJAMS 2025 LLC — 711 Ridge Road
2703 South Park LLC — 2703 South Park Avenue Abdulla Almontaser — 109 Nason Parkway
Fruci Apartments LLC — 2693 South Park Avenue Matthew Bly — 107 Nason Parkway
OLV Campus — 781 Ridge Road Federal Home Loan Mtg Co — 101 Nason Parkway
Adolf Development Co LLC — 727 Ridge Road Gerald Berdysiak — 97 Nason Parkway
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 61
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Bennett Enterprises of Buffalo
Regarding: 2711 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
Nasir Afif— 2719 South Park Avenue 717 Ridge Road LLC — 717 Ridge Road
Ahmed Ali Alahrag — 2717 South Park Avenue SJAMS 2025 LLC — 715 Ridge Road
Ahmed Alahrag — 2707 South Park Avenue SJAMS 2025 LLC — 711 Ridge Road
2703 South Park LLC — 2703 South Park Avenue Abdulla Almontaser — 109 Nason Parkway
Fruci Apartments LLC — 2693 South Park Avenue Matthew Bly — 107 Nason Parkway
OLV Campus — 781 Ridge Road Federal Home Loan Mtg Co — 101 Nason Parkway
Adolf Development Co LLC — 727 Ridge Road Gerald Berdysiak — 97 Nason Parkway
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 62
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Bordering Property Notice
Dear Sir or Madam:
As an adjoining property owner in the City of Lackawanna, you are hereby notified that a neighbor has made an
application to the City of Lackawanna’s Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals as
follows:
1. Vv Site Plan Review 2: Special Use Permit
3: Development Plan Review 4. VW Variance
5: Zoning Law Appeals 6. SEQR Negative Declaration
Address: 2711 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218
Property owner: Bennett Enterprises of Buffalo
Applicant: Marcus Andrews / Corey Williams
Regarding: Requesting a use variance to accommodate a conversion of a former restaurant to a social event
space for both public and private gatherings and a parking variance for forty-two (42) spaces, located within the
Central Business District (CBD) Zone.
Regarding: Requesting site plan approval to operate a social event space in a former restaurant for both public
and private gatherings to include pre-prepared catering drop offs, located within the Central Business District
(CBD) Zone.
You are entitled to appear at the public hearing to express your support or opposition to the granting of the
application scheduled for:
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 63
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Communications, relating to the application, may be filed with the appropriate Board before the meeting by
writing to:
Department of Development
Attn: Planning and Development Board / Zoning Board of Appeals
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 64
City of Lackawanna
Office of Code Enforcement
2838 South Park Ave Rm 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Ph: 716-827-6421
iM
Date [18 /Ae
Agenda Checklist
Zoning Board of Appeals
PropertyAddress_ — “)/_ MeV LL.
Reason infront ofpoad ELA YOLLAN.LES. ANL LVL LAA MOO.
Special Use Permit needed for Zoning? Yes /(id_ Planning? ves OL
agenda Applicant AUT ME AS FOSTER
agenda tem A) OC) ABIL Li QE ol att (PUL v
rone LCM COPEL CHL fer \
Use variance needed? Yes (No )
Description of use variance (not allowed in that zone) ee
mo
Area variance neenede’ Yes / No
Description of area variances needed (parking, height, etc) Lia 4 SMEG
4b LEAL Abb Wels AND Size LL
ATLL.
< —
Description of agenda use SAVE
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) VE 2
Legal opinion / research (if applicable) ALO
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 65
CITY OF LACKAWANNA
DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT
714 Ridge Road — Room 309
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
APPLICATION
TO THE CITY OF LACKAWANNA
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Date: L fhg d V4b Application No.
Site Plan Review Filing re S000-—
& Less than 0.5 acres <0
0.5 to 1.0 acres $ 200-00
1.0 to 2.0 acres . $ 400.00
2.0 to 5.0 acres $ 400.00
Greater than 5 acres
$ 400.00 plus $100.00 per acres $
Special Use Permit $ 500.00
Development Plan Review $50.00
Property Address: / Fa 4 An
S.B.L. No. S42. O& - Z- vin
Description of Proposed Project: - Arid. SOx OO fa he
Sun wf bling Sf) te.
Director of Development
Page 66
APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE to the City of Lackawanna Planning and Development
Board for -a site plan review, special use permit, development plan review or subdivision review as
required by the Municipal Code of the City of Lackawantia. The applicant hereby agrees to comply with
all applicable laws, rules, ordinances and regulations.
Mot Posie
Name of
Applicant Signaty pplicant
Applicant Phone No.
Role of Applicant to Projeot
(owner, attorney, lessee, agent,
architect, engineer, contractor...)
Property Owner: om
wane Mad ote _.
Addte
Director of Development
Page 67
EQUIVALENTS
TRUE N RTH
LAND SURVEYING, PLLC
BUFFALO, NY
ee
0.08'=15/16"
0.09'=1-1/16"
0.10°=1-3/16"
0,20'=2-3/8"
0.60'=7-3/4"
0.70'=8-3/8"
0.80'=9-5/8"
90'=10-13/16"
1.00'=12”
1 ROD = 16.5’
1 CHAIN = 66,0"
4 LINK = 0.01 CHAINS OR 7-15/16”
SUCCESSORS TO THE
RECORDS OF
Millard, MacKay & Delles
Millard & MacKay
Amherst Land Surveying
Roy D. Millard, L.S.
Fred Strack, L.S.
David J. Millard, L.S.
Elwood Hummel, L.S.
Phone: (716) 631-5140
John P. Niebrich, L.S.
Email: [email protected]
Maicolm L. MacKay, L.S.
G. Granson Geis, L.S.
Page 68
EAGAN — @o’ mor DRIVE
460.0" TO THE EASTERLY ,
=~ LINE OF ABBOTT (66’) ROAD 50.00 ms, ‘Set Capped Rebar
fad, Rebar {| nN
104 He Set Capped Rebor \
:
Fence 4.43 M.-
vy;
VACANT LOT 1
120,00" 120.00"
2847
Fence 135 aN
NORTH LINE OF,
UBER 4912 PAGE 82
Fance 0.15 H, Fenes 0.17 N,
& 55a \ [t h67 E Fence 1.07 W.
| set Copped Rebor
"pee 408 37 Soo" =v
a AGE
Steg B78 oy ry, Bldg. 3.05 §,
BUILDING
INSTRUMESPHI(S) UDLIZED IN. DETERMINING LOCATION OF BQUNDARY LINES: LIBER (0304 PAGE 240
TMS SUPMAT WAS PREPARED WIHOUT THE BENEFIT OF A CURRENT ABSTRACT OF THLE ANG 08 SUBIECT
10 ANY STATE OF FACTS THAT MAY BE REVEALED I SND AOSTRACE
NOTE: THIS SURVET WAS PEAFCPMED UNDER SEVERE SHOW
AND ice COnOI THE,
"Ane TT
MHS SURREY AA WAS PREPARED IM ACCORDANCE WITH TIE ScopyriGHT_2022_. BY: AMEND:
GURREP AAS STANOARDS FOR LMI) SURVETS ADOPTED BY THE
BAR ASEESOCATON GF ERE COUNT? AT ThE REQUEST OF
Anthowsspdh Cert
TRUE N@RTH SURVEY DATE: 17-28-22
LCavtor f- Aw LAND SURVEYING, PLLO “DRAWING DATE: 17-29-22
180 AERO DRIVE SCALE: /" = 20°
Ome FOI
TEPER T Bae WHOLE Wa O5tGES BUFFALO, NEW YORK 14225
(718)831-5140 ~ Truanortheltc®aol.com "ALL RIGHTS RESERVED”
THIS MAP Voto UNLESS
EMGOSSED
YaTH MEW ‘YORK STATE LICENSED LAND
SURVEYOR'S SEAL. ALTERING AN, ITEM
ON THIS MAP ISA VIOLAR OF THE
PART OF LOT__289 SECTION TOWNSHIP 70 RANGE 7 OF THE: (AW EXCEPT AS PROVIDED CN
iit SECTION
Bcetfolo Creek Reservation SURVEY ~ Erle COUNTY, N.Y. 7208, PART 2, OF THE NEW YORK
STATE Z0UCATION LAY,
‘SURVEY
OF rb} “kage Drive, tl OF TGERG IGANG SBL_No. 142 08-2-5
Page 69
EAGAN (60' moe) DRIVE
460.0° TO THE EASTERLY
LINE OF ABBOTT (663) ROAD ~ 50.00
; Set Cooped Reber
Tafa. Rebar / iw
Hat We f] set copped reser ee
Fence 4.43 ed
Dy
APPRox tinhginTEpe
VACANT LOT :
| LOCATON |.
SI 8
Se S
™~
3O ~
ae
es
nent
NORTH LINE OF,
UBER 4912 PAGE 82
hte M, Fe BIT N,
arers iN { pew é& Feoce 107 Wt Sal Copped Rebor
et
Se a —
Fence 202 5. y 50.00" \
& 442 Bldg. 274 5; Lock
:
dy, 3.05 S.
BUILBING
INSIRUMISANI(S) UTILIZED IN OETERMMING LOCATION OF BOUNDARY LINES; LuBeR 10564
PAGE Bea
THIS BURP MWAY WAS PREPARED WITHOUT THE BENEFIT OF A CURRETET ABSTRAGT
OF TILE AND IS SUGISCT TO ANY STATE OF FACTS THAT MAY BE REVEALEO IN
SAID ABSTRACT:
NOTE: THIS SURVEY WAS PERFOPMED UNDER SEVERE SHOW AND
ieé conDIncHS
I SRO es cacen mw acconusce way
Ee eyeSree
me ®copyRIGHT_2022 _. BY: AMEND:
TRUE NORTH [Sunk bmema=a;
c
Jou _ Anw LAND BURVEVINE, PLL | ORANG DATE: 71-29-22 :
te Cth, 150 AERO ORIVE
ET Hae WRF Fi Bata BUFFALO, NEW YORK 14225 SCALE: 7" = 29!
- ¥
(715)631—-5140 ~ [email protected] —1h
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ¢
THIS HAP VOD UNLESS ¢
EMBOSSED |
YATH NEW YORK STATE LICENSED
LAND iN
PART OF LOT 289 SECTION TOWNSHIP 70 RANGE 7 OF THE: | Ch eiSAe AS PROVIDED IN secon
Bue tale Creek Reservation ~ SURVEY— Erie COUNTY, N.Y. | OS RART 2,08
fC
“[(SURVERY OFT ai “Cogan Drive CHY oF Lackawanna© THE HEYyor
SBC No. 14208-2-35"
Page 70
fyELSartei
Bxgnuonesa cary
Teneof
wow
ar ‘ be t tra nur atin
i © % i =i F 7 F 7
' e Tf i i tot '
¥ io4 1 ' « i ' 1 moa '
R 1 t 4 | \ i a i 1 ho
J ‘ { 4 i 1 ' ' 1 \
‘ i 4 f 1 i moa ‘
t to i 1 1 ro 1
' to 1 1 1 1 hoa 1
i 1 Eo 1 1 roa 1
' oo4 1 1 by 1 1 roy
\ toa ' f Hoa 1 1 fl
b ‘ mn 1 q b f rot i hoa 1
q b 1 hoy 1 q |
N \ |
q cance ornromies exevromiow ~% |
p war q b q p ao q
y y
4 5 ij ij § FY 5 i
y le i |
J q p q p q ql
{ ole
darnoou |
Tr 2 HO |
=
La we “S | em
! y Guirnoou U |
= 27
re ms a ne ae aie
(Sain oon snowTECTUR BN SECOND FLOOR OBTION + secown F.gcr cent?
Vite 1 Nie OFFS
Trash Fom |
Page 71
An official website of New York State.
Here's how you know v
NEW
YORIK
STATE
Office of General Services
Login
Service-Disabled Veterans’ Enterprise System
€ Back to Directory Search
Guster Enterprises LLC
Certification Status: Certified
Business Details
Legal Name Guster Enterprises LLC
DBA Names N/A
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Phone
Email
Website
Control Number 221418
Categories Construction Horizontal: Highways & Roadways;
Maintenance, Repair & New Construction, Construction
Vertical: Building Construction; Rehabilitation & New
Construction
Business Size
_ Less than.$100,000__
Specific Function/Business Description Concrete Flatwork
Classifications ~~ Construction
Keywords concrete flatwork
Home County Erie
Home Region Western New York
Counties Served Ontario, Niagara, Wyoming, Orleans, Genesee, Erie,
Monroe, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua
Page 72
NAICS Codles
238110 Poured Concrete Foundation and Structure Contractors
238190 Other Foundation, Structure, and Building Exterior Contractors
| 238390 Other Building Finishing Contractors
238910 Site Preparation Contractors
Primary Contact
Owner Foster , Matthew J.
NYS Centralized Contract
N/A
Office of General Services Privacy Policy Accessibility Contact Us
Page 73
Scott Hayes <shayes@lacknycom™
Development
2 messages
Matthew Foster Mon, Jan 26, 2026 at 9:10 PM
To: "shayes@laskny. ackny.com
Scott, 7
am the owner of the empty lot at 51 Eagan. My goal is to put up a pole barn style building with an apartment Up top. | did hire
an engineering firm to generate drawings and apply for permits. They were told that this was not allowed even though it’s zoned
Regional Commercial. | would like to move forward with this project. Can you please steer me in the right direction? Thank you .
Please call me at your earliest convenience.
Matthew Foster
Guster eriterprises LLC
uw
Scoit Hayes <[email protected]> Mon, Feb 2, 2026 at 4:09 Pi,
To; Steve Balon <[email protected]>, James Gibson <[email protected]>
[Quoted text hidden]
scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
City of Lackawanna
716-827-8427
Page 74
Pq Gmail James Gibson <[email protected]>
51 Eagan
2 messages
Matthew Foster < Thu, Oct 29, 2026 at 6:31 AM
To: "asstdevelopm as lackey com
Attached are pictures of the building style I'm proposing.
Matthew Foster
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Jason Havens lel
Date: Fri, Oct 9, 2026 at 5:
Subject: Rendering Lackawanna Building
To:
CC: Chris Panaro< , Phuong Nguyen
matt,
2 options to consider. Let me know if one is preferred by you over the other.
We think that you could certainly present both and argue that they are very reasonably similar to the neighboring
buildings enough.
The one with the paneling on the front would seem to be cheaper but we could also use a brick panel system on
the front as shown on the first option if you or they require it.
thanks,
Jason Havens, P.E.
Principal - Civil Engineering
Architecture & Engineering
4350 Seneca Street
West Seneca, NY 14224
C: 585-305-5199
Page 75
2 attachments
Option 1_East_No Electric Pole.png
5563K
Option 2_East_No Electric Pole.png
5534K
James Gibson <[email protected]> Fri, Oct 30, 2026 at 10:52 AM
To: Scott Hayes <[email protected]>, Steve Balon <[email protected]>
[Quoted text hidden]
2 attachments
: Option 1_East_No Electric Pole.png
5563K
Option 2_East_No Electric Pole.png
5534K
Page 76
Page 77
Page 78
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Application Notice
November 10, 2026
Matthew Foster
Regarding: 51 Eagan Drive, Lackawanna, NY 14218
The above item has been placed on the agenda for the next scheduled meeting of the City of Lackawanna’s
Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals:
Zoning Board of Appeals Planning and Development Board
Date: N/A
Time: N/A
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
Boarding Neighbors:
Sovran Acquisition — 1324 Abbott Road
Mohammad Latif— 43 Eagan Drive
E&R Horizons LLC — 46 Eagan Drive
E&R Horizons LLC — 52 Eagan Drive
Sylvia Avarello — 58 Eagan Drive
James Maguire — 59 Eagan Drive
JOY AB Corp — 62 Eagan Drive
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 79
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Bordering Property Notice
Dear Sir or Madam:
As an adjoining property owner in the City of Lackawanna, you are hereby notified that a neighbor has made an
application to the City of Lackawanna’s Planning and Development Board and/or Zoning Board of Appeals as
follows:
1. ve Site Plan Review 2. Special Use Permit
3. Development Plan Review 4... __s«Varriance
3: Zoning Law Appeals 6. 4 SEQR Negative Declaration
Address: 51 Eagan Drive, Lackawanna, NY 14218
Property owner: Matthew Foster
Applicant: Matthew Foster
Regarding: Requesting a negative declaration for a State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) and site plan
approval to permit installation of a new 30-foot by 60-foot pole barn with a single-family apartment on the
second floor and to run a concrete business on the first floor located in the Regional Commercial (RC) Zone.
You are entitled to appear at the public hearing to express your support or opposition to the granting of the
application scheduled for:
Communications, relating to the application, may be filed with the appropriate Board before the meeting by
writing to:
Department of Development
Attn: Planning and Development Board / Zoning Board of Appeals
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
If you have any questions regarding the meeting, please call (716) 827-6421.
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113 Lackawanna, New York 14218 Phone (716) 827-6421 Fax (716) 827-1866
Page 80
City of Lackawanna
Department of Development
2838 South Park Avenue — Room 113
Lackawanna, NY 14218
Tel: (716) 827-6421 Fax: (716) 827-1866
Agenda Checklist
Date | | /{ i jG Zoning Board of Appeals
Planning and Development Board
Property Address TS AFOGE Roary & Mkemey (ARK Y ADDREDES 7 os 139
Reason in Front of Board SUBD VFSTOW & RECOM FEGUR RV FOU oF OLY Campus PROPER IEE 5
Special Use Permit needed for: Zoning? Yes (Nod || Planning? Yes No
J - : 1) PARA WHECLER BousD BCHotveck &
Agenda Applicant 20/D5¢ Y Hav BEM KEE Uf CRAzL Les © YTLE lisCHaeees CLARK Cory OF Krug, )
Cen Hwy)
Agenda Item Dioc €Sé of BUFFALO ’s CHePTER TL CAV RUPE RERGAWE ZA TEE PLAY
Zone OV OVERLAY wet MEW < CM RAL BUSEWESS DEST REC IY MEXED RESFDEN TEAL
Use variance needed? Yey/No)
Description of use variance (not allowed in that:zone) wi
Area variance needed? Yes(No
Description of area variances needed (parking, height, etc.) Ve
Description of agenda use 782 OPE - SUB)
F vEDE PRLheX tmATE cy I37-acre pryarty inte,
Five €5) sep
e lod 87 1262, 1366,1370 me KEWLlf ~ RECov fLOAVRE AioxtmaszELY 0-6 b¢IC$
Compre ix Sing three (3) woisting Jots into +0 C2) Miele configured lot$..
Code Enforcement research (attached if applicable) AJ 0
Legal opinion / research (attached if applicable) NM C
Scott Hayes
Code Enforcement Officer
Page 81
[re]|
Phillips Lytle LLP
Via E-Mail and Hand Delivery November 2, 2026
Office of the Director of Development
Attn: Mr. Charles Clark, Director
2838 South Park Avenue, Room 113
Lackawanna, New York 14218
Re: Subdivision Application for the OLV Campus
Dear Mr. Clark and the Town of Lackawanna Planning Board:
We represent Our Lady of Victory Homes of Charity d/b/a OLV Charities (“OLV
Charities”) and Our Lady of Victory Renaissance Corporation (“OLV Renaissance”),
and Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC represents The Diocese of Buffalo, N.Y. (the
“Diocese”) and Our Lady of Victory National Shrine (“OLV Basilica”) (collectively
“Applicants”), together in a joint application for a proposed subdivision of (1) an
approximately 138.8873 acre parcel located at 781 Ridge Road, in the City of
Lackawanna (the “City”), Erie County owned by the Diocese, Catholic Cemeteries, and
OLV Basilica (the “Ridge Road Property”), and (2) three parcels that total
approximately 0.58 acres located at 1362, 1366 and 1370 McKinley Parkway, in the City,
Erie County owned by the Diocese (the “McKinley Properties”). Pursuant to the City’s
Zoning Map, the Ridge Road Property is situated in both the Central Business District
and Open Space zoning districts, and the McKinley Properties are situated in the Mixed
Residential zoning district. The Applicants submit this joint application to (1) subdivide
the Ridge Road Property into 5 separate lots in order to facilitate the sale of a portion of
the Ridge Road Property and establish lot lines that more accurately reflect the current
owners (the “Ridge Road Subdivision”), and (2) reconfigure the McKinley Properties
into 2 newly configured lots in order to sell the McKinley Properties and establish lot
lines that correspond with the current use and occupancy of those lots (the “McKinley
Subdivision”).
As such, on behalf of the Applicants, and as set forth more fully below, we submit this
letter of intent and supporting documentation in accordance with Chapter 144, Article
II], Section 144-4 of the City of Lackawanna Municipal Code for approval of the
LINDSEY E. HAUBENREICH
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
ONE CANALSIDE 125 MAIN STREET BUFFALO, NEW YORK 14203-2887 PHONE (716) 847-8400 FAX (716) 852-6100 | PHILLIPSLYTLE.COM
NEW YORK: ALBANY, BUFFALO, CHAUTAUQUA, GARDEN CITY, NEW YORK, ROCHESTER | WASHINGTON, DC | CANADA: WATERLOO REGION
Page 82
[Fell
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 2
proposed Ridge Road Subdivision and approval of the proposed McKinley Subdivision
(“Application”). Enclosed please find the following exhibits attached hereto and made
part hereof:
Exhibit A: — Site Surveys
Exhibit B: — Proposed Subdivision Plats
PROJECT DETAILS
Applicants / Owners: Our Lady of Victory Homes of Charity d/b/a OLV
Charities, Our Lady of Victory Renaissance Corporation, The
Diocese of Buffalo, N.Y., and Our Lady of Victory National
Shrine
Applicant Address: 780 Ridge Road
Lackawanna, New York 14218
Attorney Contact: Phillips Lytle LLP
Attention: Lindsey E. Haubenreich, Esq.
125 Main Street
Buffalo, New York 14203-2887
E-mail:
Bond, Schoeneck & King, PLLC
Attention: Sarah B. Wheeler, Esq.
200 Delaware Avenue, Suite 900
Buffalo, New York 14202
Page 83
[ell
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 3
Project Location: 781 Ridge Road (Ridge Road Property), and 1362, 1366 and
1370 McKinley Parkway (McKinley Properties)
Lackawanna, New York 14218
S.B.L.s: 142.10-1-12.111 (Ridge Road Property)
142.31-3-11, 142.31-3-12, 142.31-3-13 (McKinley Properties)
Zoning District: Central Business District and Open Space (Ridge Road
Property), and Mixed Residential (McKinley Properties)
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
The Ridge Road Property and the McKinley Properties are the site of the former Father
Baker campus, and include the Our Lady of Victory National Shrine, the Holy Cross
Cemetery, and various buildings leased and occupied by OLV Charities and OLV
Renaissance. As the City is aware, the Diocese has filed for bankruptcy. In connection
with the bankruptcy proceedings, the Diocese now seeks to sell portions of the Ridge
Road Property and the McKinley Properties to OLV Charities and OLV Renaissance.
The Ridge Road Subdivision
The Applicants propose to subdivide the Ridge Road Property into five separate lots in
order to facilitate the sale of portions of the Ridge Road Property to OLV Charities and
OLV Renaissance, and to formalize the separation of the OLV Basilica land.
As depicted below, the proposed Ridge Road Subdivision will divide the existing tax
parcel into five lots to better align the legal lot configuration with the Ridge Road
Property's existing ownership, occupancy, and operational conditions. Importantly, the
proposed subdivision does not contemplate any change in the existing use or
occupancy of the Ridge Road Property. Rather, the five resulting lots will continue to be
used and occupied consistent with existing conditions.
Page 84
[ell
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 4
Proposed lots 1 and 4 will be purchased by OLV Charities, who currently leases and
occupies these lots. Proposed lot 2 will be purchased by OLV Renaissance, who
currently leases and occupies this lot. Proposed lot 3 was previously deeded to the
OLV Basilica, but was not formally subdivided from the larger Ridge Road Property.
Finally, Proposed lot 5, the Holy Cross Cemetery, will be retained by its titled owner.
The McKinley Subdivision
In addition, the Applicants propose to reconfigure the McKinley Properties from three
lots into two newly configured lots in order to facilitate the sale of the McKinley
Properties to OLV Charities and OLV Renaissance, and establish lot lines that
correspond with the current use and occupancy of those lots.
As depicted below, the proposed McKinley Subdivision will reconfigure the existing
three tax parcels into two, newly configured lots to align with the existing occupancy,
Page 85
[ell
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 5
and operational conditions. Importantly, the proposed subdivision does not
contemplate any change in the existing use or occupancy of the McKinley Properties.
Rather, the resulting lots will continue to be used and occupied consistent with existing
conditions.
ICWAY
(17 #00 PAR
MCKINLEY
i
1700"
BAKER (25° wer) ALLEY
The northern part of the parcels, as shown in white above, will be acquired by OLV
Charities. The southern part of the parcels, as shown in yellow above, will be acquired
by OLV Renaissance, who currently leases and occupies this area.
Overall, no change in the existing use or occupancy of the Ridge Road Property or the
McKinley Properties is proposed as part of the Application, and conditions following
subdivision will remain substantially the same as exist today.
Page 86
[Ell
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 6
SUBDIVISION APPLICATION PROCESS AND REQUIREMENTS
Pursuant to Chapter 144, Article III, Section 144-4 of the City of Lackawanna Municipal
Code (“Code”), where a subdivision is proposed, an application must be submitted to
the Office of the Director of Development of the City of Lackawanna, and must contain
all components listed at section 144-5(B)(1) of the Code. Accordingly, the Applicants
submit this application for approval of the proposed subdivision incorporating all
required elements.
STATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY REVIEW ACT
Pursuant to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (“SEQRA”), we
respectfully submit that the Project is a Type II Action as it is a lot line adjustment. See
6 NYCRR § 617.5(c)(16). As such, no further SEQRA review is required.
GENERAL MUNICIPAL LAW REFERRAL
To the extent that this Application requires referral to the Erie County Department of
Environment & Planning, we respectfully request that this Application be so submitted.
Page 87
rel!
City of Lackawanna, Planning
Board November 2, 2026
Page 7
CONCLUSION
On behalf of the Applicant, we respectfully request the Planning Board to commence its
subdivision review process and place this matter on the next available Planning Board
agenda, and upon completion, issue approval for the Project.
Very truly yours,
Phillips Lytle LLP
Lindsey E. Haubenreich
Page 88
NOTE: THIS SURVEY WAS PREPARED WITHOUT THE (NOTE UNAUTHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION TO THIS
BENEFIT OF AN ABSTRACT OF TITLE. DOCUMENT IS A VIOLATION OF SECTION 7209 PROVISION 2
OF THE NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION LAW.
® SET OR EX, 5/8” REBAR
Y
° moc) PARKWA
MCKINLEY (150
otCd
, 40.3"'_= <a
40.25" — DRIVE! exnn
15" x.
40. 1841) o6e'E
EX, Ip =
73'S yy
Ose 8 NN
i is
| ASPHALT DRIVE
I
FENOE .
13EN | B50" $1.26
CHAINUNK FENCE (7YP.}} FRAME
SuL14 S.L.16 | Gace =O8
|__3a.22
W000 Febiots | / anw
| |
MAP COVER|634 & ZA N
N MAP COVER |634
goaua gS
3 —a
WOOD FENCE-
5.06%,
FRAME “
cArace &
SL13 S18 5.L.25
5.80°H|
WOOD GATE:
= :
—~—J9G,00" To’ EAST LINE- 120.00"
SOUTH PARK AVE,
BAKER 25’ wor) ALLEY
SURVEY OF
SUB LOTS 17-22, MAP COVER 634
PART OF LOT 283, TOWNSHIP 10, RANGE 7
BUFFALO CREEK INDIAN RESERVATION
CITY OF LACKAWANNA, ERIE COUNTY, NEW YORK
DATE REVISION/TYPE GPI ENGINEERING, LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE & SURVEYING, LLP
P. ENGINEERING « SURVEYING + LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
4950 GENESEE STREET, SUITE 100
BUFFALO, NEW YORK 14225
(716) 633-4844 FAX 633-4940
Job No. 8995-3 Date: SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
Scale: 1" = 40’ TAX No. 142,31-3-11,12&13)
Page 89
| ar
7
asa
BAKER (2s ine) ALLEY
i
hT
SOUTH PARK (os woe AVENUE
HRI He
‘aA
RIDGE cs' woe) ROAD
Page 90
i
3 i i ly :
be,
=
A4 JL
puke fre Le|
SOUTH PARK "oy
A
SLE Yeer —
os 24 ERLUTTULJUUEQ
(LUTTE
2.
=I
i
ateis
= |__|
nS
il
fl
5
ee
ual
a
i 5
d
| i ap uf 1
pen H‘
hy : f
“BL Mem
Yo
i
I N
a
WLlLL t I
a
moet woe tE
tL
H MTPTTT G Sa i
ee
| i |
He is
t
rei
S
E
HI = 11
HLL
iD
|
=E
==
|
am =
ip
T E
E
I
LELEEULL +
Len LF CCEA
T tA,
4h
WL IT |a| | ald| | i
|r
|
i
|
|
Page 91
NOTE: THIS SURVEY WAS PREPARED WITHOUT THE NOTE: UNAUTHORIZED ALTERATION OR ADDITION TO THIS
GENEFIT OF AN ABSTRACT OF TITLE. DOCUMENT IS A VIOLATION OF SECTION 7209 PROVISION 2
OF THE NEW YORK STATE EDUCATION LAW.
© SET OR EX. 5/8” REBAR
9” WIDE) PARKWAY
MCKINLEY (5
VABOITRARY
40.15"
EX. IPI
O.73'S
OSE
ASPHALT DRIVE
|
FENCE Fa
y r 2 STORY
besaslid "© BRICK /FRAME SL. 26
ie
[CHAINLINK FENCE (TYP, HOUSE
S14 S.L16 FRAME 8 No. 1558
7 GARAGE
et 3922
wooo FENCE I T
= ; | 3} | 671 2626
>
x L | f bs
bo | | MAP COVER | 63:
4,
MAP COVER |634
Ss
8 xy
aa 8 : 3
8 |
S.L.20 | CyM SL.22 SL 24
WOOD FENCE:
5.06" 7
GUARDRAIL
7
cs
FRAME © c y fe
GARAGE & wf
SLI3 SL.15 S.L.23 SL25
5.80'W,
W000 GATE:
\
= OFF a oF OF OA
——590.00° TO’ EAST LINE-
SOUTH PARK AVE.
BAKER 25° woe) ALLEY
SURVEY OF
SUB LOTS 17-22, MAP COVER 634
PART OF LOT 283, TOWNSHIP 10, RANGE 7
BUFFALO CREEK INDIAN RESERVATION
CITY OF LACKAWANNA, ERIE COUNTY, NEW YORK
DATE REVISION /TYPE GPI ENGINEERING, LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECTURE & SURVEYING, LLP
P, ENGINEERING « SURVEYING « LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE
4950 GENESEE STREET, SUITE 100
BUFFALO, NEW YORK 14225
(716) 633-4844 FAX 633-4940
Job No. 8995-3 Date: SEPTEMBER 23, 2026
Scale: 1" = 40° TAX No. 142.31-3-11,12&13