Southtowns Record

Zoning Board of Appeals agenda packet — November 18, 2026

Government
City of Lackawanna
Board
Zoning Board of Appeals
Meeting
Nov 18, 2026
Kind
Agenda packet
Topics
Zoning and land use, Housing, Water, sewer and drainage

Original document

Same meeting

Text · page 8 of 27

Read the whole document on one page (all 27 pages, each with its own heading)

This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.

CASH4CARS WNY LLC — USE VARIANCE RESPONSES

Property: 2504 South Park Avenue, Lackawanna, NY 14218  SBL: 142.23-1-3

Applicant: Evan Walton, Owner, Cash4Cars WNY LLC

Property owner: 2504 South Park Ave LLC

Proposed use: A small, low-traffic administrative office for a newly DMV-approved business proposing
primarily online used-vehicle purchasing and resale, with three designated parking spaces (per DMV
requirements). On-site customer activity would be very limited, with minimal, small signage. No inspections,
repairs, or vehicle servicing would occur on the property at any time.

1. What facts support that the applicant cannot realize a reasonable return?
Cash4Cars WNY LLC recenily received approval from the New York State DMV. It has not yet begun
vehicle sales or received its dealer plate. The building at its current registered location, 1166 Abbott Road in
Buffalo, is being sold, creating uncertainty about whether the business may remain there. The proposed
South Park location would accommodate a smail administrative office and three designated parking spaces.
These circumstances explain the need to establish a new location; they do not, by themselves, establish
that the South Park property cannot earn a reasonable return from uses permitted under its current zoning.
Any financial evidence required to demonstrate that standard would need to be provided by the property
owner or other appropriate party.

2. Why is the alleged hardship unique to this property?
The proposed South Park location has been identified as a potential site for a limited office-based operation
with three designated parking spaces, rather than a conventional automobile sales lot. The applicant
requests consideration of the specific proposed use and site conditions. No unique physical or economic
hardship affecting this property is asserted without supporting documentation.

3. Will the variance alter the essential character of the neighborhood?

The proposed operation is not expected to materially alter the neighborhood's character. When operations
begin, vehicle purchases and sales would be handled primarily online or remotely. On-site customer visits
would be very limited, signage would be small and unobtrusive, and only three parking spaces would be
designated for the business. No inspections, repairs, or vehicle servicing would occur on the property at any
time.