February 17, 2026 Minutes (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
TOWN OF ELMA PLANNING BOARD
1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York 14059
Phone: 716-652-3260
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING ~February 17, 2026
The Regular Meeting of the Town of Elma Planning Board, hereinafter referred to as the EPB, was held
on Tuesday, February 17, 2026, at 6:57 PM in the Elma Town Hall at 1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York.
PRESENT:
Chairman Michael Cirocco TOWN REPRESENTATIVES PRESENT
Member Gregory Merkle Phyllis Todoro - Town Attorney
Member James Millard Raymond Balcerzak - Asst Building Inspector
Member Charles Putzbach James Wyzykiewicz — Town Engineer
Member Robert Waver
Alternate James Lembke
ABSENT: Member Michael Cleary
L Approval of Regular Meeting Minutes from November 18, 2025
Mr. Putzbach motioned to approve the Minutes of the EPB Regular Meeting held on November 18, 2025.
Mr. Waver 2nd motion. Motion approved.
Il. Site Plan Review for an addition for St. Paul’s Lutheran Church @ 370 Main St
Applicant- Robert Breidenstein
Jim Bammel of Bammel Architects has worked with St. Paul’s for over a year since the church burned
down.
The project is a site plan review for the reconstruction of St. Paul's Lutheran Church at 370 Main
Street, following a fire that destroyed the original church.
The new sanctuary and two new bathrooms will be added behind the existing parish hall. The
previous church had no plumbing.
The plan includes necessary parking for events and the congregation.
Changes Since Preliminary Approval
e The building was downsized
e Ancillary spaces, classrooms, and meeting rooms were removed entirely.
e The “Narthex” (connector space) between the existing building and the new addition
was reduced from 40 feet to 20 feet.
Page 2
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (2/17/2026)
Page 2
I. Site Plan Review for_an addition for St. Paul’s Lutheran Church @ 370 Main St
(Continued) Applicant- Robert Breidenstein
Approvals and Documentation
e The fire department's approval was received via email.
e Erie County approvals, including the septic design, have been submitted.
e A letter from the Elma Water Department was referred to but not included in the board’s
packet.
e There was discussion about whether a drainage district is needed.
e Town engineer verbally approved the drainage
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. The answers for question #12 & #13 were changed and initialed by the
applicant representative. Mr. Cirocco made a motion to check box #2 on the SEQR, the motion was seconded by
Mr. Lembke. Yes-6 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by Gregory Merkle and Seconded by James Millard to give final site plan approval
contingent on a letter of approval from Elma Water. Yes-6- No-0 Motion Carried
Ill. Site Plan Review for adding a 9 vs 9 soccer field @ 7110 Seneca St for Sahlen’s Sports
Park Applicant Jim Bammel
Applicant: Jim Bammel of Bammel Architects representing Sahlen’s for athletic fields at 7110 Seneca
Street.
e The plan includes improved drainage with better grading; roadside cut directs flow back toward
the field; field graded at ~8% pitch suitable for professional turf; series of flat drains leading
west to a drainpipe to an existing ditch.
e Fencing for softball with a 4-foot fence at the home run wall. A temporary fence will allow for an
overlay soccer field.
e Lighting: 60-foot poles; fixtures include heads at top and lower mounts; coverage guaranteed
for play. Dark sky compliance: Dark sky friendly; light spill under 1 foot-candle at the street; all
fixtures shielded.
e Parking: The design includes additional parking near the field for teams. The parking ties into
existing parking lot and parking is considered sufficient. Practical considerations: Attendees
will park where convenient. Overload parking is located closer to the field; street parking not
sensible; property access is at the far end.
e Applicant reaffirmed parking for both teams available near the field on overload.
e Existing house: Remains on property
e Fire department access: Marked N/A due to open site and multiple access points; no
structures necessitating specific fire access.
e Aspecial use permit required for the project has already been approved by Elma Town Board
Page 3
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (2/17/2026)
Page 3
JIT, Site Plan Review for adding a 9 vs 9 soccer field @ 7110 Seneca St for Sahlen’s Sports
Park Applicant Jim Bammel (Continued)
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. Mr. Cirocco made a motion to check box #2 on the SEQR; the motion
was seconded by Mr. Millard. Yes-6 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by Robert Waver and Seconded by James Lembke to give final site plan approval
Yes-6- No-0 Motion Carried
IV. Adjourn
Motion to adjourn at 7:21 PM by unanimous consent.
Respectfully submitted,
Baten Bloer
Barbara Blair
Elma Planning Board Secretary