March 17, 2026 Minutes (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
TOWN OF ELMA PLANNING BOARD
1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York 14059
Phone: 716-652-3260
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING ~March 17, 2026
The Regular Meeting of the Town of Elma Planning Board, hereinafter referred to as the EPB, was held
on Tuesday, March 17, 2026, at 7:00 PM in the Elma Town Hall at 1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York.
PRESENT: TOWN REPRESENTATIVES PRESENT
Chairman Michael Cirocco Phyllis Todoro - Town Attorney
Member James Millard Raymond Balcerzak - Asst Building Inspector
Member Charles Putzbach James Wyzykiewicz— Town Engineer
Alternate James Lembke
ABSENT: Member Michael Cleary, Member Gregory Merkle, Member Robert Waver
L Approval of Regular Meeting Minutes from February 17, 2026
Mr. Millard motioned to approve the Minutes of the EPB Regular Meeting held on February 17, 2026.
Mr. Putzbach 2nd motion. Motion approved.
Il. Site plan review for a 60’ x 100’ storage building for Oakgrove Construction @ 6900
Seneca St Applicant : Joshua Brown
e The board reviewed the site plan for a new 6,000-square-foot storage building proposed by Oakgrove
Construction. The proposed building is for storing equipment and materials, such as wood forms for bridge
construction, to protect them from the weather. The structure will have two large overhead doors, one man
door, and no windows. Lighting will consist of interior lights and potential floodlights over the doors. The
color will match an existing building on the property.
e The board reviewed the site plan checklist, noting the property is in an industrial zone, has sufficient
parking, requires no new curb cuts, and has no wetland or drainage issues.
e The board also determined the project would not have any significant environmental impact.
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by James Millard to give preliminary site plan approval
Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. James Millard made a motion to check box #2 on the SEQR; the motion
was seconded by James Lembke. Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by James Millard and Seconded by Charles Putzbach to give final site plan approval
contingent on approval from the fire department. Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
Page 2
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (3/17/2026)
Page 2
II. Site plan review for a shed display for Macaluso’s Garage @ 5710 Seneca St
Applicant Jay Macaluso
e The board reviewed a site plan presented by Jay Macaluso and his tenant, Brian Reinford of Northwood
Structures, to display 10-12 sheds for sale at 5710 Seneca Street.
¢ The property owner, Mr. Macaluso, is downsizing the car and RV sales business and will use the space
to display sheds for Northwood Structures, a small family business.
e The display is for sales purposes only; there will be no permanent office on-site. Signage will be limited
to temporary banners and small signs on the sheds indicating size and price.
e A key discussion point was an old, unused driveway on the property that people use as a cut-through.
The applicant agreed to the board’s recommendation to remove the old pavement and plant grass to
block access and improve aesthetics.
e The board reviewed the site plan checklist, noting the approval does not require a letter from the fire
department as the access and use are not significantly changing.
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Charles Putzbach to give preliminary site plan
approval Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by James Lembke and Seconded by Charles Putzbach to give final site plan approval
Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
IV. Site plan review for a 31,000 S. F. addition to Crossroads Christian Church @ 1050
Girdle Rd Applicant Pat Kleitz
Pastor Pat Kleitz and Douglas Klotzbach from K2 Architecture presented the site plan. The church expansion, a
project 38 years in the making, involves a 31,000 sq ft addition to create a large auditorium and gymnasium
complex. The new facility, connected to the existing building via a lobby, will have a combined seating capacity
of 1,400 for special events like high school graduations. This was made possible by acquiring and merging an
adjacent lot to create a 14-acre property, complying with the 15% building coverage limit. The board reviewed
detailed architectural plans, discussed potential community use, and addressed concerns about traffic for large
events. Following a thorough review of the preliminary site plan, which included discussions on parking
calculations, drainage district requirements, and exterior finishes, the board granted preliminary approval. The
applicant was given clear instructions on items needed for final approval, such as obtaining letters from the water,
health, and fire departments.
e The architectural design connects a new pre-engineered steel building to the existing structure via a new
lobby. The new building’s roofline is lowered to complement the original church aesthetically.
e For final approval, the applicant must provide detailed parking calculations, investigate the creation or
extension of a drainage district for the property, and obtain approval letters from the Elma Water
Department, Erie County Health Department, and the local fire department.
e They must provide detailed renderings showing exterior colors and materials, including a planned
outdoor pavilion.
e A motion was made by James Millard and Seconded by James Lembke to give preliminary site plan
approval Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
Page 3
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (3/17/2026)
Page 3
Vz Sketch plan review to convert an existing 2-unit dwelling to a 4-unit dwelling @ 6177
Seneca St Applicant Todd Huber
Mr. Huber presented a project to redevelop a property on Seneca Street into a four-unit apartment building by
renovating an existing post-and-beam structure that used to be a church. This project falls under a special
procedure requiring Town Board approval, with the Planning Board’s role being to provide a recommendation.
The applicant plans to combine two lots (6175 & 6177 Seneca Street) but noted the project cannot meet several
design standards in the Spring Brook overlay code, such as minimum lot depth and maximum impervious lot
coverage (estimated at 75-80%). They decided to recommend approval to the Town Board, suggesting that the
non-compliant items be “grandfathered” or waived, and stipulating that the lot combination is a necessary
contingency.
e The existing building is approximately nineteen hundred square feet per floor. It will have a loft on the
third floor; The building will need to have sprinklers.
The project involves renovating an existing building, which will not meet code for lot depth and will
exceed the 50% maximum impervious surface limit (estimated at 75-80%). The board felt these
deviations were acceptable and could be “grandfathered.”
The approval process falls under a special procedure. The Planning Board’s official action is to make a
formal recommendation, after which the Town Board will hold a public hearing (scheduled for mid-
April 2026)
A key contingency for the project is the legal combination of the two separate parcels (6175 and 6177
Seneca Street) into a single lot.
A drainage district will need to be formed for the new combined parcel and will need the approval from
the town engineer for the drainage plan.
It was noted that the building-mounted lighting and proposed parking were satisfactory
If the new garage does not meet the required 10” set back the applicant will be required to seek a
variance for the new garage’s rear setback.
EPB reviewed the planning board checklist:
Documentation: Applicant has applied to the Elma Town Board for a preliminary use permit. The Elma
town Board needs to hold a public hearing before the project can be approved
Zoning: property is zoned C-1 and is in the Spring Brook Multiple Dwelling Overlay
Site & Building Details: Wil| need a new stamped survey showing combined properties, property details
and layout of multiple buildings provided. It is an existing building so no engineered blueprints are needed.
A proposed picture of the exterior was provided. Layout/details of individual units not provided.
Lighting: No details of lighting on the plans. Applicant says no lighting beyond what is existing
Parking: No new curb cut. The applicant plans to build a 5-car garage. 4 spaces will be used for the multi-
dwelling building and 1 for the other single-family residence on the property. A variance from the zoning
board will be needed for the new garage setback if it does not meet the required 10’ from the back property
line. No blueprints or information about the new garage were provided. Applicant says it will have vinyl
siding and brick.
Drainage: No wetlands on the property. Will need approval from the town engineer. Will need to form a
drainage district for the new parcel.
Page 4
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (3/17/2026)
Page 4
V. Sketch plan review to convert an existing 2-unit dwelling to a 4-unit dwelling @ 6177
Seneca St (Continued) Applicant Todd Huber
EPB reviewed the planning board checklist:
Signage: No signage on the plan. Applicant says he may put a Springbrook sign.
Landscaping: Applicant is not planning to have a dumpster on the site.
Water Service & Septic System: New proposed septic system shown on site plan. No letters from Elma
Water or Erie County Health Department provided
Fire Department: No approval letter provided
After reviewing the Site Plan, The Elma Planning Board site plan checklist and the multiple dwelling code for
the Spring Brook overlay the Elma Planning Board recommends that the Elma Town Board approve the plan to
convert a 2-unit dwelling into a 4-unit dwelling at 6177 Seneca St. The EPB acknowledges the following
deviations from the zoning requirements and design standards as stated in Elma Town Code 144-142.14: the lot
exceeds the required square footage but does not meet the required lot depth, the imperious surface will exceed
50% of the lot and the existing building does not meet the front setback. The Planning Board reviewed these non-
compliant aspects and concluded that the project’s overall quality and alignment with the overlay’s design intent
outweighed the technical deviations. The EPB recommended waiving the code’s tree requirement as per the
landscaping section (J) of code 144-142.14.
The following items will need to be provided and approved before final site plan can be given: The two parcels
need to be combined into one parcel, a new stamped survey of the new property needs to be provided, a drainage
district needs to be formed, approval from the town engineer, approval of a variance from the Elma Zoning Board
for the new garage setbacks.
A motion was made by James Millard and Seconded by Michael Cirocco to give the above recommendation to
the Elma Town Board Yes-4 No-0 Motion Carried
VI. Adjourn
Motion to adjourn at 9:23 PM by unanimous consent.
Respectfully submitted,
Barbara Blair
Elma Planning Board Secretary