May 19, 2026 Minutes (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
TOWN OF ELMA PLANNING BOARD
1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York 14059
Phone: 716-652-3260
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING ~May 19, 2026
The Regular Meeting of the Town of Elma Planning Board, hereinafier referred to as the EPB, was held
on Tuesday, May 19, 2026, at 7:03 PM in the Elma Town Hall at 1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York.
PRESENT: TOWN REPRESENTATIVES PRESENT
Member Michael Cleary Phyllis Todoro - Town Attorney
Member Gregory Merkle James Wyzykiewicz — Town Engineer
Member James Millard
Member Charles Putzbach ABSENT:
Member Robert Waver Chairman Michael Cirocco
Alternate James Lembke
Raymond Balcerzak - Asst Building Inspector
L Approval of Regular Meeting Minutes from April 19, 2026
Mr. Merkle motioned to approve the Minutes of the EPB Regular Meeting held on April 19, 2026. Mr.
Cleary 2nd motion. Motion approved.
I. Site plan review for a 60’ x 115’ storage building for Cellino Plumbing @ 611 Bullis Rd
Applicant : Lucas Cellino
No applicant present
III. Siteplan review for a 50’ x 80’ addition for Transit Auto Detail @ 2161 Transit Rd
Applicant Al Hassan
The applicant, Al Hassan, plans a used car sales, towing, auto repair, and collision service business at
2161 Transit Road. Two existing buildings will remain, and an old roofless garage on-site will be
eliminated. A new 50’ x 80’ building will be added. Applicant is in the process of purchasing the
property and provided an updated letter of intent to purchase. The high ceiling existing garage will be
used to service tow trucks. The other building will include 2 bays for a repair shop, 2 for collision shop
and 1 for storage. The exterior colors will likely be gray, beige, or black.
Under C-3: automotive service/public garage uses require Planning Board approval after public hearing
(Code 144-86 A(8)(a)). Business Use Permit application submitted; public hearing expected at Town
Board. No gasoline pumps proposed; no volatile materials storage; no propane; no marine/RV
The checklist:
Documentation: Has applied to the town for a “Special Use Permit.”
Zoning: C-3 with automotive overlay, need to verify if entire parcel is C-3 orjust the first 300 feet
Page 2
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (5/19/2026)
Page 2
III. Siteplan review for a 50’ x 80’ addition for Transit Auto Detail @ 2161 Transit Rd
Applicant Al Hassan (Continued)
Site & Building Details: Applicant to submit updated site plan with revised dimensions and layout and
removal of roofless garage.
Lighting: need lighting locations on the site plan and details of lighting specs
Parking: Two-way traffic through both existing curb cuts. Need details of parking on site plan including
dimensions and layout
Drainage: Engineering drainage/elevations not yet prepared; need to show stormwater direction and
management. SEQR indicates no wetlands; town to verify against updated map. Need approval from town
engineer
Signage: Future building-mounted sign contemplated; no freestanding sign proposed for the addition at
this time. Apply to Building Department for sign permit when ready.
Landscaping: Need dumpster location with required screening on plan; Need details of fence
type/height/location (likely 8 ft solid metal for impound) and landscaping depiction. The applicant plans
to leave some woods on both sides as a buffer.
Water Service & Septic System: Water service needed for new building; no new bathrooms in addition;
existing septic remains for front building (three bathrooms). Need letter from Elma Water Department.
Fire Department: Fire department access to new building not yet reviewed. Nearest hydrants identified
along Transit (corner at Seneca & Transit). Needs approval letter from fire department.
IV. Site plan review for an addition and pavilion to Crossroads Christian Church @ 1050
Girdle Rd Applicant Pat Kleitz
The applicant presented a revised site plan for the Crossroads Church expansion, which received
preliminary approval on 2026-03-17. Key changes include reducing the size of the initial addition
(narthex/entry area) and building only the multipurpose room for now. The new auditorium and lobby
expansion are designated as future phases. A new pavilion (an open, pole-barn style structure) is also part
of the current plan. The septic system design is being managed by Metzger Engineering, who will explore
expanding the existing system as suggested by the county. Parking has been reconfigured, reducing new
pavement. The property ownership is changing, with a parcel being separated and deeded to “Father’s
Heart,” a nonprofit, to create one contiguous parcel. The plan has undergone significant changes, requiring
a restart of the review process.
The checklist:
Site & Building Details: Need dimensions for the new buildings on the site plan
Lighting: Need detailed lighting plans for building exteriors and the sign. The applicant confirmed that
new lighting will be limited to downlights under an entry canopy and on a sign.
Parking: Were changes to the parking from the original plan. No new traffic patterns or curb cuts.
Drainage: Need engineer report. Town engineer gave a verbal ok to the plan. Need a SWPPP.
Signage: Will be a lite cross on the front of the building. Need lighting details
Landscaping: Need a definite location and screening/enclosure plan for the dumpster. The only
landscaping will be grass.
Page 3
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (5/19/2026)
Page 3
IV. Site plan review for an addition and pavilion to Crossroads Christian Church @ 1050
Girdle Rd Applicant Pat Kleitz (Continued)
Water Service & Septic System: The septic system design is being managed by Metzger Engineering,
who will explore expanding the existing system as suggested by the county. Need approval letters from
Erie County Health Department and the Elma Water Department.
Fire Department: Need approval letter from the fire department. Need hydrant shown on plan.
The applicant expressed an urgent desire to begin construction on the new pavilion before the summer to
replace an existing tent. The board explained that there was too much outstanding information to give
final site plan approval of the comprehensive site plan.
They inquired if the pavilion could be approved and permitted separately from the larger project. The
board explained that because the pavilion was submitted as part of the comprehensive site plan, it cannot
be approved independently without a new, standalone application. A building permit cannot be issued
without final site plan approval for the entire project.
Applicant was advised to submit all the items needed before the deadline and get on the agenda for the
next meeting in June. The applicant acknowledged the list and will provide the missing information for
the next meeting.
Mr. Millard made a motion to give preliminary site plan approval; the motion was seconded by Mr. Waver.
Yes-6 No-0 Motion Carried
Vz Other Business
Mr. Bob Gross expressed frustration about not being on the agenda. He stated he followed the correct
procedure by submitting paperwork to the building inspector and was put on the agenda, only to be
removed by the chairman, Mike. He feels he is being discriminated against and was denied his right to be
heard. The board responded that the chairman reviewed his submission, felt it contained no new
information, and therefore he was not on the final agenda. The exchange became heated, with Mr. Gross
mentioning legal action.
Adjourn
Motion to adjourn at 8:17 PM by unanimous consent.
Respectfully submitted,
Barbara Blair
Elma Planning Board Secretary