July 21, 2026 Minutes (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
TOWN OF ELMA PLANNING BOARD
1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York 14059
Phone: 716-652-3260
MINUTES OF REGULAR MEETING ~July 21, 2026
The Regular Meeting of the Town of Elma Planning Board, hereinafter referred to as the EPB, was held
on Tuesday, July 21, 2026, at 7:00 PM in the Elma Town Hall at 1600 Bowen Road, Elma, New York.
PRESENT:
Chairman Michael Cirocco
Fa ae Poatd TOWN REPRESENTATIVES
fember Charles Putzbaci
Member Robert Waver FTV
Alternate James Lembke Phyllis Todoro - Town Attorney
Raymond Balcerzak -Asst Building Inspector
ABSENT: James Wyzykiewicz — Town Engineer
Member Gregory Merkle
Member James Millard
I Approval of Regular Meeting Minutes from June 16, 2026
Mr. Putzbach motioned to approve the Minutes of the EPB Regular Meeting held on June 16, 2026. Mr.
Lembke 2nd motion. Motion approved.
II. Site plan review to convert an existing 2-unit dwelling to a 4-unit dwelling @ 6177
Seneca St Applicant Todd Huber
Mr. Huber returned for final approval for a plan to convert a 2 unit dwelling into 4 units. He has received
variances from the Elma Zoning Board for the setbacks for both a new garage and new side decks. Final
approval from the Erie County Health Department is still pending.
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Robert Waver to give preliminary site plan
approval Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. James Lembke made a motion to check box #2 on the SEQR; the
motion was seconded by Michael Cleary. Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Michael Cleary to give final site plan
approval contingent on approval from the Erie County Health Department. Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
Page 2
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (7/21/2026)
Page2
Mr. Robert Gross asked the board when he would be allowed to speak. Chairman Cirocco told him he
would not be allowed to speak. Chairman Cirocco told Mr. Gross he was out of order and asked him to
leave the meeting. He refused to leave and was escorted from the meeting by a law enforcement officer.
Chairman Cirocco sited that New York State Open meeting laws do not require the public be allowed to
speak.
Il. Site Plan Review/Recommendation for a partial rezone of 850 Bullis Rd for K & R
Trucking to build a top-soil storage building Applicant Brad Day
Mr. Brad Day presented a plan to build an addition to an office and build a building for topsoil and salt.
His proposal is for the property behind a current easement on the property to be rezoned.
Chairman Cirocco proposed to maintain a section along Beech Rd as residential to provide a buffer of at
least 100 feet.
Chairman Cirocco states that the Elma Planning Board is recommending the rezone to C-2 be approved
and the applicant be consideredfor a special use permit in that zone. Yes-5 No-0
IV. Site Plan Review for a 24’ x 96’ green house @ 6581 Seneca St for Seneca Greenhouses
Applicant Rick Flett
Rick Flett, owner of Seneca Greenhouse, presented a plan to build an additional 24’ x 96’ greenhouse. It
will be identical to the existing greenhouses on the property. EPB reviewed the checklist.
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Michael Cleary to give preliminary site plan
approval Yes-4 No-0 Abstain-Waver Motion Carried
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. James Lembke made a motion to check box #2 on the SEQR; the
motion was seconded by Michael Cleary. Yes-4 No-0 Abstain-Waver Motion Carried
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Michael Cleary to give final site plan
approval contingent on approval from the fire department. Yes-4 No-0 Abstain-Waver
Motion Carried
Site Plan Review for fill and expansion of 2.44 acres ofpaved parking lot for The Cove
@_4071 Transit Rd Applicant John Schenne
John Schenne, engineer, Bryan Page owner of The Cove and Todd Huber introduced themselves. Todd
Huber gave a history of the business at this location and stated the current need for additional parking.
The property owner, Bryan Page, is looking to fill an adjacent lot and create 150 additional parking spaces.
It is expected to require at least 35,000 cubic yards of fill. Mr. Page provided letters from the US Army
Corp of Engineers, and the Department of Environmental Conservation showing property is not federal
or state wetlands. They will be building a temporary construction of access road but do not have a permit
Page 3
Town of Elma Planning Board Minutes (7/21/2026)
Page 3
Site Plan Review for fill and expansion of 2.44 acres of paved parking lot for The Cove
@4071 Transit Rd (Continued) Applicant John Schenne
for a new curb cut. Parking lot will have dark sky complaint lighting. A drainage district will need to be
created. A letter from the local fire company is still needed. The EPB reviewed the checklist.
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by Robert Waver to give preliminary site plan
approval Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
The EPB reviewed the short form SEQR. The answers to Part 1 13 A & B were changed, the answer and
the answer to Part Il #10 were changed. Changed and initialed by John Schenne
Michael Cleary made a motion to check box #2 on the SEOR; the motion was seconded by James Lembke.
Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
A motion was made by Michael Cirocco and Seconded by James Lembke to give final site plan approval
contingent on approval from fire department and creation of a drainage district. Property owner
verbally agreed to complete the 2 outstanding items within a reasonable amount of time.
Yes-5 No-0 Motion Carried
VI. Adjourn
Motion to adjourn at 8:15 PM by unanimous consent.
Minutes created from recording of meeting
Respectfully submitted,
Barbara Blair
Elma Planning Board Secretary