Southtowns Record

June 2, 2026 Minutes (full text)

Town of Elma Zoning Board of Appeals Jun 2, 2026 3 pages

This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.

Page 1

ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS chairman, Harry Kwiek This hearing on Tuesday June 2, 2026, called to order by at 7:00 PM. Members Present: Harry Kwiek John Jiminez Greg Kalinowski Shawn Pralow ‘James Lembke, Alternate Members Absent: Ron Carey Also Present: Robert Schaefer, Alternate Phyllis Todoro, Town Attorney Joe Colern Building Inspector Rosemary Bapst, Deputy Town Attorney 31 Pleasantview Drive, East Aurora, NY Appeals case #1501 for Christopher Musilli of than the who was given a continuance for an area variance to build a carport with less required side yard setback Section 144-99 C (4), Residential C. Mr. Musilli provided the Board with a packet of information with an email from Mr. Noah being Mauer, the adjacent owner, indicating that he had no objection to Mr. Musilli’s carport constructed within the setback of five to ten feet from the shared property line. Also, in the packet are several drawings of changes made to the plans including: The length of the carport is thirty-two feet; The carport has been moved back Seven feet from the property line; and Ten feet from his house. this project. Discussions were had concerning Mr. Musilli indicated that he would not be enclosing the sides of the carport in the future. Chairman Kwiek asked if anyone wanted to speak in favor of the project: No one spoke in favor. No one spoke against the variance. Mr. Jimenez made the motion that the variance involving Appeals case #1501 for Christopher Musilli of 31 Pleasantview Drive, East Aurora, NY who was seeking an area variance to build a carport with less than the required side yard setback Section 144-99 Cc (4), Residential C be granted for the following reasons: There is no adverse impact on the neighborhood, no hazard to the health, welfare of the neighborhood; Emergency vehicles still will have access to the property; There is no benefit from other means; and that this defines hardship based upon the contour of the property. Mr. Lembke Seconded the motion. 5 yays; 0 nays. The Board approved the area variance for Mr. Musilli to construct a carport with less than the required side yard setback.

Page 2

, Elma, NY who is requesting Appeals case #1504 for Todd Huber of 6177 Seneca Street garage unit and an an area variance to build a front porch overhang/awning, rear ns 144-142.14 F (1) and attached two-story deck with nonconforming setbacks Sectio ple dwellings). Section 144-78 D, C-1, Springbrook Overlay District (multi of the project with a Todd Huber spoke for the project and handed a revised drawing record. rendering of the proposed project with a survey made a part of the Street, namely, Todd Huber indicated that the project showed 3 different lots. 2 on Seneca Mr. Huber merged 6175 6175 and 6177 Seneca Street and one at 60 Old Pound Road. y larger and is now Seneca Street with 6177 Seneca Street so in effect it made the propert known as 6177 Seneca Street. ted with the plan submitted. Mr. Huber has changed the deck and front overhang as indica is 1 foot in width. He added alittle “deck walk”/ railings which is for aesthetics only and ry spaces Discussion was had concerning the placement of the garage and the necessa indicated that and that 60 Old Pound had a separate driveway which is all paved. Mr. Huber he had redesigned the one side without windows for the neighbor’s privacy. line and the Discussion was had concerning that the garage being 3 feet off the property line. Garage overhang would be 1 foot and the rest would be 2 feet from the property Discussion was had that the appropriate rear set back would be 10 feet after the Springbrook overlay district, so Mr. Huber is asking for a 7 feet variance. Mr. Kwiek asked for anyone in favor: No one spoke. spoke Mr. Kwiek asked for anyone against the variance: Mr. Robert Gross of 11 Northrup against the project. Mr. Gross began speaking of what occurred at the Town Planning Board meeting. Mr. Kwiek redirected him to the fact that this was the Zoning Board and read to him what the Zoning Board was required to do pursuant to N. Y. S. Mr. Gross kept indicating that the code was there for a reason and had to be enforced. He again started to state what occurred at the Town Board and Planning Board. Mr. Gross exchanged words with Joe Colern, Code Enforcement Officer and Phyllis Todoro, Town Attorney. Again Mr. Kwiek tried to redirect Mr. Gross and gave him three minutes to make his arguments. Mr. Gross indicated that the septic system was inadequate. That the Town had to treat people fairly. That because this was a nonconforming lot was no reason to make it a further nonconforming lot by granting the variance. Mr. Gross finished speaking before his 3 minutes were up. Mr. Kalinowski made the motion in Appeals case #1504 for Todd Huber of 6177 Seneca Street, Elma, NY approvithe ng area variance to build a front porch overhang/awning, rear garage unit and an attached two-story deck with nonconforming setbacks Sections 144-142.14 F (1) and Section 144-78 D, C-1, Springbrook Overlay District (multiple dwellings). Mr. Kalinowski cited that there was no other feasible means; that this variance would not produce any undesirable change in the neighborhood; that there would be no adverse effect on the environment involving wetlands and similar issues; this situation has not been self-created and that these structures have been there. Mr. Pralow seconded the motion. 5 yays; 0 nays.

Page 3

front porch The Board approved the area variance for Mr. Huber to build deck in accordance with overhang/awning, rear garage unit and an attached two-story the plan submitted. Russ and who was going Discussion was had about a municipal program by Hodgson in front of the to attend. Also, discuss briefly what future applications may come Board. ed the Mr. Pralow made the motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Jiminez second motion. 5 yays; 0 nays. Meeting was adjourned at 8:05 p.m. Respectfully submitted, R6semary Bapst, uty Town Attorney Drafted but not approved by board.

Back to the document