July 7, 2026 Minutes (full text)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Page 1
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
Amended and approved on August 4, 2026
This hearing on Tuesday July 7, 2026, called to order by chairman, Harry Kwiek
at 7:00 PM with the pledge of allegiance.
Members Present:
Harry Kwiek
John Jimenez
Greg Kalinowski
Shawn Pralow
Ron Carey
Also Present:
Robert Schaefer, Alternate
James Lembke, Alternate
Phyllis Todoro, Town Attorney
Rosemary Bapst, Deputy Town Attorney
Others Absent:
Ray Balcerzak, Assistant Building Inspector
Appeals case #1505 for Eric Hopkins of 2930 Bullis Road, Elma, NY whois requesting a
use variance to obtain a Federal Firearms License for online sale purchases Section
144-51 A(3), Section 144-51 B(1), Residential B.
Mr. Hopkins explained that he wants to have zoning to allow his in home business of buying
and selling guns through the Federal Firearms License (FFL) Type 01 for which he is
applying. He indicated that he has done approximately 8 Sales/year but that he pays other
FFL’s to do the paperwork. When he sells, he pays 15-20% commission depending on
where he goes. To do the paperwork, it costs $50.00 which if he is allowed his use variance
he would be permitted to obtain. Mr. Hopkins indicated that guns would be delivered to his
home and people would pick them up from his home.
Mr. Hopkins Indicated that he would not have a retail store in his home. Mr. Hopkins
indicated that he has been buying and selling guns for about 5 years.
Mr. Carey explained the process for granting a use variance including that he has to prove a
hardship unique to him; that Mr. Hopkins cannot make a reasonable financial return, which
is demonstrated by financial records; that this will not affect the character of the
neighborhood; and that his hardship is not self-created.
Mr. Hopkins indicated that he does not have any financial records and has not filed taxes
on this.
Mr. Hopkins is hoping to have 1-2 people per week.
His present EIN/Federal Identification Number has nothing to do with this proposed
business.
Mr. Hopkins admitted that thus far his buying and selling has operated ata loss.
Mr. Kalinowski indicated that Mr. Hopkin’s business hardship is more of an Opportunity loss
rather than financial. The Board asked several times if he could provide any financial proof
of hardship if adjourned which Mr. Hopkins indicated that he did not have any and that he
needed to rescind his application tomorrow if denied.
Page 2
Mr. Hopkins indicated that he has only bought 8 guns and has not sold any. He does
not
provide guns for raffles.
Mr. Kwiek asked if anyone wanted to speak in favor of the variance.
Robert Gross of 11 Northrup spoke in favor indicating that if the Board denied Mr. Hopkins’
variance it would be discrimination. The house is not going to change anything and then
referred back to last month’s approval of an area variance that he took issue with.
The Board attempted to explain the difference between area and use variances.
No one spoke against the variance.
Mr. Kalinowski made the motion concerning Appeals case #1505 for Eric Hopkins of 2930
Bullis Road, Elma, NY who is requesting a use variance to obtain a Federal Firearms
License for online sale purchases Section 144-51 A(3), Section 144-51 B(1), Residential
B be denied respectfully since unlike an area variance a use variance must prove
injurious state of not making a profit. Mr. Hopkins cannot prove that he cannot make a
reasonable return as shown by competent financial evidence; that alleged hardship is
unique and does not apply to the neighborhood and that the hardship was not self-
created. For those reasons, | am making this motion.
Mr. Pralow Seconded the motion.
4 Yays 7
1 No-Mr. Kwiek
The Board denied the use variance for Mr. Hopkins to obtain a Federal Firearms
License for online sale purchases pursuant to Sections 144-51A(3) and 144-51 B(1).
Mr. Jiminez made a motion to approve the minutes of the Zoning Board of Appeals’
June 2, 2026 meeting.
Mr. Kalinowski seconded the motion
4 Yays
O nays
Mr. Carey abstained since he was not at the meeting.
The June 2, 2026 meeting minutes were approved.
Mr. Jiminez made the motion to adjourn the meeting. Mr. Pralow seconded the
motion.
5 Yays
0 nays
Meeting was adjourned at 7:40 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Rosemary Bapst, Deputy Town Attorney
Drafted but not approved by board.