Southtowns Record

October 6, 2026 Minutes

Government
Town of Elma
Board
Zoning Board of Appeals
Meeting
Oct 6, 2026
Kind
Minutes
Topics
Zoning and land use, Water, sewer and drainage, Roads and traffic

Original document

Same meeting

Motions and votes

Copied word for word from these minutes. Who moved and seconded, the tally and the roll call appear only where the minutes state them. Picked out automatically: the minutes themselves are the record. All votes for this government.

  1. 5 Yays 0 nays The motion carried unanimously.

    Carried unanimously

    Page 2 of the minutes, motion 1

  2. 5 Yays 0 nays The motion carried unanimously. The variance is denied.

    Failed unanimously

    Page 4 of the minutes, motion 2

1 routine motion (minutes, bills, agenda, adjournment…)
  1. Mr. Carey made the motion to approve the minutes from the September 1, 2026 meeting. Mr. Jimenez seconded the motion. 5 Yays 0 nays The motion carried unanimously.

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Mr. Carey, seconded by Mr. Jimenez

    Page 4 of the minutes, motion 3; vote on page 5, motion 3

Text · page 3 of 5

Read the whole document on one page (all 5 pages, each with its own heading)

No one spoke in favor of the variance.

Mr. Kwiek asked if anyone wished to speak against the variance:

Mark and Kristine Dickinson, 140 Hickory Hill, Elma, NY, indicated that the proposed property
requesting a variance was self-created since Mr. Campbell had previously split off other property
which created a smaller than required lot. Mr. Campbell sold off property beginning in 2022 for
financial interest. The corner lot sold has significant problems with drainage. There have been
significant issues with stones and water crossing Hickory Hill Road turning onto Jamison Road.
In addition, on the off-shoot land there is a yard drain on that strip. Mark Dickinson indicated
that he believed that approval of this variance would change the character of the neighborhood
since this would be the third split in 3 years and would cause everyone to have further drainage
issues. The Dickinsons further stated that they approached the Campbells to purchase the land to
add to their existing property, but it did not occur. They moved in March, 2020.

Aidan Bain of 101 Hickory Hill, Elma, NY, indicated that he has resided in Elma for 27 years.
He indicated that there are stones in the street that he encounters going to work in Niagara Falls
and that this is posing a hazard. He indicates that this variance request is solely for profit and
asks that it be denied.
Richard and Cindy Marczewski, 40 Hickory Hill Road, Elma, NY, indicate that they own the
house on the corner of Hickory Hill and Jamison Road. They bought this property last year and
moved in March of 2026. They were told by the builder that the property seeking a variance
was not a buildable lot and nothing would ever be built on this property. Rose Campbell also
assured them that no one could build on the property. Based upon their assurances they were
happy to reside there for the rest of their lives.

Melissa McCaffery of 90 Hickory Hill Road, Elma, NY, indicated she was the other party who
offered to buy the land behind her property. The off-shoot property behind her house is full of
weeds, garbage, old wood where a ground hog lives, mosquitos and water. There are no pine
trees on her property. This land is lower than the lots which cause flooding and water to sit there.
She indicated that she has already paid $5,000 for drainage tiles. She indicates that this off
shoot area is “disgusting back there”.

Terry Kirby of 161 Hillside, Elma, NY, indicates that multiple properties have been sold and/or
have previously been approved but not yet built on. They have drainage issues presently but
with all of the future anticipated buildings it will be worse. He states that when he goes to East
Aurora, he can go 30 mph. Around his home the speed limit has been reduced to 25 mph, he
believes because of the drainage issues. He further states that the danger to wildlife is caused by
their loss of habitat and does not want any further development in the area.

Charles Mullen, 80 Hickory Hill Road, Elma, NY, showed the Board where the pines are, and the
other area only has scrub and sumac trees and brush.