Southtowns Record

PBA09.10.2026packet

Government
Town of West Seneca
Board
Planning Board
Meeting
Sep 10, 2026, 6:00 p.m.
Posted by publisher
Sep 4, 2026
Kind
Agenda packet
Topics
Water, sewer and drainage, Zoning and land use, Roads and traffic, Budget and taxes, Public safety, Parks and recreation

Original document

Same meeting

Text · page 6 of 84

o  Eric Sailor questioned about an entrance driveway leading directly into parking.
  o  Response: Widening, center turn lane, sidewalks, and new/upgraded signals, all
  paid by the developer.
  o Tim Hayes asked about the "surcharge" concept.
  ▪ Response: It refers to placing a weight of soil to consolidate subsurface
  soils, not related to stormwater or environmental issues.
  o Margaret Bebak asked about the status of the traffic study with NYSDOT.
  ▪ Response: The County is satisfied; awaiting DOT feedback on the latest
  version. A DOT work permit is required before off-site work can begin.
•  Public Comments:
  o Unnamed Resident: Concerned about existing traffic congestion and requested
  clarity on the traffic study's effectiveness.
  ▪ Response (Board/Engineer): The study is extensive and coordinated with
  Erie County/NYSDOT. The proposed improvements at every surrounding
  intersection are expected to address current issues.
  o Jeff Quain: 1) Recommended alignment with the town's comprehensive plan. 2)
  Asked for certainty on Costco as the tenant, citing a news article. 3) Requested
  communications with the West Seneca School District be made public to
  understand impacts, especially regarding planned work near an elementary
  school.
  o Evelyn Hicks (Seneca Creek Road): 1) Asked for clarification on "surcharge."
  2) Requested the Board delay voting to allow residents more time for review. 3)
  Asked about the integrity of the 40-50+ year old discharge pipe. 4) Asked about
  potential soil contamination from the former mall.
  o Peter Spilsbury (Fire Commissioner, West Seneca Fire District No. 5):
  Expressed strong support, citing benefits to the district's budget.
  o Joseph O’Donnell: Asked about traffic mitigation coverage, agency responses,
  legal prerequisites, and project phasing.
  o Mary Sherman (Caldwell Drive): Asked about improvements near the Route
  400/Seneca Street exit.
•  Motions:
  o Motion to close the public hearing.
  ▪ Motion by: Chairperson Margaret Bebak
  ▪ Seconded by: Joseph Sherman
  ▪ Ayes: All
  ▪ Noes: None
  ▪ Abstain: None
  ▪ Motion carried
  o Motion to approve the site plan for both the overall site and Costco.
  ▪ Recommendation: Approval subject to: 1) Completion of requirements in
  the letter from the Town Engineering Department; and 2) NYSDOT
  approval and issuance of the DOT work permit prior to off-site work.
  ▪ Motion by: Chairperson Margaret Bebak
  ▪ Seconded by: Joseph Sherman
  ▪ Ayes: All
  ▪ Noes: None

  Page 6 of 84