Southtowns Record

East Aurora Union Free School District - Procurement (2023M-125)

Government
East Aurora Union Free School District
Posted by publisher
Jan 5, 2024
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight

Publisher's summary

The Board of Education (Board) and District officials did not always procure goods and services in a competitive manner. Officials did not update the procurement policy or ensure that employees followed New York State General Municipal Law (GML) when procuring goods and services. As a result, goods and services were purchased without the benefit of competition, resulting in the increased risk that taxpayer dollars were not expended in the most prudent and economical manner.

Original document

Text · page 8 of 13

The Board and District officials did not outline in the procurement policy or
develop procedures indicating how they would procure professional services,
including whether they would request proposals or the timeline for how often
competition would be solicited. Although professional services are an exception  Although
for competitive bidding, seeking competition may be an opportunity to generate  professional
cost savings and ensure that the professional services meet the District’s needs.
  services
The Business Administrator and Director of Pupil Services, who is responsible for
procuring student services, told us that some vendors used for student services  are an
had to be used by the District because they were the only vendors available in  exception for
the area or that had availability for student placement. However, the Board did
not outline instances or situations, in the procurement policy or by resolution,  competitive
indicating when they would not use a competitive process to obtain professional
  bidding,
services.
  seeking
When officials do not seek competition for professional services in a timely
manner, they lack assurance that services are procured in the most economical  competition
way, in the best interest of taxpayers and without favoritism.
  may be an
What Do We Recommend?  opportunity
The Board should:  to generate
  1. Monitor or require the Business Administrator, as the purchasing agent, to  cost savings
  monitor compliance with GML bidding requirements.  and ensure
  2. Update the procurement policy and procedures, as required by GML, to  that the
  indicate when officials must seek competition and outline procedures for
  determining the competitive method that must be used for purchases not  professional
  subject to competitive bidding requirements.  services meet
  3. Monitor or designate the Business Administrator, as the purchasing agent,  the District’s
  to enforce and monitor compliance with the Board-adopted procurement
  policy.  needs.
The Business Administrator should:

  4. Ensure all purchase contracts over $20,000 are competitively bid as
  required by GML.

  5. Become familiar with the updated procurement policy and procedures, and
  ensure all employees obtain, document and retain the required number
  of quotes or other method of obtaining competitive pricing, as required by
  the procurement policy, for all goods and services purchased below the
  bidding threshold.

6  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller