Southtowns Record

Town of Hamburg - Finance Office (2023M-109)

Government
Town of Hamburg
Posted by publisher
Dec 8, 2023
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight

Publisher's summary

The Town Board (Board) and Town officials did not ensure that credit card purchases were supported and for proper Town purposes. The former Director of Finance (former Director) was arrested in September 2022 for charges relating to her use of the Town's credit card. She pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct in December 2022. Additionally, the Board and Town officials did not ensure Finance Office payroll was accurate and supported.

Original document

Text · page 5 of 16

l The former Director had a total of 11 restaurant charges totaling $1,251.
  Eight of these charges totaling $1,153 did not include itemized receipts
  …22 of
  listing what items were purchased, but rather included nonitemized receipts
  with the total amount charged. Some of the charges were documented  the former
  on the transaction log as meals for staff events, such as “supervisor/fire
  company meeting,” “midyear meeting,” “department meeting breakfast” and  Director’s
  “new year meeting.” However, because the Town did not have a policy for  purchases
  meal purchases at staff events, it was unclear whether these 11 charges
  were for a proper Town purpose.  totaling
  l Two hotel charges totaling $329 were documented on the transaction log  approximately
  as a “conference expense.” Although these transactions were made in May
  $1,200 were
  2019, the transaction log was completed and signed off on by the Assistant
  Accountant in October 2021, almost 2.5 years after the credit card statement  either delivered
  was paid, as the former Director had not completed and turned in the
  transaction logs for her credit card purchases.  to her home

Additionally, 22 of the former Director’s purchases totaling approximately $1,200
  address or
were either delivered to her home address or were in-person purchases. As such,  were in-person
we reviewed all of the former Director’s transactions and asked a remaining
current Finance Office employee to confirm the delivery of these purchases to  purchases.
the Town or existence of items purchased, and whether the purchases were used
for Town purposes. The employee was unable to confirm whether any of these
purchases were delivered to and/or used for Town purposes, including $470
of goods purchased from a retail store and $730 from an online vendor. These
purchases included:
  l Storage drawers and an organizer for $320,

  l Voice activated assistant with accessories for $259,

  l Area rugs for $97,

  l Office chair for $72,

  l Luggage cart for $30,

  l Tote bag for $15, and

  l Miscellaneous supplies that were for office or home use, such as batteries,
  stationary, pens and adhesive notepads, totaling $407.

Purchases By Other Employees – The remaining three Finance Office
employees had 1,160 credit card transactions totaling $386,238. Generally, these
transactions appeared to be for proper Town purposes, but 148 transactions
totaling $77,675 were not properly supported with documentation, such as
invoices or itemized receipts, or documented on the transaction log. Specifically,
99 transactions totaling $67,661 were for recurring contractual charges such
as Internet, telephone, alarm services, pump station services and newspaper

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  3