Southtowns Record

Town of Hamburg - Finance Office (2023M-109)

Government
Town of Hamburg
Posted by publisher
Dec 8, 2023
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight

Publisher's summary

The Town Board (Board) and Town officials did not ensure that credit card purchases were supported and for proper Town purposes. The former Director of Finance (former Director) was arrested in September 2022 for charges relating to her use of the Town's credit card. She pleaded guilty to disorderly conduct in December 2022. Additionally, the Board and Town officials did not ensure Finance Office payroll was accurate and supported.

Original document

Text · page 7 of 16

their transactions and certified that their purchases were supported and for proper
Town purposes without the oversight of another official.

We discussed the lack of oversight of the former Director’s credit card purchases
with the Board members and the current Supervisor and Director. The Supervisor
and Director told us they are working on drafting a credit card policy to address
the deficiencies identified. Two Board members who were on the Board when
the former Director made these credit card purchases told us that they were
part-time and they did not have time nor were they in a position to review every
credit card purchase or to audit every claim. These Board members told us that
they relied on the former Supervisor and Director for day-to-day operations,
and the individual Board members who were assigned liaison roles for selected
departments and audited that department’s claims and reported the results to
the Board. While the Board can assign certain duties to other Town officials, the
Board as a whole remains responsible for the general oversight of the Town’s
operations and finances, including the proper audit of claims.

Because unsupervised credit card use increases the potential for unauthorized
purchases, the Board should establish adequate written policies and monitor
and enforce compliance. Without a comprehensive policy enforced by the Board,
there is limited control over the use of credit cards and the Town could potentially
pay for unauthorized or excessive purchases and officials could have difficulty
recovering inappropriate or questionable charges.

What Do We Recommend?
The Board should:

  1. Adopt a written credit card policy that establishes procedures for
  documenting credit card purchases, authorizing credit card use, and
  reviewing, reconciling and approving credit card transactions.

  2. Perform a thorough audit and review of all claims, including credit card
  statements, and ensure credit card transactions are supported and for
  proper Town purposes prior to approving payment.

  3. Require that department head credit card purchases are reviewed and
  approved by an appropriate official, such as the Supervisor.

The Director should:

  4. Ensure all credit card purchases are documented on the transaction
  logs prior to payment, supported by itemized invoices or receipts and
  authorized and approved.

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  5