Southtowns Record

Holland Central School District – Claims Audit (2021M-210)

Government
Holland Central School District
Posted by publisher
Mar 4, 2022
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight, Water, sewer and drainage

Publisher's summary

The Board did not ensure that claims were adequately supported and properly audited before payment. In addition, the current claims auditor did not receive proper training to fulfill the Board's claims audit responsibilities. As a result, there is an increased risk that improper or unsupported payments could be made and not be detected and corrected.

Original document

Text · page 7 of 13

the following purchases lacked documentation of bids or quotes, or other
  evidence that officials complied with the procurement policy:
  ¡ Concrete bleacher pads totaling $30,000,

  ¡ Office furniture totaling $24,829,

  ¡ Fuel purchases totaling $21,552,

  ¡ Partial payment of a video surveillance system totaling $17,315, and

  ¡ Parking lot sealing totaling $15,075.

  l 13 claims totaling $59,956 did not contain sufficient itemization of goods or
  services received. Some examples included:
  ¡ One claim for a heating, ventilation and air conditioning vendor, for
  $28,500, included an invoice that did not list or describe the goods or
  services provided.
  ¡ One claim for occupational therapy and physical therapy services totaling
  $10,143 was not itemized with information such as the dates of services
  or how many students were provided services.
  ¡ One claim for a “refund for an iPad replacement,” totaling $514, did not
  have any documentation attached. Officials told us this was to refund a
  parent for an iPad the parent paid to replace, which was subsequently
  found and returned to the District. However, there was no documentation
  of the original payment or the purpose of the refund in the claim’s
  package.

The Business Official told us that because she reviewed and approved the claims
to be paid, she was aware that they were for appropriate District purposes and
that the appropriate bids and quotes were obtained. However, the documentation
for bids and quotes were retained by the District official who requested the
purchase and were not provided to the Business Official, accounts payable clerk
or claims auditor. If the claims auditor is not provided with sufficient supporting
documentation she cannot carry out the essential functions of her job, which
include determining whether claims are valid District expenditures and in
compliance with District policies such as the procurement policy. Further, when
claims are paid without adequate supporting documentation, there is an increased
risk the District could incur unnecessary costs or pay for goods and services that
were not actually received or were not for proper District purposes.

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  5