Southtowns Record

Town of Hamburg - Fuel Operations (2019M-75)

Government
Town of Hamburg
Posted by publisher
Jun 28, 2019
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight, Roads and traffic, Public safety

Publisher's summary

The Board did not adopt written policies and procedures for purchasing fuel from gas stations and monitoring fuel held in reserve tanks. In addition, the Superintendent did not properly monitor gas station fuel purchases or reserve tank inventories. Officials also did not adequately safeguard access to fuel. After removing active police and firefighters from the Town's authorized driver list, 267 individuals remained. We compared these names with a list of active employees and found that 148 individuals were not current employees. One individual listed was a consultant for the Town and authorized to purchase fuel for Town-related travel. The remaining 147 individuals should not have been on the list or have active PINs for fuel purchases. Although 75 of these individuals were former employees, the remaining 72 were not. The Highway Superintendent did not adequately review fuel transactions. Finally, Department officials did not maintain fuel logs or perpetual inventory records for the reserve tanks to track fuel delivered, used or remaining in the tanks.

Original document

Text · page 11 of 20

Read the whole document on one page (all 20 pages, each with its own heading)

Jeffery D. Mazula, Chief Examiner
295 Main Street, Suite 1032
Buffalo, NY 14203-2510
Tel: (716) 847-3647
Fax: (716) 847-3643
email: Muni-Buffalo@osc,ny.gov

HAMBURG HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT AUDIT RESPONSE LETTER / CAP
Unit Name: Town of Hamburg Highway Department
Audit Report Title: Town of Hamburg Fuel Operations Report of Examination
Audit Report Number: 2019M-75
Date: 06/14/19

RE: Hamburg Highway Department’s Acknowledgement and Corrective Action Plan for the State Comptrollers
Audit Report for the Town of Hamburg Fuel Operations Report of Examinations

Dear Mr. Mazula-

The following is the Hamburg Highway Department Audit Response Letter and CAP in response to the State of
New York Office of the State Comptroller Audit of Hamburg Highway Department Fuel Inventory Management.
The Hamburg Highway Department is in receipt of the draft Report of Examination (2019M-75) prepared by the
office of the State Comptroller.

On behalf of the Town of Hamburg Highway Department, I would like to thank the Auditor’s Office for the time
invested reviewing the Town of Hamburg Fuel Operations. The key findings of the audit and the resulting key
recommendations have provided concrete action items that will be implemented to improve our oversight of
this mission-critical commodity. I would also like to personally thank the principle examiner, the senior examiner
and the associate examiner for their professional and courteous demeanor throughout the audit process.

The Town of Hamburg Highway Department concurs with the audit findings and recommendations and we are
committed to implementing the OSC audit recommendations. As the Hamburg Highway Superintendent, I have
initiated an internal mandate to develop Department policies and procedures in response to the Town of Ham-
burg Fuel Operations Report of Examination audit. I see this as an opportunity to strengthen the current poli-
cies and procedures, to be more detailed regarding internal requirements for fuel operations reporting.

I agree that system controls can and should be improved to ensure that potential fraud or abuse related to
fuel consumption is identified and addressed. The Highway Department has taken pro-active steps to work to
identify and develop consistent, regular reporting policies and procedures after receiving the draft OSC report.
Highway Department reporting will be monitored on a scheduled basis to ensure potential issues are identified
and investigated. A specific area of focus will be odometer readings input by Highway Department fuel users
given that this data was revealed in your findings to be one of the key areas defined in the OSC report. This
will include collaboration with our support staff on implementing clearly defined responsibilities related to fuel
operations. I have detailed our CAP to these findings with the corrective actions that I have taken or proposed
presented below.

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  9