Southtowns Record

Zoning Board of Appeals minutes — September 15, 2026

Government
Town of Orchard Park
Board
Zoning Board of Appeals
Meeting
Sep 15, 2026
Posted by publisher
Oct 22, 2026
Kind
Minutes
Topics
Zoning and land use, Water, sewer and drainage, Short-term rentals

Original document

Motions and votes

Copied word for word from these minutes. Who moved and seconded, the tally and the roll call appear only where the minutes state them. Picked out automatically: the minutes themselves are the record. All votes for this government.

  1. Ms. Bowers made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Williams, to DENY the AREA VARIANCE, based on the fol- lowing: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. There will be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby prop- erties created. 3. The benefit sought can be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is substantial. ZBA Mtg. #08 Regular Mtg. #08 September 15, 2026 Page 3 5. There will be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neighborhood or district. 6. The difficulty is self-created. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING: METZ NAY…

    Carried, 2 opposed Not unanimous · Moved by Ms. Bowers, seconded by Mr. Williams

    Yes: BOWERS, RODO, WILLIAMS · No: METZ, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 2 of the minutes, motion 2 (full wording); vote on page 3, motion 2

  2. Mr. Williams made a MOTION, seconded by Ms. Bowers, to DENY the AREA VARIANCE, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. There will be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby prop- erties created. 3. The benefit sought can be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is substantial. 5. There will be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neighborhood or district. 6. The difficulty is self-created. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING: BOWERS AYE RODO AYE WILLIAMS AYE SZALKOWSKI AYE The MOTION was…

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Mr. Williams, seconded by Ms. Bowers

    Yes: BOWERS, RODO, WILLIAMS, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 4 of the minutes, motion 3 (full wording)

  3. Ms. Bowers made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski, to GRANT THE USE VARIANCE WITH STIPU- LATIONS, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. Strict application of the regulations will deprive the applicant of a reasonable return on the property, and the lack of return is substantial as demonstrated by competent financial evidence. 3. The hardship is unique and does not apply to a substantial portion of the district or neighborhood. 4. The variance will not alter the essential character of the neighborhood. 5. The alleged hardship was not self-created. 6. The property may not be rented, leased, sublet or used as an Airbnb. ZBA Mtg.…

    Carried, 2 opposed Not unanimous · Moved by Ms. Bowers, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski

    Yes: METZ, BOWERS, SZALKOWSKI · No: RODO, WILLIAMS

    Page 5 of the minutes, motion 4 (full wording); vote on page 6, motion 4

  4. Ms. Rodo made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski, to GRANT the AREA VARIANCE, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. There will not be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby properties created. 3. The benefit sought cannot be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is not substantial. 5. There will not be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neigh- borhood or district. 6. The difficulty is self-created, but this does not preclude the granting of the Variance. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING:…

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Ms. Rodo, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski

    Yes: RODO, WILLIAMS, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 6 of the minutes, motion 5 (full wording); vote on page 7, motion 5

  5. Mr. Szalkowski made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Williams, to GRANT the AREA VARIANCE, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. There will not be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby properties created. 3. The benefit sought cannot be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is not substantial. 5. There will not be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neigh- borhood or district. 6. The difficulty is not self-created. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING: METZ AYE BOWERS AYE RODO AYE WILLIAMS…

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Mr. Szalkowski, seconded by Mr. Williams

    Page 7 of the minutes, motion 6 (full wording); vote on page 8, motion 6

  6. Ms. Bowers made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski, to APPROVE the AREA VARIANCE with a STIPULATION, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. ZBA Mtg. #08 Regular Mtg. #08 September 15, 2026 Page 9 2. There will not be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby properties created. 3. The benefit sought cannot be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is not substantial. 5. There will not be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neigh- borhood or district. 6. The difficulty is self-created, but tha…

    Carried, 2 opposed Not unanimous · Moved by Ms. Bowers, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski

    Yes: METZ, BOWERS, SZALKOWSKI · No: RODO, WILLIAMS

    Page 8 of the minutes, motion 7 (full wording); vote on page 9, motion 7

  7. Mr. Williams made a MOTION, seconded by Ms. Bowers, to GRANT the AREA VARIANCE, based on the following: 1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed. 2. There will not be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby properties created. 3. The benefit sought cannot be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance. 4. The request is not substantial. 5. There will not be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neigh- borhood or district. 6. The difficulty is self-created, but this does not preclude the granting of the Variance. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING:…

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Mr. Williams, seconded by Ms. Bowers

    Yes: METZ, BOWERS, RODO, WILLIAMS, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 10 of the minutes, motion 9 (full wording)

3 routine motions (minutes, bills, agenda, adjournment…)
  1. A MOTION was duly made by Ms. Rodo and seconded by Mr. Szalkowski, to DISPENSE WITH THE READING OF and APPROVE THE MINUTES of the August 18, 2026 ZBA meeting. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING: METZ AYE BOWERS AYE RODO AYE WILLIAMS AYE SZALKOWSKI AYE The Minutes were UNANIMOUSLY approved.

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Ms. Rodo, seconded by Mr. Szalkowski

    Yes: METZ, BOWERS, RODO, WILLIAMS, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 1 of the minutes, motion 1

  2. Ms. Rodo made a MOTION, seconded by Mr. Williams, to ADJOURN THE MATTER WITH A STIPULATION THAT THE APPLICANT MAY CONTINUE THEIR BUSINESS UNTIL NEXT MEETING. THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING: METZ AYE BOWERS AYE RODO AYE ZBA Mtg. #08 Regular Mtg. #08 September 15, 2026 Page 10 WILLIAMS AYE SZALKOWSKI AYE The MOTION was UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.

    Carried unanimously · Moved by Ms. Rodo, seconded by Mr. Williams

    Yes: WILLIAMS, SZALKOWSKI

    Page 9 of the minutes, motion 8; vote on page 10, motion 8

  3. The meeting was adjourned at 9:15 P.M. DATED: 09/21/2026 Respectfully submitted, APPROVED: 10/20/2026 Kristin B. Mahoney, Recording Secretary

    Result not stated

    Page 10 of the minutes, motion 10

Text · page 4 of 10

Read the whole document on one page (all 10 pages, each with its own heading)

ZBA Mtg. #08  Regular Mtg. #08  September 15, 2026  Page 4

  (Two times) NO RESPONSE
  The Chair then asked if the Secretary had received any additional communication either for, or against, grant-
  ing the Variance.
  The Secretary stated she had not.
  The Chair closed the Public Hearing.
  The Board Members discussed the project and then closed the Board discussion.
  Mr. Williams made a MOTION, seconded by Ms. Bowers, to DENY the AREA VARIANCE, based on the following:
  1. Per Section 144-63 (E) (1) All public notices have been filed.
  2. There will be an undesirable change in the character of the neighborhood, or a detriment to nearby prop-
  erties created.
  3. The benefit sought can be achieved in another way, other than the granting of the Variance.
  4. The request is substantial.
  5. There will be an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions of the neighborhood
  or district.
  6. The difficulty is self-created.
  THE VOTE ON THE MOTION BEING:
  BOWERS  AYE
  RODO  AYE
  WILLIAMS  AYE
  SZALKOWSKI  AYE
  The MOTION was UNANIMOUSLY APPROVED.
3. ZBA File #23-26: Robert Eisenhauer, 6345 Powers Road, Zoned R-2, (Part of Farm Lot 12 & 20, Town-
  ship 10, Range 7, SBL # 184.16-1-2.2). Requests a Use Variance to convert an existing detached accessory
  building into a “carriage house” dwelling unit. This 2nd dwelling unit is not permitted in this R2/A1 zone.
  §144-9A, Schedule of Use Controls. Note: On 5/21/02 a Use Variance was granted allowing a commercial of-
  fice to operate from this building. ZBA #09-02.
  APPEARANCE: Holly & Robert Eisenhauer, Applicants
  The Applicants provided sketches and renderings to the Board.
  The Applicants stated that they seek to turn the original barn into a carriage house. Their property is nearly
  9 acres with a nearly 120 year old farmhouse which has been renovated over the years. Their son and his
  fiancé will live in the carriage house.
  Ms. Rodo explained that this request is for a Use Variance. As such, questions in regard to financial impacts
  must be addressed. What is the financial impact if the Variance is not granted?
  The Applicant stated that should the building be used solely for storage, the costs to fix it would be prohibi-
  tive, and no return would be generated.
  There were Board questions in regard to what would happen if the son moved out of the property.
  Ms. Seibold stated that any Variance granted will run with the land. However, a restriction that the carriage
  house will not be rented or used as an Airbnb may be placed on it.
  The Applicants stated that they do not want anyone living there besides family. If their son left, they would
  keep it as in-law quarters.
  Mr. Szalkowski noted that the project will allow the homeowners to maximize the value of their property.
  The Chair stated that a Use Variance is a higher level variance, and therefore, the Board needs to ask some
  pointed questions. He questioned the Applicants about the acquisition cost, holding and operating costs, and
  mortgage on the property, as well as income possible from permitted uses and comparative return rates.
  The Chair thanked the Applicants for their cooperation in answering the questions.