Text · page 2 of 19
Read the whole document on one page (all 19 pages, each with its own heading)
This document was a scan. Its text was produced by character recognition and may contain errors; check the original for exact wording.
Attached is an analysis of the actions taken by council on October 5, 2026. An additional report and guidance will follow. At this time, | believe it is feasible for the Council to comply with the public hearing requirement and to properly enact a local law implementing the RPTL 458-a(11) before the December 1st status date. My report will address the timeline for each step CHRISTY COOPER, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY RE. Council Action 10/5/26 item #4 motion for adoption of RPTL §458-a(11) Dear Council President Marrano, Honorable City Council; | have reviewed the action of the City Council taken on 10/5/26 with respect to the motion Councilperson Muflahi and the adoption of the Real Property Tax Law (RPTL) Section 458-a(11). It is in the position of the Law Department that the action is ineffect ive to implement the Veterans’ Alternative Exemption of RPTL §458-a(11) and that a local law, with public hearing, is required to modify the current tax exemption and expand the City’s Veterans’ Tax Exemption. ANALYSIS: The prior Veterans’ Exemption, codified under City Code Chapter 201 was adopted by local law. A local law is therefore required to amend the prior local iaw and expand the City’s application of RPTL §458-a(11) from only those prior provisions enumerated to the prior provisions plus section 11. (see 1982 Op. State Comp. No. 82-35, 1984 Op. State Comp. No.84-2 6 and 1998 Op. State Comp. No, 98-22), As the Council is aware, RPTL §458-a(11) may be adopted at local-op tion by, “local law or resolution.” (See RPTL 458 a(11)) Councilperson Muflahi “moved” to adopt the tax exemption. The language recorded by the City Clerk was as follows, "I move that the City of Lackawanna adopt the full real property tax exemption authorized under New York Real Property Tax Law §458-a(12) for qualifying permanently and totally service-disabled veterans." (See Cert Packet 10.5.26) State law does not define a “motion” but in practical terms, a motion is less formal than a resoluti on. (NYCOM Handbook for City Officials (Dec. 2025) Ch. 5). The action also does not satisfy the requirements of a local law. The City Charter directs that, “all local laws shail be introduced, considered and enacted in accordan ce with the procedure prescribed in the Municipal Home Rule Law. Notice of a public hearing on local laws shall be given by publication once in the official newspaper at least five days prior to such hearing.” (Lackawanna City Charter Ch. 3 §3.10(B)). In addition to the form prescribed by the City Charter §3.9, MHR §20(4) requires that a local law be in its final form and distributed to council members, if by email, for a period of no less that 10 days exclusive of Sundays. The local law must be in its final form before a public hearing. (Op. Atty. Gen. No. 78-243, Op, State Comp. No 81-124) The text was not distribu ted in a form or fashion to satisfy this requirement. Since the Council’s actions do not satisfy the requirements for a local law or a resolution, the action is Ineffective to implement the section of law. POTENTIAL REMEDY: A draft text of the law will be submitted for council’s review along with the documentation previously requested from Assessor Michael Milks, as soon as possible but no later that the deadline for agenda