Text · page 10 of 11
Read the whole document on one page (all 11 pages, each with its own heading)
Area variance balancing test: 1. Neighborhood character or detriment to nearby properties: No. Do not anticipate an undesirable change and said the project could improve the property. 2. Feasible alternatives: The board member did not identify a viable alternative. 3. Substantiality: The variance was considered not substantial. 4. Physical or environmental effects: The impact was described as minimal; the project could be an improvement. 5. Self-created difficulty: A member remarked that such difficulties are often self-created but said this would not affect the vote. Motioned by: Bedient Seconded by: Lang for approval. Vote: Ayes: 5, Noes: 0. The motion carried. Application 2026-051 -1100 Southwestern Boulevard- Applicant Representative: Corey Hourback (Barclay Damon) Request / Appeal Summary: o Appeal of an administrative interpretation/determination by Code Enforcement regarding a proposed adult-use retail cannabis dispensary in the C-1 zoning district. o Applicant's counsel raised a two-part appeal: 1. Town Chapter 59 proximity/dimensional requirements are preempted by New York State Cannabis Law and state regulations governing time, place, and manner. 2. Alternatively, if local special-use standards apply, relief from proximity/dimensional requirements must be classified and heard as an Area Variance (citing Real Holdings and Town Law § 274-b(3)) rather than a Use Variance, allowing the applicant to proceed to a special use permit application. o Discussion ensued between Applicant's counsel, Town Counsel Joseph Trapp, Code Enforcement, and Board members regarding communication timelines (May 18/19 emails, August 26 Town Attorney letter, October 9 appeal filing), the existence of a formal stamped determination, FOIL requests, and the ZBA's jurisdiction regarding statutory preemption versus variance classification. o County Planning returned a letter classifying the matter as local concern. NYS DOT indicated no current opinion, requesting updates on final property use. Balancing Test Framework for Future Variance Review: o AREA Variance Balancing Test (5 Questions) if classified as Area Variance: