Southtowns Record

Eden Central School District – Capital Project Management (2024M-83)

Government
Eden Central School District
Posted by publisher
Oct 4, 2024
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight, Budget and taxes, Roads and traffic

Publisher's summary

Determine whether the Eden Central School District (District) Board of Education (Board) and District officials provided sufficient oversight of and managed the District’s 2022 capital project (project) in a transparent manner.

Original document

Text · page 11 of 17

Because District officials did not request proposals for professional services, they may have paid more
than necessary. Also, officials cannot provide assurance to taxpayers that they acquired these services
without favoritism.

What Do We Recommend?
The Board should:

  1. Present future capital project plans in a more transparent manner and provide voters with
  detailed descriptions of the improvements to be made, including alternate “wish list” items.

  2. Actively monitor District projects, including reviewing and approving all change orders. Also, the
  Board should include all relevant project information in its meeting minutes.

  3. Update the purchasing policy and procedures to clearly state the dollar threshold for using an
  RFP process for professional services, who is responsible for requesting proposals, how many
  proposals should be obtained, what selection process should be used and how RFP actions
  should be documented.

The Board President should:

  4.  Approve all change orders in accordance with SED requirements.

The Board and District officials should:

  5. Comply with the District’s purchasing policy and statutory requirements by carefully evaluating
  change orders, to help ensure similar work is appropriately aggregated, and by determining
  when officials should obtain bids for contracts or competitive quotes for purchases.

  6. Send change order certifications to SED in a timely manner and ensure the certifications contain
  all required approvals.

  7. Consider following SED’s best practice guidance and contact SED to discuss change orders
  before completing the work.

  8. Comply with the District’s purchasing policy by obtaining and retaining documentation when
  using RFPs for professional services.

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  9