Southtowns Record

Town of West Seneca - Capital Project Management (2019M-195)

Government
Town of West Seneca
Posted by publisher
Mar 6, 2020
Kind
State audit
Topics
Budget and taxes, Audits and oversight, Parks and recreation

Publisher's summary

The Board did not properly plan and manage the capital project and clearly inform taxpayers when the estimated cost and scope of the project changed. In addition, the Board was not fully transparent on the anticipated project costs. As a result, original estimates were $9.8 million and increased by more than $3.6 million after competitive bids were received. When inaccurate costs are included in project estimates, there is an increased risk that the Board may issue more debt than necessary to finance the project because funding is available to pay for costs that were not within the original project scope. Finally, Town officials did not ensure an itemized project budget outlining revenues and expenditures was maintained in the accounting records and periodically updated.

Original document

Text · page 3 of 14

Report Highlights
 Town of West Seneca

Audit Objective
  Background
Determine whether the Town properly planned and
managed a capital project.  The Town of West Seneca
  (Town) is located in Erie County.
Key Findings  The Town is governed by an
  elected Town Board (Board)
The Board:  composed of a Supervisor and
  four Board members. The Board
  ll Did not properly plan and manage the capital project
  is responsible for the general
  and clearly inform taxpayers when the estimated cost
  management and oversight of the
  and scope of the project changed.
  Town’s financial operations. The
  ll Was not fully transparent on the anticipated project  Supervisor serves as the chief
  costs. As a result, original estimates were $9.8  fiscal officer.
  million and increased by more than $3.6 million after
  competitive bids were received.  In September 2016, the Board
  accepted an engineering and
Town officials did not:  architectural proposal for library
  ll Ensure an itemized project budget outlining revenues
  renovation and construction of
  and expenditures was maintained in the accounting  a community center and Town
  records and periodically updated.  offices. The project was completed
  in June 2018.

Key Recommendations  Quick Facts
  ll Prepare realistic estimates and ensure the project
  Population  44,700
  costs are clearly defined.
  Initial Estimated Project
  ll Prepare and approve an itemized budget, and amend  $9.8 million
  Cost
  and update the budget as the project changes.
  Final Project Cost  $13.5 million
Town officials agreed with our recommendations and
indicated they planned to take corrective action.  Debt Issued  $10.3 million

  Audit Period
  January 1, 2012 – July 31, 2019

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  1