Southtowns Record

Town of West Seneca - Capital Project Management (2019M-195)

Government
Town of West Seneca
Posted by publisher
Mar 6, 2020
Kind
State audit
Topics
Budget and taxes, Audits and oversight, Parks and recreation

Publisher's summary

The Board did not properly plan and manage the capital project and clearly inform taxpayers when the estimated cost and scope of the project changed. In addition, the Board was not fully transparent on the anticipated project costs. As a result, original estimates were $9.8 million and increased by more than $3.6 million after competitive bids were received. When inaccurate costs are included in project estimates, there is an increased risk that the Board may issue more debt than necessary to finance the project because funding is available to pay for costs that were not within the original project scope. Finally, Town officials did not ensure an itemized project budget outlining revenues and expenditures was maintained in the accounting records and periodically updated.

Original document

Text · page 4 of 14

Capital Project Management
How Should a Board Plan, Authorize and Monitor a Capital Project?
A governing board is responsible for the oversight and management of capital
projects, including ensuring that projects are properly planned and managed,
funding is authorized and costs are kept within the approved budget. The
board and town officials should monitor progress and implement necessary
changes to ensure the project is completed in the most cost-effective manner.1
Proper planning of a capital project requires that the board have a thorough
understanding of the project’s overall scope and estimated cost before authorizing
the project. Initial estimated costs must be realistic so a board can plan financing
and keep the taxpayers informed.

When financing a project with debt, a board must adopt a bond resolution at
the project’s inception that includes, among other things, a statement of specific
objects or purposes or class of objects or purposes for which the obligations to
be authorized by the resolution are to be issued and a statement of the estimated
maximum cost and a plan of financing of the total cost. In lieu of this statement,
the resolution may specify that such information has been set forth in a capital
budget or in an appropriation for such specific or class of objects or purposes
or in a previously adopted bond resolution. After adoption of a capital budget,
the supervisor is responsible for properly recording the project budget and
subsequent financial activities.

The board should ensure that any changes to the project plan are within the
project scope or premise of the initial proposal and update the corresponding
budget. The board should ensure that all its actions and proceedings are
documented in official records to ensure transparency to taxpayers. The board
should monitor the status of the project by reviewing monthly financial reports that
compare actual revenues and expenditures to the related budget.

The Board Was Not Fully Transparent About the Project Scope and
Budget
The Board began planning a repair and maintenance project for the library in
2012, which expanded to a plan to construct a community center. According to
the September 24, 2012 Board minutes, the Board requested the Town engineer2
to prepare architectural drawings and plans for the library as part of the overall
concept plans for the site.

In July 2014, the Board and engineer presented a plan to renovate the existing
library and include a 10,000 square foot addition. The Board minutes indicated

1 Refer to our publication Capital Projects Fund available at www.osc.state.ny.us/localgov/pubs/lgmg/capital-
projects-fund.pdf

2 The Town hired an outside engineer to serve as Town engineer.

2  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller