Southtowns Record

Town of Hamburg - Fuel Operations (2019M-75)

Government
Town of Hamburg
Posted by publisher
Jun 28, 2019
Kind
State audit
Topics
Audits and oversight, Roads and traffic, Public safety

Publisher's summary

The Board did not adopt written policies and procedures for purchasing fuel from gas stations and monitoring fuel held in reserve tanks. In addition, the Superintendent did not properly monitor gas station fuel purchases or reserve tank inventories. Officials also did not adequately safeguard access to fuel. After removing active police and firefighters from the Town's authorized driver list, 267 individuals remained. We compared these names with a list of active employees and found that 148 individuals were not current employees. One individual listed was a consultant for the Town and authorized to purchase fuel for Town-related travel. The remaining 147 individuals should not have been on the list or have active PINs for fuel purchases. Although 75 of these individuals were former employees, the remaining 72 were not. The Highway Superintendent did not adequately review fuel transactions. Finally, Department officials did not maintain fuel logs or perpetual inventory records for the reserve tanks to track fuel delivered, used or remaining in the tanks.

Original document

Text · page 7 of 20

Department Officials Did Not Adequately Safeguard Fuel Inventory
Department officials had limited safeguards in place to provide assurance the
fuel maintained in the reserve tanks was properly safeguarded and used for
appropriate purposes. The diesel tank located at Woodlawn Beach State Park
was unsecured and did not have a fuel gauge. The two tanks located at the golf
course were secured by a locked gate; however, the tanks are located in the
middle of a public parking lot and the gate is left open when the course is open to
the public. The ice arena and highway department both have a switch to turn on
the fuel pumps, which are located inside of a locked building to which only certain
employees (typically foremen) have access.

Department officials did not maintain fuel logs or perpetual inventory records for
the reserve tanks to track fuel delivered, used or remaining in the tanks. Officials
also did not monitor or take pump readings after fuel was delivered or periodically
measure and record reserve tank fuel levels to provide assurance the Town is
accurately billed for the amount of fuel received.

Officials told us that they maintained fuel logs in the past, but they did not review
the logs or perform any reconciliations and decided to eliminate them. However,
by not maintaining inventory records for fuel purchases and use, there is an
increased risk that fuel could be stolen or used for inappropriate purposes.

What Do We Recommend?
The Board should:

  1. Develop and adopt written policies and procedures for the proper
  accounting and safeguarding of fuel purchases and inventories.

The Superintendent and Director should:

  2. Immediately deactivate PINs assigned to all individuals who should not
  have access to purchase fuel.

  3. Notify the Supervisor’s secretary of any individuals who leave Town
  employment or who no longer need fuel access, so that PINs may be
  deactivated in a timely manner.

  4. Periodically review the authorized driver list to ensure it is accurate and
  up-to-date.

  5. Regularly monitor monthly reports and investigate significant
  discrepancies.

  6. Track fuel purchases made with equipment fobs to document the
  equipment or project for which fuel was purchased.

  Of f ic e of t he New York State Comptroller  5