Text · page 5 of 83
Read the whole document on one page (all 83 pages, each with its own heading)
National Grid Site Plan and Public Utility Use Variance Application August 14, 2026 Page 3 Application of the Public Utility Variance Standard and Zoning Board Review New York State Case Law Under New York State Town Law § 267-b, a four-part test is generally applied to use variance applications for most commercial uses. However, as this ZBA may be aware, this test has been adapted for public utility uses that meet a public need, such as electrical generation facilities, allowing the expansion of these essential services. The New York State Court of Appeals has recognized that certain uses are so fundamental and location specific that they cannot be subject to local zoning restrictions. This recognition established the Public Utility Variance Standard (“PUV Standard”) for public utility uses. The PUV Standard requires an applicant providing an “essential service,” to demonstrate: (1) the relief is “a public necessity in that it is required to render safe and adequate service,” and (2) there are “compelling reasons, economic or otherwise,” that make it more feasible to seek that variance than to seek alternative locations. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York v Hoffman, 43 NY2d 598, 611 (1978) (concerning nuclear power). Notably, the Court also emphasized that “where the intrusion or burden on the community is minimal, the showing required by the utility should be correspondingly reduced.” Id. As public need required more essential services, the Court of Appeals confirmed that the PUV standard “applies to entirely new siting of facilities.” Cellular Tel. Co. v. Rosenberg, 82 NY2d 364, 372 (1993) (concerning telecommunications tower). It is also well established that the PUV standard applies to private companies who help meet a public need. See id. at 371; see also Site Acquisitions, Inc. v Town of New Scotland, 2 AD3d 1135, 1136-1137 (2003) (“Since Site, Cingular and Independent are wireless phone service providers they are each treated as a public utility for zoning purposes and, thus, the general principles governing variances sought by private individuals or entities do not govern their application.”). Undeniably, “electricity is an essential service.” Patricia E. Salkin and Robert Burgdorf, Siting Wind Farms in New York: Applicability of the Relaxed Public Utility Standard, New York Zoning Law and Practice Report vol. 7, No. 1. National Grid provides an essential service in the form of electricity; therefore, the marshalling yard, which is part of the provision of public utility, electric service and National Grid’s variance is subject to review under the PUV Standard. Property Site Selection “There is no legal requirement that [an applicant] analyze each and every possible parcel of land before obtaining a variance; such a requirement would be unworkable.” Matter of Freepoint Solar LLC v Town of Athens Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 234 AD3d 127, 134 (3d Dept 2024), quoting Horvath Communications, Inc. v Town of Lockport Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 2018 NY Slip