Text · page 6 of 83
Read the whole document on one page (all 83 pages, each with its own heading)
National Grid Site Plan and Public Utility Use Variance Application August 14, 2026 Page 4 Op 33830[U] at *5 (Niagara County Supreme 2018). The Property was carefully selected based on its proximity to existing National Grid infrastructure, including major electric transmission lines and electrical substations, as well as consideration of site topography, site shape/size, slopes, vegetation, wetlands, forested areas, proximity to threatened or endangered species, adjacent uses, and site history—including history as a marshalling yard aiding in provision of National Grid’s essential service. Proximity to electrical infrastructure is paramount. National Grid is required to provide safe and reliable electric service in New York. This mandate spurred National Grid to originally use the Property as a marshalling yard as part of its GD 141/142 project. See Exhibit 7. Prior approval by the PSC in the Article VII process indicates this location is strategic and beneficial to National Grid’s essential mission. Having a permanent marshalling yard allows National Grid to adequately service many Western New York lines and upgrade aging infrastructure. In the coming years, staging at this marshalling yard will allow National Grid to commence needed upgrades on at least 33 projects within a 15-mile radius of the Property. See Exhibit 5. Given the location adjacent to the thruway on and off ramps, National can use the marshalling yard for more than just the infrastructure and projects identified within the 15-mile radius. The Property under the PUV Standard For entitlement to a use variance under the PUV standard, an applicant must demonstrate that the facility provides an essential service, and the variance relief permitting the essential service is required in order to provide safe and adequate service. Further, the applicant must show that there are compelling reasons, economic or otherwise, that make it more feasible to seek the variance than to use alternative locations. Notably, when the community intrusion is minimal, the burden by the applicant should be correspondingly reduced. Applying the PUV Standard, the electricity that the marshalling yard helps become a reality is an essential service. However, the Zoning Law of the Town (“Zoning Law”) prohibits the essential service at the Property. Therefore, the relief of the use variance is: (1) a “public necessity” because absent the use variance, the cannot “render safe and adequate [electrical] service” as it is prohibited under the Zoning Law at the Property. Absent the ability to manage its dynamic flow of project materials from a reliable and strategic location, National Grid will not have the ability to consistently, safely, and conveniently upgrade or maintain its facilities; and (2) there are “compelling reasons” that make it more feasible to seek this use variance than to seek alternate locations. Such compelling reasons include: a. The Marshalling Yard is necessary. National Grid serves the majority of Western New York. To serve this large geographic region, National Grid requires strategically placed marshaling yards that house necessary electrical